Although the magnitude of a genetic component of Parkinson disease (PD [MIM 168600]) remains to be determined, the disease has already shown remarkable genetic heterogeneity, with at least five monogenic forms identified, the most common of which is LRRK2 (MIM 609007). 1 In this issue of The American Journal of Human Genetics, four investigative teams 2-5 report that they have sought to replicate the findings from a genomewide association (GWA) study of PD affection by Maraganore et al. 6 Taken together, these four studies appear to provide substantial evidence that none of the SNPs originally featured as potential PD loci are convincingly replicated and that all may be false positives. Furthermore, that the LRRK2 gene was not identified may be considered a false-negative result. This conclusion is both disappointing and discouraging. The original study invested heavily in this venture, with 443 sibling pairs () discordant for PD typed in tier 1 n p 886 for 198,345 SNPs (172,420,019 genotype calls) and a tier 2 follow-up typing the strongest 1,892 SNPs in 332 matched case-control unrelated pairs (1,176,772 genotypes). Because this report is among the first GWA studies and because the effort appears to have failed to produce the desired objective, it is worth examining the implications for GWA studies in general and, specifically, the significance of this study for PD. First, let's examine the original report. Tier 1 of the original study is founded upon sibling pairs discordant for PD recruited from the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, MN. The sample is composed of individuals substantially of northern and central European descent. Discordant sibling pairs were selected to limit false-positive results due to population stratification bias. 7 Population differences between case and control samples are recognized as the primary source of false-positive associations, and, clearly, every effort to minimize these effects is to be encouraged. However, in PD there is substantial evidence for reduced penetrance, 8 and the disease etiology is most likely a complex interaction of genetic and v77n5/42619/tableS2new.txt and http://www.journals .uchicago.edu/AJHG/journal/issues/v77n5/42619/ tableS3new.txt) in the online-only version of the original article. 6 These results can be readily downloaded and searched for evidence of association with other interesting PD candidate genes. Maraganore and colleagues, with the Michael J. Fox Foundation, have the opportunity to establish a precedent for making the entire GWA study available online, since one may reasonably expect that true PD risk alleles may be found among the SNPs with lesser levels of statistical significance. The jury is still out on whether this GWA study holds important insights for PD.