High Raman enhancement factors (EFs) have been observed for surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) substrates fabricated from colloidal metal nanoparticles. Electrodynamic models of single nanoparticles often do not accurately predict the Raman EFs measured experimentally for such colloidal substrates, which often consist of nanoparticles that exhibit heterogeneity in both size and shape. Here, we investigate the size and shape dispersity of colloidal Ag nanocube samples and their effect on Raman EF. We generate an analytical model that incorporates nanocube size dispersion and calculates the Raman EF associated with an ensemble of differently sized nanocubes. For nanocubes that are ∼70-80 nm in size, this model is sufficient to correct the inaccuracies for electrodynamic simulations of a single nanocube model. For nanocubes >90 nm, size dispersity alone fails to account for the high EFs observed when these substrates are excited off-resonance. We hypothesize that shape defects may play a significant role in optical response at these larger sizes and discuss how these factors can play a role in our analytical model.

Surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) is a widely used sensing technique for ultrasensitivity chemical sensing, biomedical detection, and environmental analysis. Because SERS signal is proportional to the fourth power of the local electric field, several SERS applications have focused on the design of plasmonic nanogaps to take advantage of the extremely strong near-field enhancement that results from plasmonic coupling, but few designs have focused on how SERS detection is affected by molecular orientation within these nanogaps. Here, we demonstrate a nanoparticle-on-metal metasurface designed for near-perfect optical absorption as a platform for Raman detection of highly oriented molecular analytes, including two-dimensional materials and aromatic molecules. This metasurface platform overcomes challenges in nanoparticle aggregation, which commonly leads to low or fluctuating Raman signals in other colloidal nanoparticle platforms. Our metasurface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (mSERS) platform is based on a colloidal Langmuir–Schaefer deposition, with up to 32% surface coverage density of nanogaps across an entire sensor chip. In this work, we perform both simulations of the local electric field and experimental characterization of the mSERS signal obtained for oriented molecular layers. We then demonstrate this mSERS platform for the quantitative detection of the drinking-water toxin polybrominated diphenyl ether (BDE-15), with a limit of detection of 0.25 μM under 530 μW excitation. This detection limit is comparable to other SERS-based sensors operating at laser powers over 3 orders of magnitude higher, indicating the promise of our mSERS platform for nondestructive and low-level analyte detection.