Acid-base properties of cyclodextrins (CDs), persubstituted at C-6 by 3-mercaptopropionic acid, sualphadex (Suα-CD), subetadex (Suβ-CD) and sugammadex (Suγ-CD, the antidote of neuromuscular blocking steroids) were studied by 1H NMR-pH titrations. For each CD, the severe overlap in protonation steps prevented the calculation of macroscopic pKa values using the standard data fitting model. Considering the full symmetry of polycarboxylate structures, we reduced the number of unknown NMR parameters in the “Q-fitting” or the novel “equidistant macroscopic” evaluation approaches. These models already provided pKa values, but some of them proved to be physically unrealistic, deceptively suggesting cooperativity in carboxylate protonations. The latter problem could be circumvented by adapting the microscopic site-binding (cluster expansion) model by Borkovec, which applies pairwise interactivity parameters to quantify the mutual basicity-decreasing effect of carboxylate protonations. Surprisingly, only a single averaged interactivity parameter could be calculated reliably besides the carboxylate ‘core’ microconstant for each CD derivative. The speciation of protonation isomers hence could not be resolved, but the optimized microscopic basicity parameters could be converted to the following sets of macroscopic pKa values: 3.84, 4.35, 4.81, 5.31, 5.78, 6.28 for Suα-CD; 3.82, 4.31, 4.73, 5.18, 5.64, 6.06, 6.54 for Suβ-CD and 3.83, 4.28, 4.65, 5.03, 5.43, 5.81, 6.18, 6.64 for Suγ-CD. The pH-dependent charge of these compounds can now be accurately calculated, in support of designing new analytical methods to exploit their charge-dependent molecular recognition such as in cyclodextrin-aided chiral capillary electrophoresis.
