The basicities of the diad H57-D102 at N(epsilon)2 in the tetrahedral complexes of chymotrypsin with the peptidyl trifluoromethyl ketones (TFK) N-acetyl-L-Leu-DL-Phe-CF3 and N-acetyl-DL-Phe-CF3 have been studied by 1H-NMR. The protons bridging His 57 and Asp 102 in these complexes are engaged in low-barrier hydrogen bonds (LBHBs). In 1H-NMR spectra at pH 7.0, these protons appear at delta 18.9 and 18.6 ppm, and the pK(a)s of the diads are 12.0 +/- 0.2 and 10.8 +/- 0.1, respectively. The difference indicates that removal of leucine from the second aminoacyl site S2 of chymotrypsin weakens the LBHB and decreases the basicity of the H57-D102 diad relative to the case in which S2 is occupied by leucine. Consideration of the available structural data on chymotrypsin and other serine proteases, together with the high pK(a)s of the hemiketals formed with TFKs, suggests that LBHB formation in catalysis arises through a substrate-induced conformational transition leading to steric compression between His 57 and Asp 102. Because the N-O distance in the LBHB is shorter than the Van der Waals contact distance, the LBHB is proposed to stabilize the tetrahedral intermediate through relief of steric strain between these residues. In this mechanism, substrate-induced steric compression within the diad increases the basicity of N(epsilon)2 in His 57, making it a more effective base for abstracting a proton from Ser 195 in the formation of the tetrahedral intermediate. The values of pK(a) for N(epsilon)2 in TFK adducts lie between those of Ser 195 (pK(a) approximately 14) and the leaving group in tetrahedral adducts (pK(a) approximately 9), making N(epsilon)2 of the H57-D102 diad strong enough as a base to abstract the proton from Ser 195 in tetrahedral adduct formation but not so strong that its conjugate acid cannot protonate the leaving group. According to this theory, the "normal" pK(a) of His 57 in free chymotrypsin arises from the use of part of the stabilization energy provided by the LBHB to drive the conformational compression required for its formation. In catalysis, the energy for conformational compression is supplied by the binding of remote portions of the substrate, including the side chains of P1 and P2.

No abstract

We present spectroscopic evidence for the presence of low-barrier hydrogen bonds (LBHBs) in molecular complexes composed of carboxylic acids and 1-methylimidazole (1-MeIm) dissolved in aprotic organic solvents. A plot of the values of the low-field proton NMR chemical shifts versus the aqueous pKa of the carboxylic acid exhibits a positive slope for pKa values below 2.1 and a negative slope for higher pKa values. The chemical shifts for protons near the maximum in this plot are 18 ppm, similar to that of 18.3 ppm for His57-Asp102 in the protonated catalytic triad of chymotrypsin. The chemical shifts for the proton bonded to C2 of 1-MeIm in these complexes also vary with the pKa of the carboxylic acid and reveal a gradual change from neutral, hydrogen-bonded 1-MeIm in complexes of weaker acids to hydrogen-bonded 1-methylimidazolium ion in complexes of stronger acids. The midpoint chemical shift for the C2 proton corresponds to a carboxylic aqueous pKa of about 2.1. FTIR spectra of the 1-MeIm-carboxylic acid complexes in CHCl3 indicate that hydrogen bonding is strong and that the complexes are of three types: (a) neutral complexes with the weaker acids (pKa > or = 2.2) in which the antisymmetric carbonyl stretching frequencies are lowered relative to the free acids and the ethyl esters of the same acids; (b) ionic complexes of stronger acids (pKa < or = 2.1) in which the carbonyl stretching frequencies are slightly lower than those for the tetrabutylammonium salts of the same acids; (c) ionic complexes of the same acids (pKa < or = 2.1) coexisting with type b, in which the carbonyl stretching frequencies are intermediate between those for the tetrabutylammonium salts (bond order 1.5) and those of the same acids or their esters (bond order 2.0). The latter complexes appear to incorporate a low-barrier hydrogen bond and are presented as models for the protonated triad of chymotrypsin and other serine proteases. These enzymes have been postulated to utilize a low-barrier hydrogen bond between His57 and Asp102 to facilitate the abstraction of the beta-OH proton from Ser195 in the course of catalysis [Frey, P.A., Whitt, S.A., & Tobin, J.B. (1994) Science (Washington, D.C.)264,1927-1930].

The basicity of His 57-Nepsilon2 within the low-barrier hydrogen-bonded (LBHB) diad His 57-Asp 102 and the 1H NMR chemical shift of the LBHB proton in tetrahedral, hemiketal complexes of chymotrypsin with peptidyl trifluoromethyl ketones (peptidyl-TFKs) have been studied. The following results were obtained with various peptidyl-TFKs at 5 degrees C: N-Ac-Gly-DL-Phe-CF3, pKa = 11.1 and deltaLBHB = 18.7 ppm; N-Ac-L-Val-DL-Phe-CF3, pKa = 11.8 and deltaLBHB = 18.9 ppm; N-Ac-L-Leu-DL-Val-CF3, pKa = 10.3 and deltaLBHB = 18.9 ppm; and N-Ac-L-Leu-DL-naphthyl-CF3, pKa = 10.9 and deltaLBHB = 19.0 ppm. Results for peptidyl-TFKs with Phe in the P1 position and N-Ac, N-Ac-Gly, N-Ac-L-Val, and N-Ac-L-Leu in the P2 position were well correlated with literature values for inhibition constants Ki and kcat/Km for the corresponding peptidyl methyl esters. The plot of log Ki versus the apparent pKa of His 57-Nepsilon2 displayed a slope of -0.77, and that of log kcat/Km for peptidyl methyl esters versus the pKa of His 57-Nepsilon2 in corresponding peptidyl-TFK complexes gave a slope of 0.68. The slope of a plot of pKa versus deltaLBHB was 3.7, and that of log kcat/Km for peptidyl methyl ester substrates versus deltaLBHB for the corresponding peptidyl-TFK-chymotrypsin complexes was 2.7. A plot of log Ki versus deltaLBHB displayed a slope of -3.0. These plots indicated that the pKa of His 57 and substrate reactivity were correlated with increasing strength of the low-barrier hydrogen bond. The apparent pKa of His 57-Nepsilon2 for the chymotrypsin-N-Ac-L-Leu-DL-Phe-CF3 complex is 10.6 at 25 degrees C, whereas it is 12.0 at 5 degrees C [Cassidy, C. S., Lin, J. L., and Frey, P. A. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 4576-4584]. The apparent discrepancy is likely to be due to a temperature dependence in the cooperative ionization of His 57 in peptidyl-TFK complexes, which appears to be coupled to inhibitor dissociation, hydration and ionization of free peptidyl-TFK, ionization of Ile 16, and a conformational change.

The structures of the hemiketal adducts of Ser 195 in chymotrypsin with N-acetyl-L-leucyl-L-phenylalanyl trifluoromethyl ketone (AcLF-CF3) and N-acetyl-L-phenylalanyl trifluoromethyl ketone (AcF-CF3) were determined to 1.4-1.5 A by X-ray crystallography. The structures confirm those previously reported at 1.8-2.1 A [Brady, K., Wei, A., Ringe, D., and Abeles, R. H. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 7600-7607]. The 2.6 A spacings between Ndelta1 of His 57 and Odelta1 of Asp 102 are confirmed at 1.3 A resolution, consistent with the low-barrier hydrogen bonds (LBHBs) between His 57 and Asp 102 postulated on the basis of spectroscopy and deuterium isotope effects. The X-ray crystal structure of the hemiacetal adduct between Ser 195 of chymotrypsin and N-acetyl-L-leucyl-L-phenylalanal (AcLF-CHO) has also been determined at pH 7.0. The structure is similar to the AcLF-CF3 adduct, except for the presence of two epimeric adducts in the R- and S-configurations at the hemiacetal carbons. In the (R)-hemiacetal, oxygen is hydrogen bonded to His 57, not the oxyanion site. On the basis of the downfield 1H NMR spectrum in solution, His 57 is not protonated at Nepsilon2, and there is no LBHB at pH >7.0. Because addition of AcLF-CHO to chymotrypsin neither releases nor takes up a proton from solution, it is concluded that the hemiacetal oxygen of the chymotrypsin-AcLF-CHO complex is a hydroxyl group and not attracted to the oxyanion site. The protonation states of the hemiacetal and His 57 are explained by the high basicity of the hemiacetal oxygen (pK(a) > 13.5) relative to that of His 57. The 13C NMR signal for the adduct of AcLF-13CHO with chymotrypsin is consistent with a neutral hemiacetal between pH 7 and 13. At pH <7.0, His 57 in the AcLF-CHO-hemiacetal complex of chymotrypsin undergoes protonation at Nepsilon2 of His 57, leading to a transition of the 15.1 ppm downfield signal to 17.8 ppm. The pK(a)s in the active sites of the AcLF-CF3 and AcLF-CHO adducts suggest an energy barrier of 6-7 kcal x mol(-1) against ionizations that change the electrostatic charge at the active site. However, ionizations of neutral His 57 in the AcLF-CHO-chymotrypsin adduct, or in free chymotrypsin, proceed with no apparent barrier. Protonation of His 57 is accompanied by LBHB formation, suggesting that stabilization by the LBHB overcomes the barrier to ionization. On the basis of the hydration constant for AcLF-13CHO and its inhibition constant, its K(d) is 16 microM, 8000-fold larger than the comparable value for AcLF-CF3.