Restriction enzymes cannot cleave DNA without a metal ion cofactor. The specificities of the EcoRV and EcoRI endonucleases for metals were studied by measuring DNA cleavage rates with several metal ions and with combinations of metal ions. Both EcoRV and EcoRI had optimal activities with Mg2+, were less active with several other ions including Mn2+, and had virtually no activity with Ca2+. But the activities of EcoRV and EcoRI with either Mg2+ or Mn2+ were perturbed by Ca2+. For EcoRI, both Mg2+- and Mn(2+)-dependent activities, at both cognate and noncognate sites, were all inhibited by Ca2+. The activity of EcoRV at its recognition site with Mg2+ was also inhibited by Ca2+. But the Mn(2+)-dependent reaction at the EcoRV recognition site was stimulated by Ca2+. EcoRV activities at noncognate sites with either Mg2+ or Mn2+ displayed a biphasic response to Ca2+: stimulation at low concentrations of Ca2+ and inhibition at high concentrations. These observations, together with the known structures of the proteins, indicate that EcoRI needs only one metal ion per active site and is inactive when Mg2+ is displaced by Ca2+, while EcoRV needs two and that the displacement of one by Ca2+ can enhance activity. We propose a mechanism for phosphodiester hydrolysis by EcoRV that involves two metal ions.

In the presence of Mg2+, the EcoRV restriction endonuclease cleaves DNA specifically at its recognition sequence, but in the absence of divalent metal ions, it binds DNA without any specificity: gel-shift experiments had revealed multiple EcoRV-DNA complexes, due to the binding of one, two, three, or more molecules of protein per molecule of DNA, with the same equilibrium constant for each association. In this study, the binding of EcoRV to DNA was measured by gel shift in the presence of Ca2+, an ion that perturbs the Mg(2+)-dependent activity of EcoRV but that fails to support DNA cleavage. With Ca2+, and at a lower concentration of EcoRV protein than that required for binding in the absence of divalent metal ions, a single complex was observed with DNA containing the EcoRV recognition site. This complex was not formed with DNA that had been methylated at the EcoRV site nor with an isogenic DNA lacking the EcoRV recognition site. The single complex thus is due to the specific binding of EcoRV to its recognition site on the DNA. From gel shifts with a permuted set of DNA fragments, the degree of DNA bending by EcoRV at its recognition site was estimated to be 53 degrees +/- 4 degrees. This angle is similar to that seen in the crystal structure of the cognate DNA-protein complex. Calcium ions thus appear to mimic the role of Mg2+ in generating a specific protein-metal-DNA complex, but in contrast to Mg2+, Ca2+ gives a stable ternary complex in which the DNA-bound nuclease cannot cleave the DNA.

We have used the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease to monitor changes in protein conformation during binding and cleavage of a duplex oligodeoxynucleotide substrate. Appropriate conditions for single-turnover reactions were first determined by steady-state kinetics. When single turnovers were monitored by stopped-flow fluorescence, the mixing together of EcoRV, oligonucleotide and MgCl2 resulted in a rapid increase in tryptophan fluorescence followed by a slow decrease. Further analysis by order-of-mixing and quench experiments showed that the transient increase in fluorescence was due to a conformational change coupled to DNA binding, while the subsequent decay was concomitant with phosphodiester hydrolysis. The rate of the latter step varied with the concentration of Mg2+ ions, but another Mg(2+)-dependent transition was observed upon the addition of MgCl2 to a preformed enzyme-DNA complex. These results lead to a reaction scheme in which one Mg2+ binds to the active site prior to phosphodiester hydrolysis but a second Mg2+ is then needed to carry out the hydrolytic reaction. This scheme is correlated to the crystal structures of the EcoRV endonuclease and its complexes with DNA and Mg2+ ions.

A genetic system was constructed for the mutagenesis of the EcoRV restriction endonuclease and for the overproduction of mutant proteins. The system was used to make two mutants of EcoRV, with Ala in place of either Asn185 or Asn188. In the crystal structure of the EcoRV-DNA complex, both Asn185 and Asn188 contact the DNA within the EcoRV recognition sequence. But neither mutation affected the ability of the protein to bind to DNA. In the absence of metal ion cofactors, the mutants bound DNA with almost the same affinity as that of the wild-type enzyme. In the presence of Mg2+, both mutants retained the ability to cleave DNA specifically at the EcoRV recognition sequence, but their activities were severely depressed relative to that of the wild-type. In contrast, with Mn2+ as the cofactor, the mutant enzymes cleaved the EcoRV recognition site with activities that were close to that of the wild-type. When bound to DNA at the EcoRV recognition site, the mutant proteins bound Mn2+ ions readily, but they had much lower affinities for Mg2+ ions than the wild-type enzyme. This was the reason for their low activities with Mg2+ as the cofactor. The arrangement of the DNA recognition functions, at one location in the EcoRV restriction enzyme, are therefore responsible for organizing the catalytic functions at a separate location in the protein.

The EcoRV restriction endonuclease cleaves DNA at its recognition sequence more readily with Mg2+ as the cofactor than with Mn2+ but, at noncognate sequences that differ from the EcoRV site by one base pair, Mn2+ gives higher rates than Mg2+. A mutant of EcoRV, in which an isoleucine near the active site was replaced by leucine, showed the opposite behavior. It had low activity with Mg2+, but, in the presence of Mn2+ ions, it cleaved the recognition site faster than wild-type EcoRV with either Mn2+ or Mg2+. The mutant was also more specific for the recognition sequence than the native enzyme: the noncognate DNA cleavages by wild-type EcoRV and Mn2+ were not detected with the mutant. Further mutagenesis showed that the protein required the same acidic residues at its active site as wild-type EcoRV. The Ile-->Leu mutation seems to perturb the configuration of the metal-binding ligands at the active site so that the protein has virtually no affinity for Mg2+ yet it can still bind Mn2+ ions, though the latter only occurs when the protein is at the recognition site. This contrasts to wild-type EcoRV, where Mn2+ ions bind readily to complexes with either cognate and noncognate DNA and only Mg2+ shows the discrimination between the complexes. The structural perturbation is a specific consequence of leucine in place of isoleucine, since mutants with valine or alanine were similar to wild-type EcoRV.