Many tumors over express tumor-associated antigens relative to normal tissue, such as epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). This limits targeting by human T cells modified to express chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) due to potential for deleterious recognition of normal cells. We sought to generate CAR+ T cells capable of distinguishing malignant from normal cells based on the disparate density of EGFR expression by generating two CARs from monoclonal antibodies which differ in affinity. T cells with low affinity Nimo-CAR selectively targeted cells over-expressing EGFR, but exhibited diminished effector function as the density of EGFR decreased. In contrast, the activation of T cells bearing high affinity Cetux-CAR was not impacted by the density of EGFR. In summary, we describe the generation of CARs able to tune T-cell activity to the level of EGFR expression in which a CAR with reduced affinity enabled T cells to distinguish malignant from non-malignant cells.

No abstract

Carpentier is a paid consultant to CarThera. K. Beccaria was previously an employee of CarThera. A.

PURPOSE Current guidelines for postoperative management of patients with stage I-IIA cutaneous melanoma (CM) do not recommend routine cross-sectional imaging, yet many of these patients develop metastases. Methods that complement American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging are needed to improve identification and treatment of these patients. A 31-gene expression profile (31-GEP) test predicts metastatic risk as low (class 1) or high (class 2). Prospective analysis of CM outcomes was performed to test the hypotheses that the 31-GEP provides prognostic value for patients with stage I-III CM, and that patients with stage I-IIA melanoma and class 2 31-GEP results have metastatic risk similar to patients for whom surveillance is recommended. MATERIALS AND METHODS Two multicenter registry studies, INTEGRATE (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02355574 ) and EXPAND (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02355587 ), were initiated under institutional review board approval, and 323 patients with stage I-III CM and median follow-up time of 3.2 years met inclusion criteria. Primary end points were 3-year recurrence-free survival (RFS), distant metastasis-free survival (DMFS), and overall survival (OS). RESULTS The 31-GEP was significant for RFS, DMFS, and OS in a univariate analysis and was a significant, independent predictor of RFS, DMFS, and OS in a multivariable analysis. GEP class 2 results were significantly associated with lower 3-year RFS, DMFS, and OS in all patients and those with stage I-IIA disease. Patients with stage I-IIA CM and a class 2 result had recurrence, distant metastasis, and death rates similar to patients with stage IIB-III CM. Combining 31-GEP results and AJCC staging enhanced sensitivity over each approach alone. CONCLUSION These data provide a rationale for using the 31-GEP along with AJCC staging, and suggest that patients with stage I-IIA CM and a class 2 31-GEP signature may be candidates for more intense follow-up.

No abstract

CD19-specific chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)+ T cells have demonstrated clinical efficacy and long-lasting remissions, concomitant with tolerable normal B-cell aplasia. However, many tumor-associated antigens (TAAs) are expressed on normal tissues, the destruction of which would lead to intolerable toxicity. Thus, there is a need to engineer CAR+ T cells with improved safety profiles to restrict toxicity against TAA-expressing normal tissues. Bioengineering approaches include: (i) targeting CAR+ T cells to the tumor site, (ii) limiting CAR+ T-cell persistence, and (iii) restricting CAR activation. We review and evaluate strategies to engineer CAR+ T cells to reduce the potential of on-target, off-tissue toxicity.

Potential for on-target, but off-tissue toxicity limits therapeutic application of genetically modified T cells constitutively expressing chimeric antigen receptors (CARs) from tumor-associated antigens expressed normal tissue, such as epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). Curtailing expression of CAR via modification of T cells by in vitro-transcribed mRNA species is one strategy to mitigate such toxicity. We evaluated expression of an EGFR-specific CAR coded from introduced mRNA in human T cells numerically expanded ex vivo to clinically significant numbers via co-culture with activating and propagating cells (AaPC) derived from K562 pre-loaded with anti-CD3 antibody. The density of AaPC could be adjusted to impact phenotype of T cells such that reduced ratio of AaPC resulted in higher proportion of CD8+ and central memory T cells that were more conducive to electro-transfer of mRNA than T cells expanded with high ratios of AaPC. RNA-modified CAR+ T cells produced less cytokine, but demonstrated similar cytolytic capacity as DNA-modified CAR+ T cells in response to EGFR-expressing glioblastoma cells. Expression of CAR by mRNA transfer was transient and accelerated by stimulation with cytokine and antigen. Loss of CAR abrogated T-cell function in response to tumor and normal cells expressing EGFR. We describe a clinically-applicable method to propagate and modify T cells to transiently express EGFR-specific CAR to target EGFR-expressing tumor cells that may be used to limit on-target, off-tissue toxicity to normal tissue.

Immunotherapeutic approaches to cancer have shown remarkable promise. A critical barrier to successfully executing such immune-mediated interventions is the selection of safe yet immunogenic targets. As patient deaths have occurred when tumor-associated antigens shared by normal tissue have been targeted by strong cellular immunotherapeutic platforms, route of delivery, target selection and the immune-mediated approach undertaken must work together to maximize efficacy with safety. Selected tumor-specific targets can spare potential toxicity to normal tissue; however, they are far less common than tumor-associated antigens and may not be present on all patients. In the context of immunotherapy for high-grade glioma, 2 of the most prominently studied antigens are the tumor-associated epidermal growth factor receptor and its tumor-specific genetic deletion variant III. In this review, we will summarize the immune-mediated strategies employed against these targets as well as the caveats particular to these approaches.