The CGG repeat in the 5' untranslated region of the fragile X mental retardation 1 gene (FMR1) exhibits remarkable instability upon transmission from mothers with premutation alleles. A collaboration of 13 laboratories in eight countries was established to examine four issues concerning FMR1 CGG-repeat instability among females with premutation (approximately 55-200 repeats) and intermediate (approximately 46-60 repeats) alleles. Our central findings were as follows: (1) The smallest premutation alleles that expanded to a full mutation (>200 repeats) in one generation contained 59 repeats; sequence analysis of the 59-repeat alleles from these two females revealed no AGG interruptions within the FMR1 CGG repeat. (2) When we corrected for ascertainment and recalculated the risks of expansion to a full mutation, we found that the risks for premutation alleles with <100 repeats were lower than those previously published. (3) When we examined the possible influence of sex of offspring on transmission of a full mutation-by analysis of 567 prenatal fragile X studies of 448 mothers with premutation and full-mutation alleles-we found no significant differences in the proportion of full-mutation alleles in male or female fetuses. (4) When we examined 136 transmissions of intermediate alleles from 92 mothers with no family history of fragile X, we found that, in contrast to the instability observed in families with fragile X, most (99/136 [72.8%]) transmissions of intermediate alleles were stable. The unstable transmissions (37/136 [27.2%]) in these families included both expansions and contractions in repeat size. The instability increased with the larger intermediate alleles (19% for 49-54 repeats, 30.9% for 55-59, and 80% for 60-65 repeats). These studies should allow improved risk assessments for genetic counseling of women with premutation or intermediate-size alleles.

Preliminary results on a large population-based molecular survey of FRAXA and FRAXE are reported. All boys with unexplained learning difficulties are eligible for inclusion in the study and data are presented on the first 1013 tested. Individuals were tested for the number of trinucleotide repeats at FRAXA and FRAXE and typed for four flanking microsatellite markers. Mothers of 760 boys were tested to determine the stability of the FRAXA and FRAXE repeats during transmission and to provide a population of control chromosomes. The frequency of FRAXA full mutations was 0.5%, which gives a population frequency of 1 in 4994, considerably less than previous reports suggest. No FRAXE full mutations were detected, confirming the rarity of this mutation. In the boys' X chromosomes, we detected one FRAXA premutation with 152 repeats and one putative FRAXE premutation of 87 repeats. No full or premutations were seen in the control chromosomes. A significant excess of intermediate alleles at both FRAXA and FRAXE was detected in the boys' X chromosomes by comparison with the maternal control chromosomes. This suggests that relatively large unmethylated repeats of sizes 41-60 for FRAXA and 31-60 for FRAXE may play some role in mental impairment. No instability was found in transmissions of minimal or common alleles in either FRAXA or FRAXE, but we saw two possible instabilities in transmission of FRAXA and two definite instabilities in transmission of FRAXE among 43 meioses involving intermediate or premutation sized alleles. We found no linkage disequilibrium between FRAXA and FRAXE but did find significant linkage disequilibrium between large alleles at FRAXE and allele 3 at the polymorphic locus DXS1691 situated 5 kb distal to FRAXE.

To understand the origins of the fragile X syndrome and factors predisposing alleles to instability and hyperexpansion, we have compared the haplotype (using markers FRAXAC1, FRAXAC2, and DXS548) and AGG interspersion patterns of the FMR1 CGG repeat for 214 normal and 16 premutation chromosomes. Association testing between interspersion pattern and haplotype reveals a highly significant (P < 0.002) non-random distribution, indicating that all three markers are useful in phylogenetic reconstruction of mutational change. Parsimony analysis of the FMR1 CGG repeat substructure predicts that loss of AGG interruptions has occurred independently on many haplotypes associated with the fragile X syndrome, partially explaining the haplotype diversity of this disease. Among haplotypes found in linkage disequilibrium with the fragile X mutation, two different modes of mutation and predisposition to instability have been identified. One pathway has involved the frequent and recurrent loss of AGG interruptions from rare asymmetrical ancestral array structures. Intergenerational transmission studies suggest that these predisposed chromosomes progress relatively rapidly to the disease state. In contrast, the second mutational pathway involves a single haplotype which has maintained two AGG interruptions. Parsimony analysis of CGG repeat substructure within this haplotype suggests that larger alleles have been generated by gradual increments of CGG repeats distal to the most 3' interruption. Pedigree analysis of the intergenerational stability of alleles of this haplotype confirms a gradual progression toward instability thresholds. As a result, a large reservoir of chromosomes carrying large repeats on this haplotype exists. These chromosomes are predisposed to disease. The present data support a model in which there are at least two different mutational pathways predisposing alleles to instability and hyperexpansion associated with the fragile X syndrome.

In at least 98% of fragile X syndrome cases, the disease results from expansion of the CGG repeat in the 5' end of FMR1. The use of microsatellite markers in the FMR1 region has revealed a disparity of risk between haplotypes for CGG repeat expansion. Although instability appears to depend on both the haplotype and the AGG interspersion pattern of the repeat, these factors alone do not completely describe the molecular basis for the linkage disequilibrium between normal and fragile X chromosomes, in part due to instability of the marker loci themselves. In an effort to better understand the mechanism of dynamic mutagenesis, we have searched for and discovered a single nucleotide polymorphism in intron 1 of FMR1 and characterized this marker, called ATL1, in 564 normal and 152 fragile X chromosomes. The G allele of this marker is found in 40% of normal chromosomes, in contrast to 83% of fragile X chromosomes. Not only is the G allele exclusively linked to haplotypes over-represented in fragile X syndrome, but G allele chromosomes also appear to transition to instability at a higher rate on haplotypes negatively associated with risk of expansion. The two alleles of ATL1 also reveal a highly significant linkage disequilibrium between unstable chromosomes and the 5' end of the CGG repeat itself, specifically the position of the first AGG interruption. The data expand the number of haplotypes associated with FMR1 and specifically allow discrimination, by ATL1 alleles, of single haplotypes with differing predispositions to expansion. Such haplotypes should prove useful in further defining the mechanism of dynamic mutagenesis.