Small, hydrophilic molecules, including most important antibiotics in clinical use, cross the Gram-negative outer membrane through the water-filled channels provided by porins. We have determined the X-ray crystal structures of the principal general porins from three species of Enterobacteriaceae, namely Enterobacter aerogenes, Enterobacter cloacae, and Klebsiella pneumoniae, and determined their antibiotic permeabilities as well as those of the orthologues from Escherichia coli. Starting from the structure of the porins and molecules, we propose a physical mechanism underlying transport and condense it in a computationally efficient scoring function. The scoring function shows good agreement with in vitro penetration data and will enable the screening of virtual databases to identify molecules with optimal permeability through porins and help to guide the optimization of antibiotics with poor permeation.

Gram-negative bacteria and their complex cell envelope comprising an outer and inner membrane are an important and attractive system for studying the translocation of small molecules across biological membranes. In the outer membrane of Enterobacteriaceae, trimeric porins control the cellular penetration of small molecules, including nutrients and antibacterial agents. The synergistic action between relatively slow porin-mediated passive uptake across the outer membrane and active efflux transporters in the inner membrane creates a permeability barrier that reinforces the enzymatic modification barrier, which efficiently reduces the intracellular concentrations of small molecules and contributes to the emergence of antibiotic resistance. In this review, we discuss recent advances in our understanding of the molecular and functional roles of classic porins in small molecule translocation in Enterobacteriaceae and consider the crucial role of porins in antibiotic resistance. Commented [w1]: Is this specification necessary here?, in my opinion it deviates, better to put later… Commented [JP2]: Editor request... porins represent the preferred route for the entry of β-lactams, including cephalosporins, penicillins and carbapenems 14-16. The clinical relevance of membrane-associated mechanisms (MAMs) of resistance (i.e. porin defects and/or overexpression of multidrug efflux pumps) has been well established for these antibiotics. The Influx and Efflux rates control the internal concentration of antibiotics and represent the first lane (mechanical barrier) protecting the bacterial cells against therapeutic treatment 1-3,6. Consequently, studies on bacterial porins are receiving a renewed interest due to their key role in the bacterial susceptibility towards clinically used antibiotics. In combination with the expression of antibiotic-modifying enzymes expressed in the periplasm (e.g. β-lactamases), porins play a key role in β-lactam resistance 4,17. In this review, we discuss recent advances in our understanding of the molecular and functional roles of classic porins in antibiotic translocation in Enterobacteriaceae. We explore structural aspects and the insights gained into permeation and the pore translocation process, the regulation of porin expression as well as the role of porins in the emergence of antibiotic susceptibility. Enterobacterial general porins Structural aspects The crystal structures of a general porin from Rhodobacter capsulatus 18 , the OmpF and PhoE porins from E. coli 19 and other E. coli OmpF structures including mutants 20,21 were the first to be solved. Only a limited number of other enterobacterial porin structures have been reported, i.e. E. coli OmpC, K. pneumoniae OmpK36 and Salmonella typhi OmpF 22-24. The lack of data has hindered attempts to relate structure to function. Recently, the structures of two porins from P. stuartii as well as the structures of the OmpF and OmpC orthologs of K. pneumoniae, E. aerogenes and E. cloacae have been reported 12,25,26. Another recent study reported th...

Transport of molecules through biological membranes is a fundamental process in biology, facilitated by selective channels and general pores. The architecture of some outer membrane pores in Gram-negative bacteria, common to other eukaryotic pores, suggests them as prototypes of electrostatically regulated nanosieve devices. In this study, we sensed the internal electrostatics of the two most abundant outer membrane channels of Escherichia coli, using norfloxacin as a dipolar probe in single molecule electrophysiology. The voltage dependence of the association rate constant of norfloxacin interacting with these nanochannels follows an exponential trend, unexpected for neutral molecules. We combined electrophysiology, channel mutagenesis, and enhanced sampling molecular dynamics simulations to explain this molecular mechanism. Voltage and temperature dependent ion current measurements allowed us to quantify the transversal electric field inside the channel as well as the distance where the applied potential drops. Finally, we proposed a general model for transport of polar molecules through these electrostatic nanosieves. Our model helps to further understand the basis for permeability in Gram-negative pathogens, contributing to fill in the innovation gap that has limited the discovery of effective antibiotics in the last 20 years.

Although the role of general bacterial porins is well established as main pathway for polar antibiotics, the molecular details of their mode-of-action are still under debate. Using molecular dynamics simulations and water as a probe, we demonstrated the strong ordering of water molecules, differently tuned along the axis of diffusion in the transversal direction. Preserved features and important differences were characterized for different channels, allowing to put forward a general model for molecular filtering. The intrinsic electric field, responsible for water ordering, (i) filters those dipolar molecules that can compensate the entropy decrease by dipole alignment in the restricted region and (ii) might create an additional barrier by changing direction when escaping from the restricted region. We tested this model using two antibiotics, cefepime and cefotaxime, through metadynamics free energy calculations. A rational drug design should take this into account for screening molecules with improved permeation properties.

A major challenge in the discovery of the new antibiotics against Gram-negative bacteria is to achieve sufficiently fast permeation in order to avoid high doses causing toxic side effects. So far, suitable assays for quantifying the uptake of charged antibiotics into bacteria are lacking. We apply an electrophysiological zero-current assay using concentration gradients of β-lactamase inhibitors combined with single-channel conductance to quantify their flux rates through OmpF. Molecular dynamic simulations provide in addition details on the interactions between the nanopore wall and the charged solutes. In particular, the interaction barrier for three β-lactamase inhibitors is surprisingly as low as 3-5 kcal/mol and only slightly above the diffusion barrier of ions such as chloride. Within our macroscopic constant field model, we determine that at a zero-membrane potential a concentration gradient of 10 μM of avibactam, sulbactam, or tazobactam can create flux rates of roughly 620 molecules/s per OmpF trimer.

No abstract

Highlights d Projection map of a native S-layer at 4.5-Å resolution by cryo-EC d SDBC structure at 11-Å resolution by cryo-EM single-particle analysis d SDBC in situ localization and orientation d S-layer as a stabilizing component of cell-wall status

Multi-drug resistance bacteria are a challenging problem of contemporary medicine. This is particularly critical for Gram-negative bacteria, where antibiotics are hindered by the outer membrane to reach internal targets. Here more polar antibiotics make use of nanometric water-filled channels to permeate inside. We present in this work a computational all-atom approach, using water as a probe, for the calculation of the macroscopic electric field inside water-filled channels. The method allows one to compare not only different systems but also the same system under different conditions, such as pH and ion concentration. This provides a detailed picture of electrostatics in biological nanopores shedding more light on how the charged residues of proteins determine the electric field inside, and also how medium can tune it. These details are central to unveil the filtering mechanism behind the permeation of small polar molecules through nanometric water-filled channels.