Optimizing the Diels–Alder (DA) reaction for aqueous coupling has resulted in practical methods to link molecules such as drugs and diagnostic agents to proteins. Both normal electron demand (NED) and inverse electron demand (IED) DA coupling schemes have been employed, but neither mechanism entails a common multipurpose reactive group. This report focuses on expanding the bioconjugation toolbox for cyclopentadiene through the identification of reactive groups that couple through NED or IED mechanisms in aqueous solution. Dienophiles and tetrazine derivatives were screened for reactivity and selectivity toward antibodies bearing cyclopentadiene amino acids to yield bioconjugates. Twelve NED dienophiles and four tetrazine-based IED substrates were identified as capable of practical biocoupling. Furthermore, tetrazine ligation to cyclopentadiene occurred at a rate of 3.3 ± 0.5 M–1 s–1 and was capable of bioorthogonal transformations, as evidenced by the selective protein labeling in serum. Finally, an antibody–drug conjugate (ADC)-bearing monomethyl auristatin E was prepared via tetrazine conjugation to cyclopentadiene. The resulting ADC was stable and demonstrated potent activity in vitro. These findings expand the utility of cyclopentadiene as a tool to couple entities to proteins via dual DA addition mechanisms.