Due to their high degree of fluorination, highly fluorinated compounds (HFCs) have unique substance properties that differ from many other organic contaminants. To predict the environmental behavior of HFCs, models that predict both absorptive and adsorptive partitioning are needed; however, the accuracy of existing models has not heretofore been thoroughly investigated for these compounds. This report has two parts: first we show that a well-established polyparameter linear free energy relationship used to predict experimental adsorption constants underestimates values for HFCs by several orders of magnitude. We found a mechanistic explanation for the model's inaccuracy and adjusted it accordingly. In the second part of this report, we evaluate various models that predict saturated subcooled liquid vapor pressure (pL*), air-water partition constant (Kaw), and the octanol-water partition constant (Kow) based on molecular structure. These parameters are typically required for general environmental fate and transport models. Here, we found that SPARC and COSMOtherm make predictions usually within 1 order of magnitude of the experimental value, while the commonly used EPI SUITE and ClogP perform more inaccurately. The least accurate predictions occurred with ClogP for the fluorotelomer alcohols, where the estimated values were off by 2 to almost 5 orders of magnitude.
In this work we present a dataset of more than 1000 natural organic matter (NOM)/air partition coefficients covering polar and nonpolar organic compounds measured in 10 different humic and fulvic acids (HAs/FAs) from terrestrial and aquatic origins. Differences of more than 1 order of magnitude in the sorption coefficients of a given compound measured in HAs and FAs from different origins were found. The terrestrial HAs exhibited substantially higher sorption coefficients compared to aquatic HAs and FAs. The difference between any two types of NOM is mainly reflected by a constant shift in the partition coefficients that applies to all compounds in the same way. This indicates that it is the number of available sorption sites per mass of sorbent rather than the types of intermolecular interactions between the sorbate and the sorbent that governs the major differences between the sorption properties of various types of NOM. The experimental partition coefficients measured in all HAs and FAs were successfully described by polyparameter linear free energy relationships (pp-LFERs) that explicitly account for van der Waals as well as H-donor/acceptor interactions between the sorbate and the sorbent. These pp-LFER equations provide for the first time a tool that allows including the variability of the sorption properties of NOM in environmental fate models.
In a recent publication we presented experimental Leonardite humic acid/air partition coefficients for 188 polar and nonpolar organic compounds measured with one consistent method. In this paper these experimental data are evaluated with various model predictions. For the PcKocWIN model some major shortcomings become apparent. The octanol-based Karickhoff-model exhibits a good performance for the nonpolar compounds but not for the polar ones. A good description of the whole data set is achieved with a polyparameter linear free energy relationship (pp-LFER) that explicitly accounts for the nonpolar (van der Waals and cavity formation) and polar (electron donor/acceptor) interactions between the sorbate molecule and the sorbent phase. With this pp-LFER model, most of the humic acid/air partition coefficients could be predicted within a factor of 2. The pp-LFER model also successfully predicts organic-C/water partition coefficients (K(ioc)) collected from the literature when it is combined with a pp-LFER for air/water partition coefficients. This supports our earlier conclusion that the thermodynamic cycle is applicable in the humic acid/water/air system. Based on our experimental data, we present a pp-LFER-model for humic acid/air and humic acid/water partitioning at any ambient temperatures.
The environmental fate of volatile and semivolatile organic compounds is determined by their partitioning between air and soil constituents, in particular soil organic matter (SOM). While there are many studies on the partitioning of nonpolar compounds between water and SOM, data on sorption of polar compounds and data for sorption from the gas phase are rather limited. In this study, Leonardite humic acid/air partition coefficients for 188 polar and nonpolar organic compounds at temperatures between 5 and 75 degrees C and relative humidities between < 0.01% and 98% have been determined using a dynamic flow-through technique. To the best of our knowledge, this is by far the largest and most diverse and consistent data set for sorption into humic material published so far. The major results are as follows: the relative humidity affected the experimental partition coefficients by up to a factor of 3; polar compounds generally sorbed more strongly than nonpolar compounds due to H-bonding (electron donor/ acceptor interactions) with the humic acid; no glass transitions in the range of 5-75 degrees C that would be relevant with respect to the sorption behavior of hydrated Leonardite humic acid were observed; our experimental data agree well with experimental partition coefficients from various literature sources.
Classical approaches for predicting soil organic matter partition coefficients of organic compounds require a calibration with experimental partition data and, for good accuracy, experimental compound descriptors. In this study we evaluate the quantum chemical model COSMO-RS in its COSMOtherm implementation for the prediction of about 200 experimental Leonardite humic acid/air partition coefficients without calibration or experimental compound descriptors, but simply based on molecular structures. For this purpose a Leonardite Humic Acid model monomer limited to 31 carbon atoms was derived from 13C NMR analysis, elemental analysis, and acidic function analysis provided in the literature. Altogether the COSMOtherm calculations showed a good performance and we conclude that it may become a very promising tool for the prediction of sorption in soil organic matter for compounds for which the molecular structure is the only reliable information available. COSMOtherm can be expected to be very robust with respectto new and complex compound structures because its calculations are based on a fundamental assessment of the underlying intermolecular forces. In contrast, other empirical models that are also based on the molecular structure of the sorbate have an application domain that is limited by their calibration data set that is often unknown to the user.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
customersupport@researchsolutions.com
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.