Analytical methods are posing a significant technical challenge to meet low phosphorus limits.Research and testing showed that understanding the chemical species becomes a key to interpreting and improving technologies for phosphorus removal to very low limits. Phosphorus appears in wastewater in many forms such as orthophosphate, condensed phosphates, organic phosphorus, chemical phosphorus, and others. The phosphorus species change in wastewater treatment due to chemical and biological actions. Phosphorus species can be differentiated in terms of soluble and particulate forms as well as their reactivity under acid and heat. Phosphorus speciation was conducted to better understand the removal mechanisms and opportunities for process optimization.Reactive phosphorus measurements will delineate not only soluble orthophosphate but other reactive phosphorus species such as chemically precipitated phosphorus. This complicates the interpretation of analytical data. Separating the results into soluble and particulate fractions provide a simple and effective method to interpret results.Pilot studies have demonstrated that the removal efficiency of various phosphorus species is different for various treatment technologies. Characterization of phosphorus species including soluble and particulate phosphorus with different separation filter sizes, reactive and non-reactive species, provides insight into the treatment technology effectiveness and the application to achieve very low phosphorus concentrations. However, at this time it appears that practical removal of phosphorus to 10ug/L is beyond the ability of current technology.
Spokane River dischargers face restrictive phosphorus discharge limits that are technically challenging. A tertiary phosphorus removal pilot at the wastewater treatment plant was conducted between June and October 2006. Technologies from four different manufacturers were tested on their ability to reliably produce effluent total phosphorus (TP) concentrations of less than 50 µg/L and less then 10 µg/L. The demonstration pilot showed that effluent total phosphorus concentration of less than 50 µg/L can be produced by at least two of the tested technologies, Blue Water Technologies Blue Pro (DSBP) and Siemens Trident ® HS-1 (THS-1). While not fully demonstrated, GE (Zenon) ultrafiltration (ZW-500) and Parkson Incorporation Dual Sand (DSD2) would also likely be able to meet 50 µg/L. None of them showed ability to meet a 10 µg/L TP limit. While there were a number of days with 10 µg/L or less, they were few and far between.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.