Gas modulation refractometry (GAMOR) is a methodology that can mitigate fluctuations and drifts in refractometry. This can open up for the use of non-conventional cavity spacer materials. In this paper, we report a dual-cavity system based on Invar that shows better precision for assessment of pressure than a similar system based on Zerodur. This refractometer shows for empty cavity measurements, up to 10 4 s, a white noise response (for N 2 ) of 3 mPa s 1 / 2 . At 4303 Pa, the system has a minimum Allan deviation of 0.34 mPa (0.08 ppm) and a long-term stability (24 h) of 0.7 mPa. This shows that the GAMOR methodology allows for the use of alternative cavity materials.
By measuring the refractivity and the temperature of a gas, its pressure can be calculated from fundamental principles. The most sensitive instruments are currently based on Fabry–Perot cavities where a laser is used to probe the frequency of a cavity mode. However, for best accuracy, the realization of such systems requires exceptional mechanical stability. Gas modulation refractometry (GAMOR) has previously demonstrated an impressive ability to mitigate the influence of fluctuations and drifts whereby it can provide high-precision (sub-ppm, i.e., sub-parts-per-million or sub-10−6) assessment of gas refractivity and pressure. In this work, two independent GAMOR-based refractometers are individually characterized, compared to each other, and finally compared to a calibrated dead weight piston gauge with respect to their abilities to assess pressure in the 4–25 kPa range. The first system, referred to as the stationary optical pascal (SOP), uses a miniature fixed point gallium cell to measure the temperature. The second system, denoted the transportable optical pascal (TOP), relies on calibrated Pt-100 sensors. The expanded uncertainty for assessment of pressure (k=2) was estimated to, for the SOP and TOP, [(10mPa)2+(10×10−6P)2]1/2 and [(16mPa)2+(28×10−6P)2]1/2, respectively. While the uncertainty of the SOP is mainly limited by the uncertainty in the molar polarizability of nitrogen (8 ppm), the uncertainty of the TOP is dominated by the temperature assessment (26 ppm). To verify the long-term stability, the systems were compared to each other over a period of 5 months. It was found that all measurements fell within the estimated expanded uncertainty (k=2) for comparative measurements (27 ppm). This verified that the estimated error budget for the uncorrelated errors holds over this extensive period of time.
Gas Modulation Refractometry (GAMOR) has recently been developed to mitigate drifts in the length of the cavities in Dual-Fabry-Perot Cavity (DFPC) based refractometry. By performing repeated reference assessments with the measurement cavity being evacuated while the reference cavity is held at a constant pressure, the methodology can reduce the influence of the long-term drifts, allowing it to benefit from the high precision of DFPCbased refractometry at short time scales. A novel realization of GAMOR, referred to as Gas Equilibration GAMOR (GEq-GAMOR), that outperforms the original realization of GAMOR, here referred to as Single Cavity Modulated GAMOR (SCM-GAMOR), is presented. It is based upon the fact that the reference measurements are carried out by equalizing the pressures in the two cavities. By this, the time it takes to reach adequate 2 conditions for the reference measurements has been reduced. This implies that a larger fraction of the measurement cycle can be devoted to data acquisition, which reduces white noise and improves on its short-term characteristics. The presented realization also encompasses a new cavity design with improved temperature stabilization and assessment. This has contributed to an improved long-term characteristics of the GAMOR methodology. The system was characterized with respect to a dead weight piston gauge. It was found that for short integration times (up to 10 min) it can provide a response that exceeds that of the original SCM-GAMOR system by a factor of two. For integration times longer than this, and up to 18 hours, the system shows, for a pressure of 4303 Pa, an integration time independent Allan deviation of 1 mPa (corresponding to a precision, defined as twice the Allan deviation, of 0.5 ppm). This implies that the novel system shows a significant improvement with respect to the original realization of GAMOR for all integration times (by a factor of 8 for an integration time of 18 hours).When used for low pressures, it can provide a precision in the sub-mPa region; for the case with an evacuated measurement cavity, the system provided, up to ca. 40 measurement cycles (ca. 1.5 hours), a white-noise limited noise of 0.7 mPa (cycle) 1/2 , and minimum Allan deviation of 0.15 mPa. Furthermore, over the pressure range investigated, i.e. in the 2.8 -10.1 kPa range, it shows, with respect to a dead weight piston gauge, a purely linear response. This implies that the system can be used for transfer of calibration over large pressure ranges with exceptional low uncertainty.3
A novel procedure for a robust assessment of cavity deformation in Fabry–Pérot (FP) refractometers is presented. It is based on scrutinizing the difference between two pressures: one assessed by the uncharacterized refractometer and the other provided by an external pressure reference system, at a series of set pressures for two gases with dissimilar refractivity (here, He and N2). By fitting linear functions to these responses and extracting their slopes, it is possible to construct two physical entities of importance: one representing the cavity deformation and the other comprising a combination of the systematic errors of a multitude of physical entities, viz., those of the assessed temperature, the assessed or estimated penetration depth of the mirror, the molar polarizabilities, and the set pressure. This provides a robust assessment of cavity deformation with small amounts of uncertainties. A thorough mathematical description of the procedure is presented that serves as a basis for the evaluation of the basic properties and features of the procedure. The analysis indicates that the cavity deformation assessments are independent of systematic errors in both the reference pressure and the assessment of gas temperature and when the gas modulation refractometry methodology is used that they are insensitive to gas leakages and outgassing into the system. It also shows that when a high-precision (sub-ppm) refractometer is characterized according to the procedure, when high purity gases are used, the uncertainty in the deformation contributes to the uncertainty in the assessment of pressure of N2 with solely a fraction (13%) of the uncertainty of its molar polarizability, presently to a level of a few ppm. This implies, in practice, that cavity deformation is no longer a limiting factor in FP-based refractometer assessments of pressure of N2.
By measuring the refractivity and the temperature of a gas, its pressure can be assessed from fundamental principles. The highest performing instruments are based on Fabry-Perot cavities (FPC). Gas modulation refractometry (GAMOR)is a methodology that has the ability to reduce the influence of disturbances to such an extent that high-precision (sub-parts-per-million) assessments of pressure can be made by the use of FPCs of Invar. To allow for high accuracy assessments, it is of importance to assess the uncertainty contribution from the thermodynamic effects that are associated with the gas filling and emptying of the cavity (pV work). This paper presents a detailed scrutiny of the influence of the gas exchange process on the assessment of gas temperature on an Invar-based dual-FPC (DFPC) instrumentation. It is shown that by virtue of a combination of a number of carefully selected design entities (a small cavity volume with a bore radius of 3 mm, a spacer material with high heat capacitance, large thermal conductivity, and no regions that are connected with low thermal conductance, i.e. no heat islands, and a continuous assessment of temperature of the cavity spacer) the system is not significantly affected by pV work. Simulations show that 10 s after the filling all temperature gradients in the system are well into the sub-mK range. Experiments support that refractivity assessments initiated after 40 s are not significantly affected by the pV work. The analysis given in this work indicates that an upper limit for the influence of pV work on the Invar-based DFPC system using 100 s long gas modulation cycles is 0.5 mK/100 kPa (or 1.8ppm/100 kPa). Consequently, thermodynamic effects will not be a limiting factor when the Invar-based DFPC GAMOR system is used for assessments of pressure or as a primary pressure standard up to atmospheric pressures.
An Invar-based Fabry-Perot cavity refractometer equipped with an automated, miniaturized gallium fixed-point cell for assessment of pressure is presented. The use of an Invar cavity spacer has previously demonstrated pressure assessments with sub-0.1 ppm precision. The fixed-point cell, whose design and implementation are presented here, provides a reference for temperature assessment of the gas inside the cavity with an uncertainty of 4 ppm. This opens up for a self-contained system for realization of the Pascal with an accuracy in the low ppm range. This is an important step towards disseminating the Pascal through fundamental principles.
Refractometry is a powerful technique for pressure assessments that, due to the recent redefinition of the SI system, also offers a new route to realizing the SI unit of pressure, the Pascal. Gas modulation refractometry (GAMOR) is a methodology that has demonstrated an outstanding ability to mitigate the influences of drifts and fluctuations, leading to long-term precision in the 10−7 region. However, its short-term performance, which is of importance for a variety of applications, has not yet been scrutinized. To assess this, we investigated the short-term performance (in terms of precision) of two similar, but independent, dual Fabry–Perot cavity refractometers utilizing the GAMOR methodology. Both systems assessed the same pressure produced by a dead weight piston gauge. That way, their short-term responses were assessed without being compromised by any pressure fluctuations produced by the piston gauge or the gas delivery system. We found that the two refractometer systems have a significantly higher degree of concordance (in the 10−8 range at 1 s) than what either of them has with the piston gauge. This shows that the refractometry systems under scrutiny are capable of assessing rapidly varying pressures (with bandwidths up to 2 Hz) with precision in the 10−8 range.
The 18SIB04 QuantumPascal EMPIR project aims for development of photon-based standards that can replace primary standards of the SI unit of pressure, the Pascal. In this project, four partners simulated the pressure-induced deformation of a given Fabry-Pérot cavity, using various versions of two types of software, COMSOL Multiphysics (R) and ANSYS Workbench. It was demonstrated that, for a given geometry and set of material parameters, simulations of the deformation could be performed by the various partners with such small discrepancies that methodological mistakes of the simulation procedures will solely contribute to a sub-ppm uncertainty in the assessments of refractivity of N<sub>2</sub>.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.