Five cultivation systems for spring-sown barley were tested on a clay to sandy-clay loam for 4 years and their cumulative effects on soil and crop measured. Four primary cultivations in the autumn, shallow (7-5 cm), medium (15 cm) and deep (23 cm) tine cultivation and mouldboard ploughing (23 cm deep) followed in spring by secondary cultivations and sowing, were compared with direct drilling seed into uncultivated soil after controlling weeds with herbicides. At the same rates of seed and fertilizer for all systems, direct drilling and shallow cultivation yielded significantly less grain than deeper tillage in the second year only; over 4 years the differences in mean yield were small and non-significant. In terms of crop output per unit of implement net energy (estimated) direct drilling was eight times more efficient than ploughing.Direct drilling and shallow cultivation caused concentration gradients of ' available' phosphorus and potassium to form in the top soil. Soil strength and to a lesser extent bulk density were greater without than with cultivation but these changes had only a relatively small effect on root distribution in the profile. In untilled soil the proportion of the root system was less in the surface 2-5-12-5 cm and greater in the 12-5-32-5 cm horizon than in shallow or deep tilled soil.Mean nitrogen uptake by the crop in the third and fourth seasons was least in directdrilled barley probably due to lower rates of mineralization of soil nitrogen in compacted than tilled soil. It was deduced that for spring barley the' yield plateau' was the same for each system but that optimal rates of nitrogen would be higher for crops in untilled than tilled soils.
Physical measurements were made on the soil of a long-term cultivation experiment comparing direct drilling, tine cultivation and mouldboard ploughing for spring barley to investigate possible reasons for differences in yield. The soil was a typical argillio brown earth, approximately 90 cm of sandy clay loam topsoil and clay loam subsoil overlying magnesian limestone. For the three periods 1971-4, 1975-7 and 1978-80 the mean grain yields were marginally lower after direct drilling than after shallow cultivation or ploughing. There was an average decline in yield of 1-33 t/ha from the first to the last period, the decline being greater for direct drilling than the other two tillage systems.Although the surface horizon (0-5 cm) of direct-drilled soil had a higher content of organic matter than the ploughed, this did not increase the stability of the aggregates. Slaking tests had shown the soil to be inherently unstable and likely to suffer from structural problems. After the first 3 years bulk density of direct-drilled soil (0-15 cm) increased markedly to ca. l-5g/cm a and then remained relatively stable. In the ploughed soil, density increased steadily over the period to an average value of co.
Three constant and four variable heights of cutting were applied to swards of Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.) cv. Aberystwyth S. 22 and perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) cv. Aberystwyth S. 23 for a period of 2 years. The treatments were initially given in the seeding year of the Italian ryegrass swards and first harvest year of the perennial ryegrass. The same swards were used throughout the duration of the two experiments. The three heights of cutting 3, 6 and 9 cm were defined by the mean lengths of tiller remaining after defoliation with a flail harvester.The yield of dry matter (D.M.) was relatively low from Italian ryegrass cut repeatedly to 3 cm because many plants died. Higher yields were obtained by cutting repeatedly to 6 or 9 cm but only when the grass at the end of the season was cut to 3 cm. Italian ryegrass produced more herbage by variable than constant heights of cutting, especially when a lax cut occurred in mid-summer.Perennial ryegrass gave higher yields of D.M. by constant low than high cutting, but there were no differences in yield when the constant high cut swards were closely defoliated at the end of each season. More herbage was produced by variable than constant heights of cutting in the second year, especially when several lax cuts occurred in the variable height of cut treatments.As perennial ryegrass had a very prostrate growth habit in swards which received several close cuts tillers were not defoliated too severely. In contrast, Italian ryegrass remained erect in growth habit even in swards which were closely defoliated and thus tillers were cut more severely than those of perennial ryegrass. The need to measure accurately the actual lengths of tillers after defoliation is emphasized in height of cutting treatments.
SummarySoil disturbance caused by a slant-legged subsoiler (Trade name, ‘Paraplow’) and the duration of its effect was investigated in an experiment comparing long-term direct drilling with shallow tine cultivation and mouldboard ploughing. The ‘Paraplow’ significantly reduced soil strength, measured by cone resistance, to the depth of cultivation (33–35 cm) for up to 20 months, after which soil recompacted. The ‘Paraplow’ increased the volume of soil with cone resistance < 1·5 MPa by 52% within its working depth, compared with an equivalent depth of undisturbed soil. Contour diagrams of cone resistances clearly illustrate the patterns of soil loosening caused by the ‘Paraplow’.Measurements on soil cores (73 mm diameter × 50 mm) show that the ‘Paraplow’ did not appear to increase significantly the volume of macropores (> 60 μm) in direct-drilled soil, nor did it reduce the bulk density in the top 5 cm as effectively as the mouldboard plough.The root density of spring barley, measured at the beginning and end of tillering, was significantly increased within the horizon disturbed by the ‘Paraplow’ but below the depth of loosening there were no differences. This improvement of root growth probably resulted from an increase in the number of large pores (which could not be measured adequately in the soil cores), as well as the reduced soil strength. Better drainage of the soil loosened with the ‘Paraplow’ suggested that macroporosity was improved. The need to sample large volumes of soil to detect changes in bulk density and macroporosity is stressed.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.