The flow-independent (intrinsic) tensile modulus of the extracellular matrix of human knee joint cartilage has been measured for normal, fibrillated, and osteoarthritic (removed from total knee joint replacements) cartilage. The modulus was determined in our isometric tensile apparatus and measured at equilibrium. We found a linear equilibrium stress-strain behavior up to approximately 15% strain. The modulus was measured for tissues from the high and low weight-bearing areas of the joint surfaces, the medial femoral condyle and lateral patello femoral groove, and from different zones (surface, subsurface, middle, and middle-deep) within the tissue. For all specimens, the intrinsic tensile modulus was always less than 30 MPa. Tissues from low weight-bearing areas (LWA) are stiffer than those from high weight-bearing areas (HWA). The tensile modulus of the ECM correlates strongly with the collagen/proteoglycan ratio; it is higher for LWA than for HWA. Osteoarthritic cartilage from total knee replacement procedures has a tensile stiffness less than 2 MPa.

The compressive, tensile, and swelling properties of articular cartilage were studied at two time periods following transection of the anterior cruciate ligament in the knee of greyhound dogs. An experimental protocol was designed to quantify the essential equilibrium and biphasic material properties of cartilage in tension, compression, and shear, as well as the parameters of isometric swelling behavior. All properties were measured at several sites to elicit differences between sites of frequent and less frequent contact. Hydration was determined at each site and was compared with the material properties of cartilage from corresponding sites. There were extensive changes in all compressive, tensile, and swelling properties of cartilage after transection of the anterior cruciate ligament. Twelve weeks after surgery, the intrinsic moduli were reduced significantly in compression (approximately 24% of control values), tension (approximately 64%), and shear (approximately 24%), and the hydraulic permeability was elevated significantly (approximately 48%). Significant increases in hydration (approximately 9%) also were observed, as well as a strong correlation of hydration with hydraulic permeability. The pattern of these changes was not found to differ with site in the joint, but significant differences were observed in the magnitude of change for cartilage from the femoral groove and the femoral condyle. The pattern and extent of changes in the material properties following transection of the anterior cruciate ligament indicate that altered loading of the joint severely compromises the overall mechanical behavior of articular cartilage. The observed loss of matrix stiffness in compression, tension, and shear is associated with increases in the deformation of the solid matrix, a diminished ability to resist swelling, and the increase in hydration observed in this study. The increased swelling and elevated water content were related directly to the increase in hydraulic permeability; this suggests an associated loss of fluid pressurization as the load support mechanism in the degenerated cartilage. Without a successful mechanism for repair, damage to the solid matrix may progress and lead to further degenerative changes in the biochemistry, morphology, and mechanical behavior of articular cartilage.

No abstract

The mechanical behavior and biochemical composition of articular cartilage were studied in an experimental model of joint disuse, in which the canine knee was immobilized in a sling at 90 degrees of flexion. Articular cartilage from the surface zone of the femur was tested in an isometric tensile test and full-thickness cartilage on the tibial plateau was tested in a compressive indentation test. Water, proteoglycan and collagen contents were measured in site-matched samples. Site-specific increases in the tensile moduli (approximately 88% above control values in distal femoral groove) were observed in cartilage after 8 weeks of joint disuse, and after 3 weeks of remobilization following either 4 (approximately 140%, distal and proximal femoral groove) or 8 weeks (approximately 140%, distal femoral groove) of joint disuse. In contrast, the compressive properties of cartilage determined in the indentation test exhibited no change from control values with joint disuse or disuse followed by remobilization. Water contents increased at some sites on the tibia after 8 weeks of joint disuse (approximately 6% of tissue wet weight, posterior site), but not in the surface zone tissue of the femur. Proteoglycan/collagen and cartilage thickness were not found to change with disuse or disuse followed by remobilization. Reduced values for the ratio of proteoglycan:water were observed in the surface zone tissue of the femur (approximately 23%, distal femoral groove) and in the full-thickness tissue of the tibia (approximately 21%, anterior and posterior sites) after periods of joint disuse. In this study, the measured material properties suggest that the articular surface remains intact following periods of disuse or disuse with remobilization. This finding suggests one important difference between this model of joint disuse and other experimental models in which cartilage changes are both progressive and degenerative, such as surgically-induced joint instability.