Consumer co-operatives in Korea have been growing rapidly since they launched their own shops. If co-operatives would be too much oriented to enlargement or economic growth, they might easily pay no attention to members' participation which is one of the priorities in co-operatives. It could lead to losing the value of co-operatives. So it is important to adjust the balance between members' participation and economic growth. This paper focuses on the role of board of directors in doing that. It aims to examine how effectiveness of the board influences members' participation and the participation has effect on performance of co-operatives in the case of iCOOP Korea. The variables such as communication with members and usage of management skills and knowledge are employed as measures of the effectiveness of the board in decision-making process. The data are collected by survey the respondents of which are 222 directors of 30 primary co-operatives. It is analyzed by Structural Equation Model. The findings of the research are as follows. Firstly, communication of the board with members increases the members' democratic participation, and the increased participation contributes to improving the financial performance. Secondly, management skills and knowledge of the board does not have significant relations with the level of members' participation, even though members' economic participation has significantly positive relation with the financial performance. The findings imply that members' voluntary participation will be increased when boards of co-operatives try to reflect members' needs in the decision making processes, and it can help the co-operatives improve their financial performance. It suggests a clue for the trade-off between the value of co-operatives and growth of business which many co-operatives are trying to resolve.Les coopératives de consommation se sont fortement développées en Corée depuis qu'elles ont ouvert leurs propres magasins. Les coopératives trop orientées vers le développement ou la croissance
The capital structure of co-operatives can differ from that of IOB (Investor-Owned Businesses) since the two organizations differ in their aims, governance structures and decision-making principles. This paper examines whether the determinants verified in IOB affect the leverage ratio of consumer co-operatives. Consumer co-operatives in South Korea have been rapidly growing during the last decade. There are two leading theories in finance that explain capital structure: the trade-off and pecking order theories. Focusing on consumer co-operatives in South Korea, the paper aims to analyze empirically what determinants have effect on the capital structure of consumer co-operatives and which of the two theories is more plausible. This study reveals that profitability and firm size have a significantly negative effect on leverage while tangibility and growth have a significantly positive effect on it. In conclusion, it seems that neither of the theories above perfectly accounts for the capital structure of consumer co-operatives because of the differences in governance characteristics between consumer co-operatives and IOB as well as in the costs of bankruptcy, agency, informational asymmetry and securities issuance. *
Member shares of co‐operatives are hybrid securities in that they have characteristics of both equity and liabilities. Prior studies propose that in order to classify hybrid securities as equity or liabilities, the economic substance of those securities should be considered. This study aims to examine whether the economic substance of member shares can be considered as equity or liabilities. Systematic risk is used as a proxy of economic substance. This study tests whether the proportion of member shares to equity is positively or negatively related to equity betas. If the test shows a negative relation, member shares can be considered to have the economic substance of equity; a positive relation implies that member shares have the substance of liabilities.
The results show that the proportion of member shares to equity is significantly negatively related to systematic risk of equity, which means that member shares have equity‐like characteristics. The robustness checks taking into account the tax effect of debt support the findings more strongly that redeemable member shares play an equity‐like role in consumer co‐operatives in South Korea. Although the legal and institutional systems in Korea do not provide member shares of consumer cooperatives with a clear status as equity, member shares still show equity‐like economic substance.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.