Previous studies showed that monomolecular films of extracted calf surfactant collapse at the equilibrium spreading pressure during quasi-static compressions but become metastable at much higher surface pressures when compressed faster than a threshold rate. To determine the mechanism by which the films become metastable, we studied single-component films of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine (POPC). Initial experiments confirmed similar metastability of POPC if compressed above a threshold rate. Measurements at different surface pressures then showed that rates of collapse, although initially increasing above the equilibrium spreading pressure, reached a sharply defined maximum and then slowed considerably. When heated, rapidly compressed films recovered their ability to collapse with no discontinuous change in area, arguing that the metastability does not reflect transition of the POPC film to a new phase. These observations indicate that in several respects, the supercompression of POPC monolayers resembles the supercooling of three-dimensional liquids toward a glass transition.

No abstract

Fluid monolayers of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine collapse from an air/water interface to form a three-dimensional bulk phase at the equilibrium spreading pressure (π e ) of ~47 mN/m. This phase transition limits access to higher surface pressures under equilibrium conditions or during slow continuous compressions. We have shown previously that these films avoid collapse and become metastable when compressed on a captive bubble to surface pressures above 60 mN/m and that the metastability persists during expansion at least to π e . Here, we first documented the extent of this persistent metastability. Rates of isobaric collapse during expansion of the metastable films were up to 3 orders of magnitude slower than those during the initial compression to high surface pressures. Recovery of the ability to collapse depended on the surface pressure to which the films were expanded and how long they were held there. Films reverted after brief exposure to 20 mN/m and after 1 h at 35 mN/m. At π e , films remained capable of reaching high surface pressures during slow compressions after 65 h, although an increase in compressibility above 55 mN/m suggested somewhat increased rates of collapse. We also determined if the films remained metastable when they acquired sufficient free area to allow reinsertion of collapsed material. Faster isobaric expansion in the presence of more collapsed material and with further deviation below π e supported the existence of reinsertion. The persistence of metastability to π e shows that films with sufficient free area to allow reinsertion remain resistant to collapse. Observations that suggest heterogeneous reinsertion, however, argue that free area may be distributed heterogeneously and leave open the possibility that metastability persists because significant regions retain a restricted free area.

Unlike surfactants considered in previous studies, when phosphatidylcholine (PC) monolayers collapse at constant surface tension to form a 3D bulk phase, surface area decreases at rates that slow. The different kinetics could result from collapse by a distinct mechanism. Rather than the transfer of molecules all along the interface between the monolayer and bulk phase, PC films can collapse by the folding and subsequent sliding of a bilayer over the monolayer. By this mechanism, molecules can transfer to collapsed trilayers through a locus of constant size. In this article, we use the theory of nucleation and growth to show analytically that during collapse, the area can decrease at rates that decelerate when each individual structure grows through a region of fixed dimensions. We also show that binary films of 30% dihydrocholesterol (dchol) and dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC), which have previously been shown to form a homogeneous monolayer from which trilayer disks grow through a point, collapse with rates of area decay that slow, in agreement with our analytical expressions.

The kinetics of phase transitions in three-dimensional bulk materials are commonly presented in transformation diagrams. Time-temperature transformation (TTT) and continuous-coolingtransformation (CCT) diagrams plot the time required to transform specific fractions of the material to the new phase by cooling below a transition temperature. Transformation occurs isothermally for the TTT diagrams and during continuous cooling through a range of temperatures for CCT curves. Here we present analogous transformation diagrams for two-dimensional monolayers, which collapse at the equilibrium spreading pressure (π e ) to form a three-dimensional bulk phase. Time-surface pressure-transformation (TπT) diagrams give the time required for specific fractions of the film to collapse when surface pressure is constant, and continuouscompression-transformation diagrams give the same information when surface pressure varies continuously. The diagrams, constructed here from previously reported data for 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine, provide insights into the behavior of the films. The TπT diagrams successfully predict the existence and approximate magnitude of a threshold rate for compressing the films to high surface pressures above π e and the approximate shape of isotherms obtained with different rates of interfacial compression. The diagrams also caution that the behavior of mixed monolayers, explained previously in terms of compositional changes, can instead result from collapse that varies with surface pressure. Finally, the similarity between the shapes of the TTT and TπT diagrams, with the time for transformation passing through a minimum and then increasing as the systems deviate further from equilibrium, suggests that analogous mechanisms determine the behavior of both systems.