It is shown by rational site-directed mutagenesis of the lid region in Thermomyces lanuginosus lipase that it is possible to generate lipase variants with attractive features, e.g., high lipase activity, fast activation at the lipid interface, ability to act on water-soluble substrates, and enhanced calcium independence. The rational design was based on the lid residue composition in Aspergillus niger ferulic acid esterase (FAEA). Five constructs included lipase variants containing the full FAEA lid, a FAEA-like lid, an intermediate lid of FAEA and TlL character, and the entire lid region from Aspergillus terreus lipase (AtL). To investigate an altered activation mechanism for each variant compared to that of TlL, a combination of activity- and spectroscopic-based measurements were applied. The engineered variant with a lid from AtL displayed interfacial activation comparable to that of TlL, whereas variants with FAEA lid character showed interfacial activation independence with pronounced activity toward pNP-acetate and pNP-butyrate below the critical micelle concentration. For variants with lipase and esterase character, lipase activity measurements further indicated a faster activation at the lipid interface. Relative to their activity toward pNP-ester substrates in calcium-rich buffer, all lid variants retained between 15 and 100% activity in buffer containing 5 mM EDTA whereas TlL activity was reduced to less than 2%, demonstrating the lid's central role in governing calcium dependency. For FAEA-like lid variants, accessible hydrophobic surface area measurements showed an approximate 10-fold increase in the level of binding of extrinsic fluorophores to the protein surface relative to that of TlL accompanied by a blue shift in emission indicative of an open lid in aqueous solution. Together, these studies report on the successful alteration of the activation mechanism in TlL by rational design creating novel lipases with new, intriguing functionalities.

Triacylglycerol hydrolases (EC 3.1.1.3) are thought to become activated when they encounter the water-lipid interface causing a "lid" region to move and expose the catalytic site. Here, we tested this idea by looking for lid movements in Thermomyces lanuginosus lipase (TL lipase), and in variants with a mutated lid region of esterase (Esterase) and esterase/lipase (Hybrid) character. To measure lid movements, we employed the tryptophan-induced quenching (TrIQ) fluorescence method to measure how effectively a Trp residue on the lid of these mutants (at position 87 or 89) could quench a fluorescent probe (bimane) placed at nearby site 255 on the protein. To test if lid movement is induced when the enzyme detects a lower-polarity environment (such as at the water-lipid interface), we performed these studies in solvents with different dielectric constants (ε). The results show that lid movement is highly dependent on the particular lid residue composition and solvent polarity. The data suggest that in aqueous solution (ε = 80), the Esterase lid is in an "open" conformation, whereas for the TL lipase and Hybrid, the lid remains "closed". At lower solvent polarities (ε < 46), the lid region for all of the mutants is more "open". Interestingly, these behaviors mirror the structural changes thought to take place upon activation of the enzyme at the water-lipid interface. Together, these results support the idea that lipases are more active in low-polarity solvents because the lid adopts an "open" conformation and indicate that relatively small conformational changes in the lid region play a key role in the activation mechanism of these enzymes.

No abstract

Lipases naturally function at the interface formed between amphiphilic molecules and the aqueous environment. Thermomyces lanuginosus lipase (TLL) is a well-characterised lipase, known to exhibit interfacial activation during which a lid region covering the active site becomes displaced upon interaction with an interface. In this study, we investigate the effect the amino acid sequence of the lid region on interfacial binding and lid dynamics of TLL. Three TLL variants were investigated, a wild-type variant, a variant containing an esterase lid region (Esterase), and a Hybrid variant, containing both wild-type lid residues and esterase lid residues. Multiple coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations revealed that the interfacial binding orientation of TLL was significantly affected by the nature of amino acids in the lid region, and atomistic simulations indicated effects on the structural dynamics of the lid itself. The atomistic simulations, as well as steered molecular dynamics simulations, also indicated that the Esterase lid region was less flexible than the wild-type lid region, whereas the Hybrid variant displayed superior lid flexibility and stability in the open conformation both at the interface, and in aqueous solution. Additional experiments performed to investigate the activity and binding behaviour of the lipase variants indicated a slightly higher specific activity for the Hybrid variant compared to the wild-type variant, correlating the observations of increased lid flexibility. Together, these results are in line with previous experimental studies, highlighting the importance of the nature of the amino acid residues within the functional lid region of lipases, particularly regarding interfacial binding orientation, activation, and structural stability.

Thermomyces lanuginosus lipase (TlL) and related lipases become activated in low-polarity environments that exist at the water-lipid interface where a structural change of the "lid" region occurs. In this work, we have investigated the activation of TlL (Lipase_W89) and certain lid mutants, containing either a single positive charge mutation, E87K (Lipase_K87_W89), within the lid region or a lid residue composition of both lipase and esterase character (Hybrid_W89) as a function of solvent polarity. Activation differences between the variants and TlL were studied by a combination of biophysical and theoretical methods. To investigate the structural changes taking place in the lid region upon lipase activation, we used a fluorescence-based method measuring the efficiency of Trp89 in the lid to quench the fluorescence of a bimane molecule attached in front (C255) and behind (C61) the lid. These structural changes were compared to the enzymatic activity of each variant at the water-substrate interface and to theoretical calculations of the energies associated with lid opening as a function of the dielectric constant (ε) of the environment. Our results show that the lid in Lipase_K87_W89 undergoes a pronounced structural transition toward an open conformation around ε = 50, whereas only small changes are detected for Lipase_W89 ascribed to the stabilizing effect of the positive charge mutation on the open lid conformation. Interestingly, Hybrid_W89, with the same charge as Lipase_W89, shows a stabilization of the open lid even more pronounced at high solvent polarities than that of Lipase_K87_W89, allowing activation at ε < 80. This is further indicated by measurement of the lipase activity for each variant showing that Hybrid_W89 is more quickly activated at the water-lipid interface of a true, natural substrate. Combined, we show that a correlation exists between structural changes and enzymatic activities detected on one hand and theoretical calculations on lid opening energies on the other. These results highlight the key role that the lid plays in determining the polarity-dependent activation of lipases.

The attractiveness of lipases as industrial biocatalysts underlines the importance of understanding their molecular action in detail, helping future efforts to improve performance and applicability. Lipases represent a special class of carboxyl ester hydrolases, which act on long‐chained water insoluble acyl‐glycerols at the water‐lipid interface. This heterogeneous catalysis makes it very difficult to monitor the structural changes taking place in the enzyme during activation in its preferred milieu. In this review, we cover recent developments toward a deeper understanding of the interfacial activation phenomenon of lipases and discuss a selection of biophysical methods suitable for studying lipase activation. For many lipases, such as that from Thermomyces lanuginosus, a structural domain called the “lid” is directly involved in the activation process. This has been shown through alteration of the lid‐residue composition using rational design. The resulting lid‐mutants have highlighted the lid's role in governing enzymatic activity and interfacial activation. Moreover, a recently developed fluorescence‐based technique called the Tryptophan Induced Quenching method has proved to enable the direct measurement of lipase activation in water‐ethanol mixtures, and thus represents an intriguing method to gain further insight into the structural movements taking place at the water‐lipid interface. Practical applications: Lipases are important industrial biocatalysts widely used in industrial applications including detergent, leather, paper, fuel, fine chemicals, baking, cosmetics, and food. Knowledge of structural changes of lipase upon activation and identification of the amino acids involved in lipase activation is crucial for design of new variants with improved or new properties. Rational design of the lid‐region in lipases has an interesting potential for optimization of lipase function and adapting them to different environments. In order to leverage on the design of new lipase variants and their altered function, methods that enable direct measurement of lipase action directly in solution, in real time, are desired. In this context, fluorescence based methods have shown great potential and provides interesting perspectives for probing the delicate movements occurring in lipases upon activation. Interfacial activation of lipases and the lid movements studied by rational design, fluorescence quenching methods, and solvent effect – polarity driven activation.

No abstract