Questions related to dinosaur behavior can be difficult to answer conclusively by using morphological studies alone. As a complement to these approaches, carbon and oxygen isotope ratios of tooth enamel can provide insight into habitat and dietary preferences of herbivorous dinosaurs. This approach is based on the isotopic variability in plant material and in surface waters of the past, which is in turn reflected by carbon and oxygen isotope ratios of animals that ingested the organic matter or drank the water. Thus, it has the potential to identify and characterize dietary and habitat preferences for coexisting taxa.In this study, stable isotope ratios from coexisting hadrosaurian and ceratopsian dinosaurs of the Hell Creek Formation of North Dakota are compared for four different stratigraphic levels. Isotopic offsets between tooth enamel and tooth dentine, as well as taxonomic differences in means and in patterns of isotopic data among taxa, indicate that primary paleoecological information is preserved. The existence of taxonomic offsets also provides the first direct evidence for dietary niche partitioning among these herbivorous dinosaur taxa. Of particular interest is the observation that the nature of this partitioning changes over time: for some localities ceratopsian dinosaurs have higher carbon and oxygen isotope ratios than hadrosaurs, indicating a preference for plants living in open settings near the coast, whereas for other localities isotope ratios are lower, indicating a preference for plants in the understory of forests. In most cases the isotope ratios among hadrosaurs are similar and are interpreted to represent a dietary preference for plants of the forest canopy. The inferred differences in ceratopsian behavior are suggested to represent a change in vegetation cover and hence habitat availability in response to sea level change or to the position of river distributaries. Given our current lack of taxonomic resolution, it is not possible to determine if dietary and habitat preferences inferred from stable isotope data are associated with single, or multiple, species of hadrosaurian/ceratopsian dinosaurs.
Field surveys of the Upper Cretaceous Hell Creek Formation in southwesternNorth Dakota since 1986 have produced a total of 10 124 specimens from 42 vertebrate microsites and an additional 41 dinosaur skulls or partial skeletons or skulls from separate sites representing 61 taxa of vertebrates dominated by fish, dinosaurs, turtles, and crocodilians. Common elements of this diverse fauna occur to within 2.37 m of the Cretaceous-Tertiary (K-T) boundary. The stratigraphically highest fossil in the study is a partial ceratopsian skeleton 1.77 m below the K-T boundary in the basal Fort Union Formation. All dinosaurs that occur at more than two sites also occur at the highest level that yielded more than 500 specimens (8.40 m below the K-T boundary). The fine-grained uppermost 2 m of the Hell Creek is nearly devoid of all fossils, including taxa known to occur in the overlying formation. The absence of channel deposits in this part of the formation may be the reason for the absence of fossil localities. The presence of marine-tolerant taxa suggests that the study area may have been adjacent to a previously unidentified seaway of latest Cretaceous age. Rarefaction analysis indicates no evidence for a decline in vertebrate diversity through the formation or dinosaurian diversity in the 3 m below the K-T boundary. Our results are not compatible with gradual vertebrate extinction at the end of the Cretaceous.
A nearly complete turtle shell from the Late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) Hell Creek Formation of Slope County, North Dakota, represents the most complete remains to date of a Mesozoic kinosternoid turtle and a new species, Hoplochelys clark nov. sp. The new taxon is diagnosable from other representatives of Hoplochelys by the plesiomorphic placement of the humeral/femoral sulcus behind the hyo/hypoplastral suture and the autapomorphic development of an interrupted median (neural) keel. All six previously named Paleocene (Puercan and Torrejonian) representatives of Hoplochelys lack diagnostic characters and are synonymized as Hoplochelys crassa. A phylogenetic analysis reveals that Hoplochelys spp. and Agomphus pectoralis are most parsimoniously placed within Kinosternoidea along the phylogenetic stem of the extant Mesoamerican River Turtle Dermatemys mawii, extending that taxon's stem lineage from the early Eocene to the late Maastrichtian. The two primary crown lineages of Kinosternoidea are thus known from the Mesozoic and split prior to the late Campanian. The presence of a thickened cruciform plastron, true costiform processes, only three inframarginals, and the reduction of the medial contact of the abdominals are synapomorphies of Chelydroidea, the clade formed by Chelydridae and Kinosternoidae.Keywords Hell Creek Formation Á North Dakota Á Maastrichtian Á Late Cretaceous Á Kinosternoidea Á Hoplochelys clark n. sp. Á Dermatemys mawii Kurzfassung Eine fast komplette Schildkrötenschale, die in der spätkretazischen (Maastrichtium) Hell Creek Formation in Slope County, Norddakota, gefunden wurde, stellt den bisher vollständigsten mesozoischen Rest einer kinosternoideen Schildkröte dar und wird hier als neue Art Hoplochelys clark beschrieben. Anhand der plesiomorphen Lage des humero/femoralen Sulcus hinter der hyo/hypoplastralen Sutur und des autapomorphisch unterbrochenen medianen Kiels kann die neue Schildkröte von anderen Hoplochelys Arten unterschieden werden. Allen sechs bisher bekannten Arten aus dem Paläozän (Puercium und Torrejonium) fehlen diagnostische Merkmale. Daher werden sie als Hoplochelys crassa synonymisiert. Die phylogenetische Analyse ergibt, dass es am sparsamsten ist, Hoplochelys spp. und Agomphus pectoralis entlang der
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.