Groups of patients with Parkinson's disease (PD), striatonigral degeneration-type multiple system atrophy (MSA) or progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) with motor disability stages II and III according to Hoehn and Yahr, and a healthy control group were compared using neuropsychological tests of executive functions. The results indicate that all three patient groups were impaired in the tests of executive functions. In comparison with healthy subjects, the three patient groups showed impaired performance regarding verbal fluency, problem solving and verbal and figural working memory. Patients with PD differed significantly from healthy subjects in a test of verbal recency, while patients with MSA or PSP were unimpaired. The comparison of patient groups revealed no differences between PD and MSA patients. However, patients with PSP showed greater impairment in both phonemic and semantic fluency than patients with PD or MSA. Using discriminant function analysis, it was found that variables derived from four verbal fluency tasks (simple and alternate semantic and phonemic fluency) discriminated among the three patient groups at a level significantly exceeding chance. Over 90% of patients with PSP were correctly classified. Patients with PD and MSA were correctly classified in over 70% of cases. These results suggest that verbal fluency tasks may be sensitive measures in the differential diagnosis of PD, MSA and PSP.

Parkinson’s disease is frequently associated with depressive symptoms. When depression occurs at early stages and before the onset of characteristic motor symptoms of the disease, differential diagnosis of major depression may be difficult. Differences in psychopathological features of depression in Parkinson’s disease and major depression have been reported by some authors. This study presents data of 49 patients with depression in Parkinson’s disease and 38 patients with major depression. The severity of depressive symptoms was equivalent in both groups. Depressive features did not differ between the two groups with exception of affective flattening, delusional ideas and suicide attempts. In conclusion, this investigation gives support to the assumption of a common neurobiological origin of depression in Parkinson’s disease and major depression.

No abstract

Atrophy of frontal lobe, midbrain, pons, and cerebellum was studied in 16 patients with progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP), 14 with multiple system atrophy of striatonigral type (MSA-P), 20 with idiopathic Parkinson's disease (IPS), and 12 age-matched healthy controls using axial T2-weighted MR images (1.5 Teslar). With <16 mm, the PSP group showed significantly lower anteroposterior midbrain diameters than the IPS, MSA-P, and control groups. We conclude that measurement of the anteroposterior diameter of the midbrain with axial T2-weighted MRI is a useful feature and should be incorporated into the diagnostic criteria for PSP. In addition to the typical slit hyperintensity in margin of putamen and decreased signal intensity in dorsolateral putamen, we found cerebellar atrophy in 64% of patients with MSA-P. Before now, this was considered a typical sign of multiple system atrophy of cerebellar type (MSA-C). The use of this feature in the differential diagnosis of both types of multiple system atrophy is debatable.

No abstract