We investigated genome folding across the eukaryotic tree of life. We find two types of three-dimensional (3D) genome architectures at the chromosome scale. Each type appears and disappears repeatedly during eukaryotic evolution. The type of genome architecture that an organism exhibits correlates with the absence of condensin II subunits. Moreover, condensin II depletion converts the architecture of the human genome to a state resembling that seen in organisms such as fungi or mosquitoes. In this state, centromeres cluster together at nucleoli, and heterochromatin domains merge. We propose a physical model in which lengthwise compaction of chromosomes by condensin II during mitosis determines chromosome-scale genome architecture, with effects that are retained during the subsequent interphase. This mechanism likely has been conserved since the last common ancestor of all eukaryotes.

An emerging regulatory principle governing enhancers is the use of suboptimal affinity binding sites to encode tissue-specific gene expression. Here we investigate if optimizing single-nucleotide variants that violate this principle can disrupt tissue-specific gene expression and development. The ZRS enhancer mediates expression of Shh in the posterior of the developing limb buds and is critical for limb and digit development. We find that the ZRS contains suboptimal-affinity ETS binding sites. Two human mutations and a synthetic mutation that optimize the affinity of the ETS-A site from 0.15 to 0.25 relative binding affinity cause polydactyly with the same penetrance and severity. Further increasing the affinity of the ETS-A site results in more penetrant and severe phenotypes. The prevalent use of suboptimal affinity binding sites within enhancers to encode tissue-specificity creates a vulnerability within genomes whereby variants that optimize affinity, even subtly, can be pathogenic. This provides a generalizable approach to identify causal variants that underlie enhanceropathies.

SummaryEnhancers direct precise gene expression patterns during development and harbor the majority of variants associated with disease. We find that suboptimal affinity ETS transcription factor binding sites are prevalent within Ciona and human developmental heart enhancers. Here we demonstrate in two diverse systems, Ciona intestinalis and human iPSC-derived cardiomyocytes (iPSC-CMs), that single nucleotide changes can optimize the affinity of ETS binding sites, leading to gain-of-function gene expression associated with heart phenotypes. In Ciona, ETS affinity-optimizing SNVs lead to ectopic expression and phenotypic changes including two beating hearts. In human iPSC-CMs, an affinity-optimizing SNV associated with QRS duration occurs within an SCN5A enhancer and leads to increased enhancer activity. Our mechanistic approach provides a much-needed systematic framework that works across different enhancers, cell types and species to pinpoint causal enhancer variants contributing to enhanceropathies, phenotypic diversity and evolutionary changes.In BriefThe prevalent use of low-affinity ETS sites within developmental heart enhancers creates vulnerability within genomes whereby single nucleotide changes can dramatically increase binding affinity, causing gain-of-function enhancer activity that impacts heart development.HighlightsETS affinity-optimizing SNVs can lead to migration defects and a multi-chambered heart.An ETS affinity-optimizing human SNV within an SCN5A enhancer increases expression and is associated with QRS duration.Searching for ETS affinity-optimizing variants is a systematic and generalizable approach to pinpoint causal enhancer variants.

The cell type-specific expression of key transcription factors is central to development. Brachyury/T/TBXT is a major transcription factor for gastrulation, tailbud patterning, and notochord formation; however, how its expression is controlled in the mammalian notochord has remained elusive. Here, we identify the complement of notochord-specific enhancers in the mammalian Brachyury/T/TBXT gene. Using transgenic assays in zebrafish, axolotl, and mouse, we discover three Brachyury-controlling notochord enhancers T3, C, and I in human, mouse, and marsupial genomes. Acting as Brachyury-responsive, auto-regulatory shadow enhancers, deletion of all three enhancers in mouse abolishes Brachyury/T expression selectively in the notochord, causing specific trunk and neural tube defects without gastrulation or tailbud defects. Sequence and functional conservation of Brachyury-driving notochord enhancers with the brachyury/tbxtb loci from diverse lineages of fishes dates their origin to the last common ancestor of jawed vertebrates. Our data define the enhancers for Brachyury/T/TBXTB notochord expression as ancient mechanism in axis development.