Bone healing commences with an inflammatory reaction which initiates the regenerative healing process leading in the end to reconstitution of bone. An unbalanced immune reaction during this early bone healing phase is hypothesized to disturb the healing cascade in a way that delays bone healing and jeopardizes the successful healing outcome. The immune cell composition and expression pattern of angiogenic factors were investigated in a sheep bone osteotomy model and compared to a mechanically-induced impaired/delayed bone healing group. In the impaired/delayed healing group, significantly higher T cell percentages were present in the bone hematoma and the bone marrow adjacent to the osteotomy gap when compared to the normal healing group. This was mirrored in the higher cytotoxic T cell percentage detected under delayed bone healing conditions indicating longer pro-inflammatory processes. The highly activated periosteum adjourning the osteotomy gap showed lower expression of hematopoietic stem cell markers and angiogenic factors such as heme oxygenase and vascular endothelial growth factor. This indicates a deferred revascularization of the injured area due to ongoing pro-inflammatory processes in the delayed healing group. Results from this study suggest that there are unfavorable immune cells and factors participating in the initial healing phase. In conclusion, identifying beneficial aspects may lead to promising therapeutical approaches that might benefit further by eliminating the unfavorable factors.

No abstract

During hematoma formation following injury, an inflammatory reaction ensues as an initial step in the healing process. As granulation tissue matures, revascularization is a prerequisite for successful healing. The hypothesis of this study was that scarless tissue reconstitution in the regenerative bone healing process is dependent on a balanced immune reaction that initiates revasculatory steps. To test this hypothesis, cellular composition and expression profiles of a bone hematoma (regenerative, scarless) was compared with a muscle soft tissue hematoma (healing with a scar) in a sheep model. Upregulation of regulatory T helper cells and anti-inflammatory cytokine expression (IL-10) coincided with an upregulation of angiogenic factors (HIF1α and HIF1α regulated genes) in the regenerative bone hematoma but not in the soft tissue hematoma. These results indicate that the timely termination of inflammation and early onset of revascularization are interdependent and essential for a regenerative healing process. Prolonged pro-inflammatory signaling occurring in a delayed bone-healing model supports the finding that timely termination of inflammation furthers the regenerative process. Differing cellular compositions are due to different cell sources invading the hematoma, determining the ensuing cytokine expression profile and thus paving the path for regenerative healing in bone or the formation of scar tissue in muscle injury.

Blood vessel formation is a prerequisite for bone healing. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that a delay in bone healing is associated with an altered regulation of blood vessel formation. A tibial osteotomy was performed in two groups of sheep and stabilized with either a rigid external fixator leading to standard healing or with a highly rotationally unstable one leading to delayed healing. At days 4, 7, 9, 11, 14, 21, and 42 after surgery, total RNA was extracted from the callus. Gene expressions of vWF, an endothelial cell marker, and of several molecules related to blood vessel formation were studied by qPCR. Furthermore, histology was performed on fracture hematoma and callus sections. Histologically, the first blood vessels were detected at day 7 in both groups. mRNA expression levels of vWF, Ang1, Ang2, VEGF, CYR61, FGF2, MMP2, and TIMP1 were distinctly lower in the delayed compared to the standard healing group at several time points. Based on differential expression patterns, days 7 and 21 postoperatively were revealed to be essential time points for vascularization of the ovine fracture callus. This work demonstrates for the first time a differential regulation of blood vessel formation between standard and mechanically induced delayed healing in a sheep osteotomy model. ß

Despite the growing knowledge on the mechanisms of fracture healing, delayed healing and non-union formation remain a major clinical challenge. Animal models are needed to study the complex process of normal and impaired fracture healing and to develop new therapeutic strategies. Whereas in the past mainly large animals have been used to study normal and impaired fracture healing, nowadays rodent models are of increasing interest. New osteosynthesis techniques for rat and mice have been developed during the last years, which allowed for the first time stable osteosynthesis in these animals comparable to the standards in large animals and humans. Based on these new implants, different models in rat and mice have been established to study delayed healing and non-union formation. Although in humans the terms delayed union and non-union are well defined, in rodents definitions are lacking. However, especially in scientific studies clear definitions are necessary to develop a uniform scientific language and allow comparison of the results between different studies. In this consensus report, we define the basic terms "union", "delayed healing" and "non-union" in rodent animal models. Based on a review of the literature and our own experience, we further provide an overview on available models of delayed healing and non-union formation in rats and mice. We further summarise the value of different approaches to study normal and delayed fracture healing as well as non-union formation, and discuss different methods of data evaluation.

Fracture healing is a unique biologic process starting with an initial inflammatory response. As in other regenerative processes, bone and the immune system interact closely during fracture healing. This project was aimed at further elucidating how the host immune system participates in fracture healing. A standard closed femoral fracture was created in wild-type (WT) and recombination activating gene 1 knockout (RAG1 À/À ) mice lacking the adaptive immune system. Healing was investigated using micro-computed tomography (mCT), biomechanical testing, and histologic and mRNA expression analyses. Biomechanical testing demonstrated a significantly higher torsional moment on days 14 and 21 in the RAG1 À/À mice compared to the WT group. mCT evaluation of RAG1 À/À specimens showed earlier mineralization and remodeling. Histologically, endochondral ossification and remodeling were accelerated in the RAG1 À/À compared with the WT mice. Histomorphometric analysis on day 7 showed a significantly higher fraction of bone and a significantly lower fraction of cartilage in the callus of the RAG1 À/À mice than in the WT mice. Endochondral ossification was accelerated in the RAG1 À/À mice. Lymphocytes were present during the physiologic repair process, with high numbers in the hematoma on day 3 and during formation of the hard callus on day 14 in the WT mice. Expression of inflammatory cytokines was reduced in the RAG1 À/À mice. In contrast, expression of anti-inflammatory interleukin 10 (IL-10) was strongly upregulated in RAG1 À/À mice, indicating protective effects. This study revealed an unexpected phenotype of enhanced fracture healing in RAG1 À/À mice, suggesting detrimental functions of lymphocytes on fracture healing. The shift from proinflammatory to anti-inflammatory cytokines suggests that immunomodulatory intervention strategies that maximise the regenerative and minimize the destructive effects of inflammation may lead to enhanced fracture repair. ß

Mechanical loading further enhanced the efficacy of BMP2 application evidenced by increased mineralized tissue volume and mineralization at the stage of bony callus bridging. These data suggest that already a minimal amount of mechanical stimulation through load bearing or exercise may be a promising adjunct stimulus to enhance the efficacy of cytokine treatment in segmental defects. Further studies are required to elucidate the mechanistic interplay between mechanical and biological stimuli.

Fracture healing requires a certain degree of mechanical stability and an adequate blood supply. The hypothesis of the present study was that increased interfragmentary shear leads to a reduced initial vascularization and prolonged healing. The aim of the study was to quantitatively analyze the histological appearance of vascularization and tissue differentiation with regard to fracture stability during the course of healing. A mid-shaft osteotomy of the tibia was performed in two groups of sheep and stabilized with either a rigid or semirigid external fixator, differing in bending stiffness. Interfragmentary movements and ground reaction forces were evaluated in vivo during a 9-week period. The sheep were sacrificed at 2, 3, 6, and 9 weeks postoperatively. The tibiae were tested biomechanically and histological sections from the callus were prepared for analysis of tissue differentiation and vascularization. Larger interfragmentary shear movements in the semirigid fixator group were associated with a reduced initial blood supply. At 6 weeks the semirigid fixator group showed a significantly lower percentage of mineralized bone and a higher amount of fibrous tissue leading to a significantly lower stiffness of the callus than the rigid fixator group. This initial delay in healing was compensated for in the later stages with the production of greater volumes of callus tissue so that both groups showed the same callus stiffness at 9 weeks. However, the rigid fixator group showed signs of the beginning of callus remodeling at the latest time points suggesting a faster bone healing. The results indicate the important role of the initial mechanical stability specifically in the vascularization of an osteosynthesis. Further studies should illustrate the precise role of mechanical conditions on the regulation of angiogenesis during early bone healing.