Substance use disorder is a behavioral disorder characterized by volitional drug consumption, compulsive behavior, drug seeking, and relapse. Mouse models of substance use disorder allow for the use of molecular, genetic, and circuit level tools, which provide enormous potential for defining the underlying mechanisms of this disorder. However, the relevance of results depends entirely on the validity of the mouse models used. Self-administration models have long been considered the gold standard of preclinical addiction models, as they allow for volitional drug use, this providing strong face validity. In a series of experiments, we show that traditional mouse models of self-administration, where behavior is maintained on a fixed-ratio one schedule of reinforcement, show similar levels of responding in the presence and absence of drug delivery -demonstrating that it is impossible to determine when intake is and is not volitional. Further, when assessing inclusion criteria, we find a sex-bias in exclusion criteria where females that acquired food self-administration were eliminated when traditional criteria were applied. To address these issues, we have developed a novel mouse self-administration procedure where animals do not need to be pre-trained on food and behavior is maintained on a variable ratio schedule of reinforcement. This procedure increases rates of reinforcement behavior, increases levels of drug intake, and eliminates sex bias in inclusion criteria. Together, these data highlight a major issue with fixed-ratio models in mice that complicates subsequent analysis and provide a simple and novel approach to minimize these confounds with escalating variable-ratio schedules of reinforcement.