Objectives/Hypothesis
The objective of this project was to develop a virtual temporal bone dissection system that would provide an enhanced educational experience for the training of otologic surgeons.
Study Design
A randomized, controlled, multi-institutional single blinded validation study.
Methods
The project encompassed 4 areas of emphasis: structural data acquisition, integration of the system, dissemination of the system, and validation.
Results
Structural acquisition was performed on multiple imaging platforms. Integration achieved a cost effective system. Dissemination was achieved on different levels including casual interest, downloading of software, and full involvement in development and validation studies. A validation study was performed at 8 different training institutions across the country using a two arm, randomized trial where study subjects were randomized to a two-week practice session using either the virtual temporal bone or standard cadaveric temporal bones. Eighty subjects were enrolled and randomized to one of the two treatment arms, 65 completed the study. There was no difference between the two groups using a blinded rating tool to assess performance after training.
Conclusions
1. A virtual temporal bone dissection system has been developed and compared to cadaveric temporal bones for practice using a multi-center trial. 2. There is no statistical difference seen between practice on the current simulator when compared to practice on human cadaveric temporal bones. 3. Further refinements in structural acquisition and interface design have been identified which can be implemented prior to full incorporation into training programs and use for objective skills assessment.
The Welling scale can be used reliably to assess temporal bone dissection performance where performance is measured by assessment of end product (mastoidectomy with facial recess approach).
We designed and tested three PilA-derived vaccine candidates in a chinchilla model of ascending nontypeable Haemophilus influenzae (NTHI)-induced otitis media (OM). Delivery of antiserum directed against each immunogen conferred varying degrees of protection. Presentation of a B-cell epitope derived from the OMP P5 adhesin at the N-terminus of recombinant soluble PilA protein (as opposed to the C-terminus), resulted in a protective chimeric immunogen that combined epitopes from two distinct NTHI adhesins (type IV pili and OMP P5). Incorporating protective epitopes derived from two NTHI adhesins/virulence determinants into a single pediatric vaccine candidate to prevent OM has multiple potential inherent advantages.
Percutaneous sclerotherapy provides effective treatment for macrocystic and microcystic LM as primary treatment or for recurrence after surgical resection.
The system provides an environment to learn temporal bone surgery in a way similar to the experience with cadaver material where the subject is able to interact with the data without constraints (nondeterministic). Eventually, it may provide the "front end" to a large repository of various temporal bone pathologies that can be accessed through the Internet.
Objectives/Hypothesis
There is increasing interest in objective assessment of surgeon competence. In the field of otolaryngology, several surgical training programs, including The Ohio State University, the University of Toronto, and Stanford University, have pursued standardized criteria to rate their trainees’ performance in the initial steps of temporal bone dissection (complete mastoidectomy with facial recess approach). Although these assessment metrics require the completion of similar basic components integral to successful temporal bone dissection, certain listed criteria are unique to each institution. Our aim was to establish a more standardized set of criteria that can be used across different institutions to objectively assess temporal bone dissection. We translated these new criteria into automated metrics in our temporal bone dissection simulator to achieve even more objective grading of temporal bone dissections.
Study Design
Cross-sectional study/survey.
Methods
The temporal bone assessment criteria developed by each of the three aforementioned institutions were compiled into an all-encompassing scale. This compilation was sent out as an online survey to members of the American Neurotology Society and American Otological Society with instructions to rate the importance of each criterion.
Results
Criteria that were ranked by >70% of respondents as either “very important” or “important” were used to create the new, cross-institutional scale for the objective assessment of temporal bone dissection.
Conclusions
The new assessment scale and its eventual incorporation into the temporal bone surgical simulator will enhance the objectivity of currently existing methods to evaluate surgical performance across different institutions.
This article focuses on key issues surrounding the needs and application of simulation technologies for technical skills training in otolaryngology. The discussion includes an overview of key topics in training and learning, the application of these issues in simulation environments, and the subsequent applications of these simulation environments to the field of otolaryngology. Examples of past applications are presented, with discussion of how the interplay of cultural changes in surgical training in general, along with the rapid advancements in technology have shaped and influenced their adoption and adaptation. The authors conclude with emerging trends and potential influences advanced simulation and training will have on technical skills training in otolaryngology.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.