The population living along the riverbanks of the Amazon basin depends heavily on fish for nutritional support. Mono-methyl-mercury (MMHg) concentrates in fish, which can contaminate humans, the risk depending not only on fish MMHg concentration but also on the amount of fish consumed. We sampled nine locations of the Rio Negro basin, differing in water pH, Hg concentrations, and dissolved organic carbon (DOC), and determined total Hg from 951 fish samples of species representative of the food web: herbivorous, detritivorous, omnivorous, and piscivorous. Mercury concentrations varied widely in all species but showed a trend that depended on fish feeding strategies. The highest mean concentration was found in the piscivorous species (688.90 ng/g(-1)), followed by omnivorous (190.30 ng/g(-1)), detritivorous (136.04 ng/g(-1)), and herbivorous (70.39 ng/g(-1)). Fish Hg concentrations exceeding current safe limits (500 ng/g(-1)) for human consumption were found mainly in the piscivorous species (60%). Significant positive correlation between fish weight and Hg concentration was seen for the piscivorous Serrasalmus spp. (n = 326; r = 0.3977; p < 0.0001), Cichla spp. (n = 125; r = 0.4600; p < 0.0001), and Pimelodus spp. (n = 12; r = 0.8299; p = 0.0008), known locally as Piranha, Tucunaré, and Mandi, respectively. However, a negative correlation was seen for non-piscivorous Potamorhina latior (n = 30; r -0.3763; p = 0.0404) and Leporinus spp. (n = 44; r = -3987; p = 0.0073), known as Branquinha (detritivorous) and Aracu (omnivorous). Fish-Hg concentrations in the acidic waters (pH range, 4.09-6.31) of the Rio Negro habitat, with its wide gradient of Hg concentrations (3.4-11.9 microg/L(-1)) and DOC (1.85-15.3 mg/L(-1))--but no history of gold mining activity-are comparable to other Amazonian rivers. Opportunity fish catches in the Rio Negro habitat show high muscle-Hg derived from natural sources, but no systematic association with site-dependent geochemistry.
This work puts the risks and benefits of a mercury acquisition through a fish-dominated diet in the context of the other endemic health problems in the Amazon. Fish consumption rate was assessed after determining mercury concentrations in the most consumed fish and in hair of women at fertile age (15 to 45 years of age), living in remote localities of the Rio Negro basin (not impacted by gold mining). Fish-meals were consumed once a day (7.1%) but in most cases (78.6 %) at least twice a day with an estimated mean fish consumption rate of 170.5 g (range 23 to 293 g). The fish-species most preferred were Tucunarés (Cichla spp), Pacus (Mylossoma aureum and Myleus micans), Piranhas (Sarrasalmus spp), Cará (Satanoperca jurupari), Jaraquí (Semaprochilodus taeniurus). The mean Hg concentration in these species varies widely (38 to 592 ng g(- 1)) but 27% of samples had Hg concentrations above 500 ng g(- 1), and only 7% were above 1000 ng g(- 1). The hair-Hg concentrations ranged from 6.5 to 32.6 microg g(- 1) with 82% of them having concentrations above 10 microg g(- 1) (w.w.) hair. Hair-Hg concentrations were positively correlated with women's age (r=0.4500; P=0.0111). Clinical evaluation did not detected symptoms (paraparesis, tremor, numbness of limbs, sensory disturbances) compatible with Minamata disease, but there was a high (71%) incidence of clinical history of malaria. Fish is an abundant natural resource, rich in essential nutrients and important to the diet of 'ribeirinhos' of Brazilian Amazonia. We hypothesize that lack of basic medical care in these communities outweighs risk of naturally occurring fish-MMHg. Therefore food habits based on fish consumption is part of a successful strategy for survival and should be considered as a health asset.
Human mercury contamination can be monitored through hair analysis of mercury's inorganic and organic form as methylmercury (Me-Hg). Hair total mercury and Me-Hg were studied in a Negro River fish-eating population in relation to age, gender, and body mass index (BMI). This riverbank population eats fish at least twice a day and is exposed to high levels of Me-Hg. Total mercury ranged from 1.51 microg/g to 59.01 microg/g, with only 21% of the sampled population having Hg concentration of less than 10 microg/g hair. The mean percentage of Me-Hg was 71.3% (range 34% to 100%) of the total mercury in hair. No statistically significant differences were found in regard to age groups (children and adults) or BMI. However, women had significantly lower total mercury in hair than men, but the percentage of Me-Hg was not significantly different. Women in fertile age (15-40 years) had hair total mercury ranging from 1.65-32.63 microg/g, and 65% in this subgroup had hair mercury above 10 microg/g hair. The percentage of Me-Hg concentration in hair of this freshwater, fish-eating population is comparable to populations eating ocean fish from different parts of the world and does not seem to be affected by age, gender, and BMI.
Exposure to intrinsic Hg in fish was studied in Amazon populations with high prevalence of malaria disease. High fish-eater riverines were compared to urban (Manaus residents) low fish-eater riverines in regards to Hg exposure (hair-Hg) and serum antinuclear antibodies (ANA). Most riverines (99.0%) ate fish daily compared to only 3% of controls. Fish species high in MeHg was consumed more frequently (45.5%) by riverines than controls (18.8%). Mean hair-Hg (34.5 ppm) of riverines was significantly higher than controls (1.0 ppm). Although positive serum ANA was more frequently observed in riverine fish-eaters (12.4%) than controls (2.9%), there was no significant association between hair-Hg and ANA. High prevalence of malaria reporting among riverines was neither associated with Hg exposure nor with serum ANA. An autoimmune dysfunction is unlikely to occur as a result of MMHg exposure due to fish consumption.
Fish are abundant and important dietary items for the Amer-Indians, and total hair-Hg (HHg) concentration is a reliable marker of fish consumption. We studied the impact of fish consumption (HHg) on the nutritional status of Indian children of Eastern Amazonia. Weight-for-height Z score (WHZ) was measured, and HHg was determined in 203 children younger than 10 years of age in three villages. There was significantly higher fish consumption in Kayabi children (16.55 microg Hg/g; SD, 11.44) than in children of the Munduruku villages of Missão-Cururu (4.76 microg Hg/g; SD, 2.09) and Kaburua (2.87 microg Hg/g; SD, 2.13). Anthropometric indices showed WHZ means of -0.27, -0.22, and 0.40, respectively, for Kayabi, Missão-Cururu and Kaburua villages. Despite a different pattern of fish-protein consumption between tribes, there was no significant correlation between WHZ and HHg concentrations (r2 = 0.0079; P < 0.2021). Dietary differences among Amazonian tribes can be traced and used in measuring health outcomes. Higher fish consumption, although important for Kayabis, was compensated by other protein sources by the Kaburua villagers.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.