Local populations of Sulfolobus islandicus diverge genetically with geographical separation, and this has been attributed to restricted transfer of propagules imposed by the unfavorable spatial distribution of acidic geothermal habitat. We tested the generality of genetic divergence with distance in Sulfolobus species by analyzing genomes of Sulfolobus acidocaldarius drawn from three populations separated by more than 8000 km. In sharp contrast to S. islandicus, the geographically diverse S. acidocaldarius genomes proved to be nearly identical. We could not link the difference in genome conservation between the two species to a corresponding difference in genome stability or ecological factors affecting propagule dispersal. The results provide the first evidence that genetic isolation of local populations does not result primarily from properties intrinsic to Sulfolobus and the severe discontinuity of its geothermal habitat, but varies with species, and thus may reflect biotic interactions that act after propagule dispersal.

In order to analyze in molecular terms how genomes diverge, damage-induced mutations and natural polymorphisms (PMs) were identified in laboratory constructs and wild-type isolates, respectively, of Among wild-type isolates drawn from one local population, pairwise nucleotide divergence averaged 4 × 10, which is about 0.15% of the corresponding divergence reported for The most variable features of wild-type genomes were homopolymer (mononucleotide) tracts and longer tandem repeats, consistent with the spontaneous mutations that occur under laboratory conditions. Natural isolates, however, also revealed large insertions/deletions and inversions, which did not occur in any of the laboratory-manipulated strains. Several of the large insertions/deletions could be attributed to the integration or excision of mobile genetic elements (MGEs), and each MGE represented a distinct system of site-specific recombination. The mode of recombination associated with one MGE, a provirus related to , was also seen in certain chromosomal inversions. Artificially induced mutations, non-MGE insertions/deletions, and small PMs exhibited different distributions over the genome, suggesting that large-scale patterning of genomes begins early in the divergence process. Unlike induced mutations, natural base pair substitutions occurred in clusters, and one cluster exhibited properties expected of nonreciprocal recombination (gene conversion) between dispersed imperfect repeats. Taken together, the results identify simple replication errors, slipped-strand events promoted by tandem repeats, homologous recombination, and rearrangements promoted by MGEs as the primary sources of genetic variation for this extremely acidophilic archaeon in its geothermal environment. The optimal growth temperatures of hyperthermophilic archaea accelerate DNA decomposition, which is expected to make DNA repair especially important for their genetic stability, yet these archaea lack certain broadly conserved types of DNA repair proteins. In this study, the genome of the extreme thermoacidophile was found to be remarkably stable, accumulating few mutations in many (though not all) laboratory manipulations and in natural populations. Furthermore, all the genetic processes that were inferred to diversify these genomes also operate in mesophilic bacteria and eukaryotes. This suggests that a common set of mechanisms produces most of the genetic variation in all microorganisms, despite the fundamental differences in physiology, DNA repair systems, and genome structure represented in the three domains of life.

Hyperthermophilic archaea exhibit certain molecular-genetic features not seen in bacteria or eukaryotes, and their systems of homologous recombination (HR) remain largely unexplored in vivo. We transformed a Sulfolobus acidocaldarius pyrE mutant with short DNAs that contained multiple non-selected genetic markers within the pyrE gene. From 20 to 40% of the resulting colonies were found to contain two Pyr+ clones with distinct sets of the non-selected markers. The dual-genotype colonies could not be attributed to multiple DNAs entering the cells, or to conjugation between transformed and non-transformed cells. These colonies thus appear to represent genetic sectoring in which regions of heteroduplex DNA formed and then segregated after partial resolution of inter-strand differences. Surprisingly, sectoring was also frequent in cells transformed with single-stranded DNAs. Oligonucleotides produced more sectored transformants when electroporated as single strands than as a duplex, although all forms of donor DNA (positive-strand, negative-strand, and duplex) produced a diversity of genotypes, despite the limited number of markers. The marker patterns in the recombinants indicate that S. acidocaldarius resolves individual mismatches through un-coordinated short-patch excision followed by re-filling of the resulting gap. The conversion events that occur during transformation by single-stranded DNA do not show the strand bias necessary for a system that corrects replication errors effectively; similar events also occur in pre-formed heteroduplex electroporated into the cells. Although numerous mechanistic details remain obscure, the results demonstrate that the HR system of S. acidocaldarius can generate remarkable genetic diversity from short intervals of moderately diverged DNAs.

Although homologous recombination (HR) is known to influence the structure, stability, and evolution of microbial genomes, few of its functional properties have been measured in cells of hyperthermophilic archaea. The present study manipulated various properties of the parental DNAs in high-resolution assays of Sulfolobus acidocaldarius transformation, and measured the impact on the efficiency and pattern of marker transfer to the recipient chromosome. The relative orientation of homologous sequences, the type and position of chromosomal mutation being replaced, and the length of DNA flanking the marked region all affected the efficiency, linkage, tract continuity, and other parameters of marker transfer. Effects predicted specifically by the classical reciprocal-exchange model of HR were not observed. One analysis observed only 90 % linkage between markers defined by adjacent bases; in another series of experiments, sequence divergence up to 4 % had no detectable impact on overall efficiency of HR or on the co-transfer of a distal non-selected marker. The effects of introducing DNA via conjugation, rather than transformation, were more difficult to assess, but appeared to increase co-transfer (i.e. linkage) of relatively distant non-selected markers. The results indicate that HR events between gene-sized duplex DNAs and the S. acidocaldarius chromosome typically involve neither crossing over nor interference from a mismatch-activated anti-recombination system. Instead, the donor DNA may anneal to a transient chromosomal gap, as in the mechanism proposed for oligonucleotidemediated transformation of Sulfolobus and other micro-organisms.