The relative depth of penetration of melittin into egg phosphatidylcholine and bovine heart cardiolipin model membranes was investigated using fluorescence spectroscopy techniques. The tryptophan intrinsic fluorescence shift suggests a more hydrophobic surrounding of this residue in cardiolipin, while the accessibility for charged and uncharged aqueous quenchers is decreased in the cardiolipin system when compared with the phosphatidylcholine-bound situation. A lipid incorporated hydrophobic, collisional quencher and a resonance energy transfer acceptor on the other hand are more effective in quenching the tryptophan fluorescence of cardiolipin bound melittin. The combination of these results is interpreted as prove of a deeper positioning of the tryptophan containing part of the peptide molecule in the cardiolipin system in comparison with the situation in phosphatidylcholine. Models that take this difference into account are presented, which try to explain the opposite effect of melittin binding to the two lipid systems with respect to supramolecular structure, as reported in the preceding article (Batenburg, A.M., Hibbeln, J.C.L., Verkleij, A

The interaction of melittin with bovine heart cardiolipin model membranes was investigated via binding assays, 3t P-NMR, freeze-fracture electron microscopy, small angle X-ray diffraction and fluorescence based fusion assays. A strong binding (K d < 10-7 M) appeared to be accompanied by the formation of large structures, resulting from a fusion process of extremely fast initial rate. As the melittin content is increased, bilayer structure is gradually lost and from a cardiolipin to melittin ratio of about 6 the lipid starts to organize itself in an hexagonal H ii phase. At lower temperatures (T < 40 ° C) the coexistence of another structure is observed, characterized by a broad isotropic 31p-NMR signal and giving rise to sharp X-ray reflections, most probably a cubic phase, as suggested also by freeze-fracture images, showing orderly stacked particles. The results are discussed in relation to contrasting observations on the structural changes induced by melittin in the zwitterionic phospholipid system of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (Dufourcq, J. et al. (1986) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 859, 33-48). The biological relevance of the observations with respect to the process of protein insertion into membranes is indicated.