The CD28-specific mAb TGN1412 rapidly caused a life-threatening “cytokine storm” in all six healthy volunteers in the Phase I clinical trial of this superagonist, signaling a failure of preclinical safety testing. We report novel in vitro procedures in which TGN1412, immobilized in various ways, is presented to human white blood cells in a manner that stimulates the striking release of cytokines and profound lymphocyte proliferation that occurred in vivo in humans. The novel procedures would have predicted the toxicity of this superagonist and are now being applied to emerging immunotherapeutics and to other therapeutics that have the potential to act upon the immune system. Data from these novel procedures, along with data from in vitro and in vivo studies in nonhuman primates, suggest that the dose of TGN1412 given to human volunteers was close to the maximum immunostimulatory dose and that TGN1412 is not a superagonist in nonhuman primates.

In 2006, a life-threatening 'cytokine storm', not predicted by pre-clinical safety testing, rapidly occurred in all six healthy volunteers during the phase I clinical trial of the CD28 superagonist monoclonal antibody (mAb) TGN1412. To date, no unequivocal explanation for the failure of TGN1412 to stimulate profound cytokine release in vitro or in vivo in species used for pre-clinical safety testing has been established. Here, we have identified a species difference almost certainly responsible for this disparate immunopharmacology. EXPERIMENTAL APPROACHPolychromatic flow cytometry and intracellular cytokine staining were employed to dissect the in vitro immunopharmacology of TGN1412 and other therapeutic mAbs at the cellular level to identify differences between humans and species used for pre-clinical safety testing. KEY RESULTSIn vitro IL-2 and IFN-g release from CD4+ effector memory T-cells were key indicators of a TGN1412-type response. This mechanism of cytokine release differed from that of other therapeutic mAbs, which can cause adverse reactions, because these other mAbs stimulate cytokine release primarily from natural killer cells. In contrast to humans, CD28 is not expressed on the CD4+ effector memory T-cells of all species used for pre-clinical safety testing, so cannot be stimulated by TGN1412. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONSIt is likely that activation of CD4+ effector memory T-cells by TGN1412 was responsible for the cytokine storm. Lack of CD28 expression on the CD4+ effector memory T-cells of species used for pre-clinical safety testing of TGN1412 offers an explanation for the failure to predict a 'cytokine storm' in humans.

SUMMARYWe have screened for spontaneous anticytokine autoantibodies in patients with infections, neoplasms and autoimmune diseases, because of their increasingly reported co-occurrence. We tested for both binding and neutralizing autoantibodies to a range of human cytokines, including interleukin-1alpha (IL-1 a ), IL-1 b , IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, IL-12, IL-18, interferon-alpha2 (IFN-a 2), IFN-w , IFN-b , IFN-g , tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-a ), transforming growth factor beta-1 (TGF-b 1) and granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), in plasmas or sera. With two notable exceptions described below, we found only occasional, mostly low-titre, non-neutralizing antibodies, mainly to GM-CSF; also to IL-10 in pemphigoid. Strikingly, however, high-titre, mainly IgG, autoantibodies to IFN-a 2, IFN-w and IL-12 were common at diagnosis in patients with late-onset myasthenia gravis (LOMG + ), thymoma (T) but no MG (TMG -) and especially with both thymoma and MG together (TMG + ). The antibodies recognized other closely related type I IFN-a subtypes, but rarely the distantly related type I IFN-b , and never (detectably) the unrelated type II IFN-g . Antibodies to IL-12 showed a similar distribution to those against IFN-a 2, although prevalences were slightly lower; correlations between individual titres against each were so modest that they appear to be entirely different specificities. Neither showed any obvious correlations with clinical parameters including thymoma histology and HLA type, but they did increase sharply if the tumours recurred. These antibodies neutralized their respective cytokine in bioassays in vitro ; although they persisted for years severe infections were surprisingly uncommon, despite the immunosuppressive therapy also used in most cases. These findings must hold valuable clues to autoimmunizing mechanisms in paraneoplastic autoimmunity.

Some adverse reactions to the transfusion of platelet concentrates (PCs) cannot be attributed to antibodies against blood cells or to subclinical microbial agents. It has been suggested that leucocyte-derived inflammatory cytokines such as interleukin (IL)-1, IL-6 and tumour necrosis factor (TNF) may contribute to a larger number of unexplained non-antibody-mediated adverse reactions. Three types of PCs, containing different levels of leucocytes, are currently produced. Filtration is used on demand to further reduce leucocyte contamination of these components. we have monitored the plasma of PCs prepared by the platelet-rich plasma method (PRP), the buffy-coat method or by apheresis for IL-6, IL-1, transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), TNF and interferon gamma (IFN gamma). Biologically active IL-6 increased in stored PRP-PCs from a mean of 140 pg/ml on day 1 to 2395 pg/ml on day 5/6. Elevated levels of IL-8, as detected by immunoassay, were evident in PRP-PCs during routine storage under blood bank conditions. Small amounts of immunoreactive IL-1 with only minimal biological activity were present in some PRP-PCs by day 5/6. No significant increase in the levels of IL-8, IL-6 or IL-1 were seen in buffy-coat PCs during storage for 5/6 d. For apheresis PCs, an increase in IL-8 content, but not in IL-6 over 6 d was observed. In all three types of PCs, elevated amounts of both bioactive and immunoreactive TGF beta were present, but there was no evidence of any biologically active or immunoreactive TNF alpha. Pre-storage filtration of PRP-PCs for depletion of leucocytes prevented the increase in IL-8 and IL-6 levels of these PCs. Our results show that leucocyte reduction by buffy-coat method reduces cytokine levels to a comparable level to filtered or apheresis PCs, containing low levels of leucocytes, but use of these PCs in minimizing the severity and incidence of reactions in recipients will require clinical evaluation. This is the first comprehensive and comparative study which, on the basis of biological activity of cytokines, directly indicates that the mode of platelet production grossly influences the levels of cytokines.

No abstract