The canine-and-canine retainer displayed an 18% detachment rate, a value significantly lower than the 29% determined for the 0.0195" canine-to-canine retainers. The 0.0215" canine-to-canine retainer had the highest detachment rate (53%). The 37% detachment rate with dry field bonding was slightly higher than the 32% with relatively dry field bonding. Comparison of the composites showed a significantly higher detachment rate for Heliosit (73%) than for Concise (27%). Plaque accumulation increased with all retainer types in the course of the study, but with no significant inter-group differences. Tooth position with canine-to-canine retainers showed a good degree of stability. The canine-and-canine retainer induced frequent relapse of incisors not bonded to the retainer. In view of their higher rate of subjective discomfort, canine-and-canine retainers were given a significantly poorer rating than their canine-to-canine counterparts.