The essay explores the analogies between the two characters of Deianeira and Penelope in Homer and Sophocles. It investigates some common traits of the two heroines with respect to their existential situation and personality, namely age, grief, expectation, anxiety, loneliness, and resignation. Through the investigation, supported by a series of reworkings of epic idioms, of the imaginary of tears, of the wedding bed and of the night, Leitmotive which define the two female protagonists both in the Trachiniae and in the Odyssey, the essay highlights how Sophocles brings the Homeric symbolism of pain, life, love, and death to extreme and tragic consequences.
No abstract
B.'s monograph on Telamonian Ajax is a timely contribution to the unparalleled fortune the eterno secondo among heroes has been enjoying in recent years. A brand-new commentary of Sophocles' Ajax just appeared for Les Belles Lettres, and another one is forthcoming by S. Murnaghan for the 'Green and Yellow' series. The Ajax myth in all its possible implications is investigated in the rich collective volume Looking at Ajax edited by D. Stuttard (2019). B.'s contribution also focuses on a wide-ranging account of polytropos Ajax, to adopt the provocative title of a recent conference, and it represents the most comprehensive overview of the myth of Ajax in archaic and classical Greece to date.After a brief introduction, the book is divided into three main chapters, followed by a bibliography, index of Greek words, inscriptionum, locorum and a very useful and ample general index. In the introduction B. explains her methodology, a blend of H.R. Jauss's 'Reception Aesthetics' and F. de Saussure's principles of synchronie and diachronie. Accordingly, after establishing Ajax's peculiar attributes in early mythical traditions, the study surveys his reception in all kinds of cultural media.Chapter 1, 'Ajax from Salamis', deals with the hero's representation in early pre-Homeric hexameter poetry and in archaic art. B. reconstructs two of Ur-Ajax's unique features, whichshe convincingly arguesconstitute obliterated pre-Homeric motifs: invulnerability and a hostile relationship with Athena. The first is clearly attested in ancient sources (Hesiod, Pindar, iconography). However, B. argues that Homer indirectly preserves traces of this. Thus, Ajax is the only major hero in the Iliad never wounded, and two similes (14.402-20; 13.321-5) covertly allude to his invulnerability. Also, there is his defensive role of ἕρκος Ἀχαιῶν and his high-risk task of rescuing the bodies of Patroclus and Achilles. Athena's enmity is also implied in the Iliad: Ajax, who is never directly assisted by a god, never prays to Athena. B. argues that Ajax's unique overconfidence in his own strength and suicide in the pre-Homeric account stem from his original invulnerability. B.'s reconstruction of Ur-Ajax, although not completely original, is the most persuasive attempt. With respect to Homeric suppression of wondrous elements (invulnerability and immortality), she rightly refers to J. Griffin's contributions. However, she could have also dealt with M. Davies's studies on the adaptation of folk-tale elements in Homer (e.g. 'The Folk-tale Origins', WS 115 [2002]) and explored in greater depth the bearing of Homer's recasting of Ajax in order to exploit his world view of human frailty and mortality in the Iliad.Chapter 2, 'Ajax in Aegina', convincingly demonstrates that Ajax was imbued with strong political significance throughout the first half of the fifth century, especially during the rivalry between Aegina and Athens. With this aim, it investigates the use made of Ajax by Pindar and Bacchylides in Epinikia for Aeginetan patrons. The analysis follows the...
Il libro raccoglie i contributi presentati nel corso del primo Seminario internazionale METra (Mapping Epic in Tragedy – Epica e tragedia greca: una mappatura) svoltosi nel maggio del 2021 presso l’Università degli Studi di Verona. Il fine di questo volume – e del progetto da cui prende le mosse – è sondare i confini della ricca e frastagliata eredità dell’epica greca arcaica (in primis Omero) nel dramma attico. Tale eredità viene qui indagata secondo direttrici molteplici e multidisciplinari: dall’analisi linguistica e metrica all’esegesi filologica, stilistico-letteraria e drammaturgica, dalle prospettive della ricerca antropologica e storico-religiosa a quelle della storia culturale e delle idee. I saggi costituiscono – per quanto in modo inevitabilmente parziale – una prima, provvisoria ma già estesa mappatura delle fertili, continue e innovative rivisitazioni in chiave drammatica del patrimonio mitico, linguistico e culturale dell’epica messe in opera dai grandi tragediografi del V secolo a.C.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
customersupport@researchsolutions.com
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.