Sequence-specific protein-DNA interactions are at the heart of the response of the tumor-suppressor p53 to numerous physiological and stress-related signals. Large variability has been previously reported in p53 binding to and transactivating from p53 response elements (REs) due, at least in part, to changes in direct (base) and indirect (shape) readouts of p53 REs. Here, we dissect p53 REs to decipher the mechanism by which p53 optimizes this highly regulated variable level of interaction with its DNA binding sites. We show that hemi-specific binding is more prevalent in p53 REs than previously envisioned. We reveal that sequences flanking the REs modulate p53 binding and activity and show that these effects extend to 4–5 bp from the REs. Moreover, we show here that the arrangement of p53 half-sites within its REs, relative to transcription direction, has been fine-tuned by selection pressure to optimize and regulate the response levels from p53 REs. This directionality in the REs arrangement is at least partly encoded in the structural properties of the REs. Furthermore, we show here that in the p21-5′ RE the orientation of the half-sites is such that the effect of the flanking sequences is minimized and we discuss its advantages.

The tumor suppressor protein p53 is situated in the midst of a complex cellular network that is activated in response to cellular stress. Activated p53 functions mainly as a transcription factor, regulating the expression of numerous genes involve in various cellular pathways critical for preventing cancer, and in pathways unrelated to cancer surveillance. An unresolved question in the field is how p53 is able to parse its myriad functions in response to the severity of the stress signal and consequently to coordinate the functional outcome in a timely manner. We have previously shown that DNA torsional flexibility distinguishes between different p53 response elements (REs). Here we show across the genome that p53 target genes belonging to pathways acting early in the stress response (e.g., DNA damage response and innate immunity) have REs that are significantly more flexible than REs of genes involved in pathways that need to be more strictly regulated, or that their functional outcome occurs later in the response to stress (e.g., intrinsic apoptosis and p53 negative regulation). We validated these statistical findings by several complementary experimental approaches, in vitro and in cells, for six p53 REs belonging to pathways that operate at different times post p53 induction. Our results clearly demonstrate that the flexibility of p53 REs contributes significantly to the temporal expression of p53 target genes and thereby to life versus death decisions in the p53 system.