The introduction of two amino acid substitutions within the enzymatically active subunit Si of pertussis toxin (PT) abolishes its ADP-ribosyltransferase activity and toxicity on CHO cells (Pizza et al., Science 246:497-500, 1989). These genetically inactivated molecules are also devoid of other in vivo adverse reactions typical of PT, such as induction of leukocytosis, potentiation of anaphylaxis, stimulation of insulin secretion, and histamine sensitivity. However, the mutant PT molecules are indistinguishable from wild-type PT in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and maintain all the physical and chemical properties of PT, including affinity for toxin-neutralizing poly-and monoclonal antibodies. Either alone or stabilized with formaldehyde, PT mutants are able to induce high levels of neutralizing antibodies and to protect mice in a dose-dependent fashion against intracerebral challenge with virulent B. pertussis. These results clearly show that these genetically inactivated PT molecules are nontoxic but still immunogenic and justify their development as a component of a new, safer aceliular vaccine against whooping cough.

The in vivo immunizing potency of diphtheria toxoid and formalin-treated corss-reacting material (CRM197, a nontoxic mutant protein) was compared in guinea pigs. Major antigenic differences between the two untreated proteins were also tested in rats. The results showed that diphtheria toxoid and CRM197 were equally effective immunogens, but only if the latter was treated with formalin in the same concentration (0.7% vol/vol) was that of the toxoid. Formalin treatment rendered the antigens more resistant to enzymatic proteolysis by trypsin in vitro.

Proteins to be used as vaccines are frequently treated with formaldehyde, although little is known about the effects of this treatment on protein antigenicity. To investigate the effect of formaldehyde treatment on antigen recognition by T cells, we compared the in vitro T-cell response to proteins that have been formaldehyde treated with the response to untreated proteins. We found that peripheral blood mononuclear cells from individuals vaccinated with three formaldehyde-treated proteins (pertussis toxin, filamentous hemagglutinin, pertactin) of Bordetella pertussis showed little or no response to the formaldehyde-treated proteins but proliferated very well in response to the corresponding untreated protein. These findings were further confirmed with CD4+ T-cell clones specific for defined epitopes of the bacterial proteins. We found that some epitopes are presented poorly or not at all when formaldehyde-treated proteins are used, whereas other epitopes are equally presented to T-cell clones when either formaldehyde-treated or untreated antigens are used. However, T-cell recognition could be restored by either antigen degradation before formaldehyde treatment or heat denaturation after such treatment. Parallel digestion with trypsin of both formaldehyde-treated and untreated proteins showed that fragments generated from the two forms of the same antigen were different in size. These results demonstrate that formaldehyde treatment can constrain antigen presentation to T cells and that this may be due to an altered proteolytic processing of formaldehyde-treated proteins.

Formaldehyde treatment is a method routinely used to detoxify diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis toxins as well as other molecules suitable for vaccine production. To investigate whether chemical detoxification alters the immunological properties of vaccine components, we have treated the pertussis toxin mutant PT-9K/129G with formaldehyde and tested the properties of the resulting molecules. Very low concentrations of formaldehyde stabilize the molecule without affecting the physicochemical and immunological parameters. Increasing doses of formaldehyde abolish the mitogenic and hemagglutinating activities of PT-9K/129G. At the same time, the molecule loses the ability to be recognized by a monoclonal antibody specific for a major protective epitope on the S1 subunit of pertussis toxin and its affinity for anti-pertussis toxin polyclonal antibodies is also reduced. In marked contrast, the ability of PT-9K/129G to be recognized by human T-cell clones is not affected by Formalin treatment. In vivo, the formaldehyde-treated molecules induce amounts of specific antibodies comparable with those of untreated molecules but significantly lower levels of toxin-neutralizing antibodies. Furthermore, the formaldehyde-treated molecules also show a reduced protective activity in the intracerebral challenge assay.

No abstract