No abstract

Various ecomorphs of the shallow-water Cisco Coregonus artedi were the dominant fish planktivores in each of the Great Lakes until invasive species and overfishing resulted in extirpations and extinctions. In this paper, we describe the present morphological diversity and distribution of shallow-water Ciscoes in each of Lake Huron's three basins: the main basin, Georgian Bay, and the North Channel. Typical artedi, a formerly widespread ecomorph that had supported the lake's largest fishery, appears to have been extirpated from all three basins. Three types of shorthead cisco, a recently described and variable ecomorph, were extant. One type was morphologically robust and abundant along the north rim of the lake. The second type was large bodied, terete (streamlined), short finned, and collected at only one location in the main basin. The third type consisted of putative shorthead cisco × typical artedi hybrids, which were widespread in Georgian Bay and the North Channel. Only the putative hybrids were regularly collected in midwater trawls, suggesting that they were more pelagic, which we attribute to an inferred partial ancestry with typical artedi. The putative shorthead cisco × typical artedi hybrids of Georgian Bay and the North Channel have replaced typical artedi to some degree, while shorthead ciscoes in the main basin, though possibly more abundant now than in the past, have not measurably replaced typical artedi. Even with the apparent extirpation of typical artedi, Lake Huron has a greater diversity of shallow-water Ciscoes than any of the other Great Lakes, which we attribute to its more complex topography.

Objective: Here we determine how traditional morphometrics (TM) compares with geometric morphometrics (GM) in discriminating among morphologies of four forms of ciscoes of the Coregonus artedi complex collected from Lake Huron.Methods: One of the forms comprised two groups of the same deepwater cisco separated by capture depth, whereas the other three forms were shallow-water ciscoes.Result: Our three groups of shallow-water ciscoes were better separated (3% vs. 19% overlap) in principle component analysis (PCA) with TM data than with GM data incorporating semilandmarks (evenly spaced nonhomologous landmarks used to bridge between widely separated homologous landmarks). Our two deepwater cisco groups, comprising a putatively single form collected from different depths, separated more in PCAs with GM data (33% overlap) than in PCAs with TM data (66% overlap), an anomaly caused by greater decompression of the swim bladder and deformation of the body wall in the group captured at greater depths. Separation of the two deepwater cisco groups captured at different depths was not affected by the removal of semilandmarks. Assignment of forms using canonical variate analysis accurately assigned 86% of individuals using TM data, 98% of individuals using GM data incorporating semilandmarks, and 100% of individuals using GM data without semilandmarks. However, we considered assignments from the same form of deepwater cisco into separate groups as misassignments resulting from different capture depths, which reduced the accuracy of assignments with GM data incorporating semilandmarks to 66%. Conclusion:Our study implies that TM will continue to have an important role in morphological discrimination within Coregonus and other fishes similarly shaped.

No abstract

Age-0 lake whitefish Coregonus clupeaformis stomachs from western Lake Huron were examined in 2018 to evaluate spatial variation in feeding ecology. Overall, age-0 lake whitefish had narrow diet niches and similar feeding strategies across sites in western Lake Huron, with all sizes of age-0 lake whitefish specializing on one prey at each site, with some other prey eaten occasionally by most individuals as fish grew at some sites. Although prey selectivity and the dominant prey types varied among sites, feeding success was generally similar among sites for most sizes of fish. For fish collected in neuston nets (13-21 mm), food biomass per fish did not differ between Saginaw Bay and Thunder Bay for fish that had lost their yolk sac even though cyclopoid copepods were selected in Saginaw Bay and calanoid copepods were selected in Thunder Bay, suggesting that the type of copepod available to early stage age-0 lake whitefish might not be as important as previously thought. Fish from beach seines (20-51 mm) also had a narrow diet niche with a fair degree of diet specialization on calanoids, cyclopoids, or Bosmina, depending on site, along with generalized feeding on chironomid pupae at some sites. Selectivity patterns on zooplankton prey by larger age-0 fish followed patterns in prey availability, indicating the ability to adapt to prevailing prey conditions. Despite these spatial differences in prey importance, most fish had food in their stomachs and food biomass per fish did not differ among sites for most size groups, suggesting that variable diet patterns might not result in differential conditions for growth or survival of age age-0 lake whitefish. Adaptability in prey use might not entirely buffer age-0 lake whitefish from environmental variability, as we noted strong differences in both diet composition and feeding success among years (2014)(2015)(2016)(2017)(2018) at the Monaghan Point site.

Feeding success is associated with increased growth and survival during early life stages for fish, and understanding the factors that influence feeding success is a critical step toward predicting future recruitment to the fishery. The goal of our study was to test whether various biotic and abiotic factors, including prey abundance, fish abundance, and water temperature, affected the feeding success of early juvenile Lake Whitefish Coregonus clupeaformis from Lakes Michigan and Huron. Higher feeding success, which was determined using residuals from average weights of consumed prey for a given length fish, was associated with more rapid growth rates in length and depended on multiple factors. Although the relationships were not overly strong, one factor that was most consistently associated with increased feeding success was available zooplankton biomass in combination with some other factor(s) such as water temperature and/or total fish or Lake Whitefish density. There was no difference in diet composition or the available zooplankton community composition among four different levels of feeding success. Feeding success measures help integrate complex environmental factors that can vary with fish ontogeny. In turn, feeding success has the potential to be an important metric for Lake Whitefish fishery management strategies that critically need to account for the myriad factors influencing survival and growth of prerecruits to the fishery.