The current study compared the speed and legibility of handwriting produced by children exposed to either traditional instruction (TI) or whole-language instruction (WLI) in an attempt to determine whether children who received traditional, intensive classroom instruction in handwriting produce more legible andfaster handwriting. Forty-four TI students in lower (4 & 5) and upper (7 & 8) grades were matched with WLI students on the basis of chronological age, sex, grade, and dominant hand. All participants provided three writing samples exemplifying their best cursive writing, their usual cursive writing, and their handwriting under the pressure of speed. Samples were codedfor legibility using the Test ofLegible Handwriting (Larsen & Hammill, 1989), and a total word count was computedfor speeded samples. The majorfindings showed that the TI children produced more legible handwriting than did WLI students, were able to write significantly more words under time pressure, and that these differences between the groups did not diminish with increased grade/age. The practical implications of the results are discussed, particularly the findings related to speed of transcription. Specifically noted in the discussion is the relationship between the automaticity of writing and compositional fluency that has emerged in recent research.La presente etude vise a comparer la vitesse et la lisibilite de lIecriture d'enfants exposes soit a une methode d'enseignement de la langue traditionnelle (TI) ou a une methode globale (WLI), dans le but de determiner si les enfants exposes a une me6thode d'enseignement traditionnelle, intensive et en classe, ecrivent plus rapidement et de faVon plus lisible. Quarante-quatre eleves TI de 4me et 5me anne6e et de 7me et 8me annee ont et6 jumeles a des eleves WLI selon leur age chronologique, sexe, niveau scolaire, et main dominante. Tous les participants ont fourni trois echantillons e'crits representant leur meilleure e6criture cursive, leur ecriture cursive ordinaire, et leur ecriture lorsque chronometr6s. Les 6chantillons ont ete codes pour la lisibilite selon le Atest de l"ecriture lisible@ (Larsen & Hammil, 1989), et un total du nombre de mots a 6te enregistre pour les echantillons ecrits lorsque chronometres. Les resultats montrent que les enfants TI ont produit une ecriture plus lisible que les enfants WLI, et ont ete capables de
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.