Fossil palms provide qualitative evidence of (sub-) tropical conditions and frost-free winters in the geological past, including modern cold climate regions (e.g., boreal, or polar climates). The freeze intolerance of palms varies across different organs and life stages, with seedlings in particular less tolerant of sub-zero temperatures than adult plants, limiting successful establishment of populations while permitting adult palms to survive in cultivation outside their natural ranges. Quantitatively, palms indicate minimum cold month mean temperature (CMMT) at 2–8 °C in palaeoclimate reconstructions. These data have accentuated model-proxy mismatches for high latitudes during Paleogene hyperthermals when palms expanded poleward in both hemispheres. We constructed a manually filtered dataset of >20,000 georeferenced Arecaceae records, by eliminating cultivars. Statistically derived mean annual temperature, mean annual temperature range, and CMMT thresholds for the Arecaceae and lower rank subfamilies and tribes reveal large differences in temperature sensitivity depending on lower taxonomic classification. Cold tolerant tribes such as the Trachycarpeae produce thresholds as low as CMMT ≥ 2.2 °C. However, within the palm family, CMMT < 5 °C is anomalous. Moreover, palm expansion into temperate biomes is likely a post-Palaeogene event. We recognize a CMMT ≥ 5.2 °C threshold for the palm family, unless a lower taxonomic rank can be assigned.
Abstract. Early Eocene climates were globally warm, with ice-free conditions
at both poles. Early Eocene polar landmasses supported extensive forest
ecosystems of a primarily temperate biota but also with abundant
thermophilic elements, such as crocodilians, and mesothermic taxodioid
conifers and angiosperms. The globally warm early Eocene was punctuated by
geologically brief hyperthermals such as the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal
Maximum (PETM), culminating in the Early Eocene Climatic Optimum (EECO),
during which the range of thermophilic plants such as palms extended into
the Arctic. Climate models have struggled to reproduce early Eocene Arctic
warm winters and high precipitation, with models invoking a variety of
mechanisms, from atmospheric CO2 levels that are unsupported by proxy
evidence to the role of an enhanced hydrological cycle, to reproduce winters
that experienced no direct solar energy input yet remained wet and above
freezing. Here, we provide new estimates of climate and compile existing
paleobotanical proxy data for upland and lowland midlatitude sites in
British Columbia, Canada, and northern Washington, USA, and from
high-latitude lowland sites in Alaska and the Canadian Arctic to compare
climatic regimes between the middle and high latitudes of the early
Eocene – spanning the PETM to the EECO – in the northern half of North
America. In addition, these data are used to reevaluate the latitudinal
temperature gradient in North America during the early Eocene and to provide
refined biome interpretations of these ancient forests based on climate and
physiognomic data.
The upper Paleocene to lower Eocene Margaret Formation exposed at Stenkul Fiord on southern Ellesmere Island, Nunavut, Canada, represents a nearly continuous terrestrial succession of microfossilrich clastic sediments and coal. These strata were deposited at a time of extensive tectonic activity associated with Eurekan deformation. The precise chronology of the Eurekan deformation is poorly known. Prior studies at Stenkul Fiord provided a stratigraphic overview and relative age estimates for exposed strata but lack the absolute age control required to investigate the timing of deformation events. Strata at Stenkul Fiord preserve evidence of Arctic forests that may have grown during hyperthermal events that characterized the Paleogene, namely, the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) and Eocene Thermal Maximum 2 (ETM2). A quantitative palynological approach is herein used to define a new higher-resolution biostratigraphic framework for the Margaret Formation strata at Stenkul Fiord. This resulting improved biostratigraphic framework is integrated with new absolute age control of 53.7 ± 0.06 Ma provided by U-Pb ID-TIMS of zircon preserved in an ash bed within the studied succession. Nine pollen zones are defined based on cluster analysis, NMDS ordination, firstand last occurrences of taxa, and angiosperm pollen taxa diversity (H 0 ). The presence of thermophilic pollen taxa at Stenkul Fiord provides evidence of climates related to the globally warm climates during the early Paleogene.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.