Swift's sermon of 1715, "On False Witness," is, compared to previous homilies on "sins of the tongue" (by Isaac Barrow, Robert South, Ezekiel, Hopkins, Peter Newcome), unique in focusing on government informers, in addressing its "Hearers" not as potential liars but as potential victims of lying, and in offering the congregation advice on how to avoid entrapment by spies. This choice of focus, determined by Swift's immediate aim of protecting his neighbors from the flourishing post-Succession "trade in carrying stories to the government," is relevant to Gulliver's Travels. Alternately victim and perpetrator of false witness, Gulliver exposes the unreliability of those who "inform" on the basis of individual observation, rather than speaking for, and from within, a neighborly community.
The extant correspondence between Ruskin and Angelo Alessandri consists of fifty-five letters from Ruskin to Alessandri and drafts of twenty-six letters plus one final version of a letter from Alessandri to Ruskin. With one exception, all these letters and drafts are in the possession of Alessandri's daughter, Signora Maria Pennati Alessandri, who has kindly allowed me to transcribe and quote from them. The only surviving version of an Alessandri letter (letter 77 in my list in Appendix B) is in the Rylands, 1 and I am grateful to the Library for permission to quote from it. 2. Of Ruskin's fifty-five letters, six were published in full or almost in full in the Library Edition. while extracts. usually only a phrase or two. from nine others were used in the General Catalogue of the Ruskin Museum as comments on copies by Alessandri in the collection. 2 Transcripts of most of those published or quoted from. and of twelve other letters, are among the transcripts Alexander Wedderburn gave to the Bodleian in 1936. 3 I do not always agree with the transcriptions, although it is only in a few cases that the sense is altered. None of Alessandri's letters has been published. 3. Alessandri obviously kept Ruskin's letters carefully, and some time after the end of the correspondence placed each letter in a simple paper cover on which he noted the following kinds of information : (i) Either one or two numbers : (a) One series of numbers reflects the overall chronological order of Ruskin's letters and extends from 1 to 55 (there is some confusion in the numeration of a few letters). In the case of thirty letters (which for convenience I call "group A") Alessandri used Arabic numerals, but with twenty-five letters ("group B") he used Roman numerals. Thus the overall chronological sequence runs I, II, 3. 4. 5. 6, VII, VIII etc. (b) In addition, "group B" has its own, self-contained numeration, which runs from l to 24 in Arabic numerals (there are twenty-five letters in this group but two are numbered "24"). (ii) The date of the letter. In "group A" Alessandri gives the dates in Italian. in "group B" in English. Where Ruskin did not date a letter Alessandri always tried to establish a rough date, and usually seems reliable. I have, therefore, accepted his dating where necessary except in one instance: letter l in my list below Alessandri thought was of "Febbraio o Marzo del 1878"-but the letter was clear1y written while Ruskin was in Venice, which he was not in 1878; the letter is c1early, then, of 1877, and I prefer February to March (see above p. 408. and notes 2 and 6). (iii) Occasionally Ruskin's whereabouts at the time of writing. Usually Ruskin used headed notepaper and this was not necessary, but in the few cases in which Ruskin was writing in Venice Alessandri supplies the name of the hotel-the Calcina in 1877, the Europa in 1888. (iv) Alessandri's own whereabouts at the time of receiving the letter. (v) Comments on the contents of the letter. These are often useful in identifying a reference, particularly to a painting or ...
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.