Fishes exhibit a dynamic array of reproductive diversity. Among the various forms of reproduction, internal fertilization has evolved at least 13 times and has been observed in 2–3% of teleost species, half of which are marine. Internal fertilization has led to the evolution of male intromittent organs to aid in sperm transfer during copulation. The intromittent organs of poeciliids have been widely investigated, but little research has focused on the intromittent organs of marine fishes. The surfperches are internally fertilizing, viviparous fishes with a ventrally located papilla. In this article, the external morphology of 19 Embiotocidae species was examined. Additionally, paraffin histology was used to investigate the walleye surfperch (Hyperprosopon argenteum), black perch (Embiotoca jacksoni), and dwarf perch (Micrometrus minimus) papilla to aid in the identification of tissue composition to determine its function. External morphology was documented via macro photography and males were dissected to observe the relationship between the testes, spermatic duct, and papilla. We provide histological evidence that the urogenital papilla is directly connected to the spermatic duct and testis and likely involved in spermatozeugmata transfer. Our research also determined that the papillae were composed of both urinary and reproductive tissues, thus we propose the papilla be referred to as a urogenital papilla. Our study contributes to an overall understanding of intromittent organs of marine fishes, particularly in the surfperches, which has not been previously documented.