Increasing silage production and quality is paramount for dairy and beef feedlot production. We aimed to (a) increase dry matter, protein production, and profit per acre of corn (Zea mays L.) by intercropping it with soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.]; (b) compare soybean maturity groups (MGs) intercropped or grown as the sole crop; and (c) quantify the soybean planting rate's influence on land equivalent ratios (LER), total dry matter yield, nutrient concentration and economic return per acre in cornsoybean intercropping systems. A 2-yr field study was conducted with two soybean MGs (MG1 and MG7) and four soybean planting rates: 0 (control), 38,000 (1×), 76,000 (2×), and 152,000 (4×) seeds acre −1 . Intercropping with MG7 increased soybean dry weight by 33% compared with MG1. The MG7 4× rate in 2012 and the 1× and 2× rates in 2013 maximized yield and LER when forage contained 7 to 10% soybean. Averaged over years, the MG7 soybean planting rate had a significant quadratic influence on nutrient value, peaking at the 2× rate at $23 ton -1 more than monoculture corn. Intercropping with the 2× MG7 soybean increased the net economic return per acre on a nutrient value basis by $238 acre −1 . The soybean concentration in the mix that produced the highest total dry matter yield 5 and 7% and 7 and 10% for gross economic return per acre in 2012 and 2013, respectively. On a tonnage only basis, intercropping 2× MG7 soybean increased yield and produced $26 acre −1 more profit than monoculture corn.Abbreviations: 1×, soybean seeding rate of 38,000 seeds per acre; 2×, soybean seeding rate of 76,000 seeds per acre; 4×, soybean seeding rate of 152,000 seeds per acre; ADF, acid detergent fiber; aNDF, ash-free neutral detergent fiber; CP, crude protein; LER, land equivalent ratio; MG, maturity group of soybean.