Summary Distant-acting tissue-specific enhancers vastly outnumber protein-coding genes in mammalian genomes, but the functional significance of this regulatory complexity remains insufficiently understood1,2. Here we show that the pervasive presence of multiple enhancers with similar activities near the same gene confers phenotypic robustness to loss-of-function mutations in individual enhancers. We used genome editing to create 23 mouse deletion lines and inter-crosses, including both single and combinatorial enhancer deletions at seven distinct loci required for limb development. Surprisingly, none of ten deletions of individual enhancers caused noticeable changes in limb morphology. In contrast, removal of pairs of limb enhancers near the same gene resulted in discernible phenotypes, indicating that enhancers function redundantly in establishing normal morphology. In a genetic background sensitized by reduced baseline expression of the target gene, even single enhancer deletions caused limb abnormalities, suggesting that functional redundancy is conferred by additive effects of enhancers on gene expression levels. A genome-wide analysis integrating epigenomic and transcriptomic data from 29 developmental mouse tissues revealed that mammalian genes are very commonly associated with multiple enhancers that have similar spatiotemporal activity. Systematic exploration of three representative developmental structures (limb, brain, heart) uncovered more than a thousand cases in which five or more enhancers with redundant activity patterns were found near the same gene. Taken together, our data indicate that enhancer redundancy is a remarkably widespread feature of mammalian genomes and provides an effective regulatory buffer preventing deleterious phenotypic consequences upon loss of individual enhancers.

Engineered nucleases target specific DNA sequences for gene disruption in nonmodel organisms.

In many species, a dosage compensation complex (DCC) is targeted to X chromosomes of one sex to equalize levels of X-gene products between males (1X) and females (2X). Here we identify cis-acting regulatory elements that target the Caenorhabditis elegans X chromosome for repression by the DCC. The DCC binds to discrete, dispersed sites on X of two types. rex sites (recruitment elements on X) recruit the DCC in an autonomous, DNA sequence-dependent manner using a 12-base-pair (bp) consensus motif that is enriched on X. This motif is critical for DCC binding, is clustered in rex sites, and confers much of X-chromosome specificity. Motif variants enriched on X by 3.8-fold or more are highly predictive (95%) for rex sites. In contrast, dox sites (dependent on X) lack the X-enriched variants and cannot bind the DCC when detached from X. dox sites are more prevalent than rex sites and, unlike rex sites, reside preferentially in promoters of some expressed genes. These findings fulfill predictions for a targeting model in which the DCC binds to recruitment sites on X and disperses to discrete sites lacking autonomous recruitment ability. To relate DCC binding to function, we identified dosage-compensated and noncompensated genes on X. Unexpectedly, many genes of both types have bound DCC, but many do not, suggesting the DCC acts over long distances to repress X-gene expression. Remarkably, the DCC binds to autosomes, but at far fewer sites and rarely at consensus motifs. DCC disruption causes opposite effects on expression of X and autosomal genes. The DCC thus acts at a distance to impact expression throughout the genome.[Keywords: Dosage compensation; condensin; X chromosome; gene expression; epigenetics; C. elegans] Supplemental material is available at http://www.genesdev.org.

The evolution of body shape is thought to be tightly coupled to changes in regulatory sequences, but specific molecular events associated with major morphological transitions in vertebrates have remained elusive. We identified snake-specific sequence changes within an otherwise highly conserved long-range limb enhancer of Sonic hedgehog (Shh). Transgenic mouse reporter assays revealed that the in vivo activity pattern of the enhancer is conserved across a wide range of vertebrates including fish, but not in snakes. Genomic substitution of the mouse enhancer with its human or fish ortholog results in normal limb development. In contrast, replacement with snake orthologs caused severe limb reduction. Synthetic restoration of a single transcription factor binding site lost in the snake lineage reinstated full in vivo function to the snake enhancer. Our results demonstrate changes in a regulatory sequence associated with a major body plan transition and highlight the role of enhancers in morphological evolution.

Non-coding "ultraconserved" regions containing hundreds of consecutive bases of perfect sequence conservation across mammalian genomes can function as distant-acting enhancers. However, initial deletion studies in mice revealed that loss of such extraordinarily constrained sequences had no immediate impact on viability. Here, we show that ultraconserved enhancers are required for normal development. Focusing on some of the longest ultraconserved sites genome wide, located near the essential neuronal transcription factor Arx, we used genome editing to create an expanded series of knockout mice lacking individual or combinations of ultraconserved enhancers. Mice with single or pairwise deletions of ultraconserved enhancers were viable and fertile but in nearly all cases showed neurological or growth abnormalities, including substantial alterations of neuron populations and structural brain defects. Our results demonstrate the functional importance of ultraconserved enhancers and indicate that remarkably strong sequence conservation likely results from fitness deficits that appear subtle in a laboratory setting.

Exploitation of custom-designed nucleases to induce DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) at genomic locations of choice has transformed our ability to edit genomes, regardless of their complexity. DSBs can trigger either error-prone repair pathways that induce random mutations at the break sites or precise homology-directed repair pathways that generate specific insertions or deletions guided by exogenously supplied DNA. Prior editing strategies using site-specific nucleases to modify the Caenorhabditis elegans genome achieved only the heritable disruption of endogenous loci through random mutagenesis by error-prone repair. Here we report highly effective strategies using TALE nucleases and RNA-guided CRISPR/Cas9 nucleases to induce error-prone repair and homology-directed repair to create heritable, precise insertion, deletion, or substitution of specific DNA sequences at targeted endogenous loci. Our robust strategies are effective across nematode species diverged by 300 million years, including necromenic nematodes (Pristionchus pacificus), male/female species (Caenorhabditis species 9), and hermaphroditic species (C. elegans). Thus, genome-editing tools now exist to transform nonmodel nematode species into genetically tractable model organisms. We demonstrate the utility of our broadly applicable genome-editing strategies by creating reagents generally useful to the nematode community and reagents specifically designed to explore the mechanism and evolution of X chromosome dosage compensation. By developing an efficient pipeline involving germline injection of nuclease mRNAs and single-stranded DNA templates, we engineered precise, heritable nucleotide changes both close to and far from DSBs to gain or lose genetic function, to tag proteins made from endogenous genes, and to excise entire loci through targeted FLP-FRT recombination. STRATEGIES to engineer heritable, site-directed mutations at endogenous loci have revolutionized our approach toward manipulating and dissecting genome function. Studies of plants and animals alike, whether conducted in whole organisms or cell lines, have benefitted greatly from these genomeediting approaches (Bibikova et al. 2002;Beumer et al. 2006;Doyon et al. 2008;Geurts et al. 2009;Hockemeyer et al. 2009;Holt et al. 2010;Zhang et al. 2010;Hockemeyer et al. 2011;Tesson et al. 2011;Wood et al. 2011;Young et al. 2011;Bedell et al. 2012;Bassett et al. 2013;Cong et al. 2013;Jinek et al. 2013;Mali et al. 2013;Wang et al. 2013;Zu et al. 2013). The most modern tools for modifying complex genomes at single-nucleotide resolution are site-specific nucleases that induce DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) at specifically designated genomic locations. DSBs trigger repair pathways that can elicit targeted genetic reprogramming, primarily through two mechanisms: error-prone nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) (Lieber 2010) and precise, homology-directed recombination or repair (HDR) (Chapman et al. 2012). NHEJ rejoins broken ends of chromosomes through an imprecise process that produces nucleo...

Whole-genome sequencing is identifying growing numbers of non-coding variants in human disease studies, but the lack of accurate functional annotations prevents their interpretation. We describe the genome-wide landscape of distant-acting enhancers active in the developing and adult human heart, an organ whose impairment is a predominant cause of mortality and morbidity. Using integrative analysis of >35 epigenomic data sets from mouse and human pre- and postnatal hearts we created a comprehensive reference of >80,000 putative human heart enhancers. To illustrate the importance of enhancers in the regulation of genes involved in heart disease, we deleted the mouse orthologs of two human enhancers near cardiac myosin genes. In both cases, we observe in vivo expression changes and cardiac phenotypes consistent with human heart disease. Our study provides a comprehensive catalogue of human heart enhancers for use in clinical whole-genome sequencing studies and highlights the importance of enhancers for cardiac function.

In Caenorhabditis elegans, an X chromosome-counting mechanism specifies sexual fate. Specific genes termed X-signal elements, which are present on the X chromosome, act in a concerted dose-dependent fashion to regulate levels of the developmental switch gene xol-1. In turn, xol-1 levels determine sexual fate and the activation state of the dosage compensation mechanism. The crystal structure of the XOL-1 protein at 1.55 Å resolution unexpectedly reveals that xol-1 encodes a GHMP kinase family member, despite sequence identity of 10% or less. Because GHMP kinases, thus far, have only been characterized as small molecule kinases involved in metabolic pathways, for example, amino acid and cholesterol synthesis, XOL-1 is the first member that controls nonmetabolic processes. Biochemical investigations demonstrated that XOL-1 does not bind ATP under standard conditions, suggesting that XOL-1 acts by a mechanism distinct from that of other GHMP kinases. In addition, we have cloned a XOL-1 ortholog from Caenorhabditis briggsae, a related nematode that diverged from C. elegans ∼50-100 million years ago. These findings demonstrate an unanticipated role for GHMP kinase family members as mediators of sexual differentiation and dosage compensation and, possibly, other aspects of differentiation and development.[Keywords: C. elegans; XOL-1; sexual differentiation; GHMP kinase; crystal structure] Received February 7, 2003; revised version accepted February 11, 2003. Sex determination is the critical and universal developmental pathway underlying sexual reproduction. Its manifestations are pervasive and often conspicuous. Whereas the presence or absence of the Y chromosome dictates male or female development in mammals, sexual fate in the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster and the free-living nematode Caenorhabditis elegans is determined genetically by the number of X chromosomes relative to the number of sets of autosomes. In mammals, the primary sex determining gene is SRY, which is present only on the Y chromosome and encodes an HMG domain-containing transcription factor. In the fruit fly, the primary sex determination gene Sex-lethal (Sxl; Maine et al. 1985) is a female-specific trans-acting gene regulator that binds tra transcripts and directs alternative splicing (Inoue et al. 1990). The SRY (Werner et al. 1995) and SXL (Handa et al. 1999) interactions with polynucleotides have been characterized structurally. In C. elegans, sexual differentiation is regulated by the expression levels of the developmental switch gene xol-1. High and low levels of xol-1 result in male (XO) and hermaphrodite (XX) development (Fig. 1), respectively. XOL-1 activity is absolutely required for proper sexual differentiation and male viability (Rhind et al. 1995), but its mechanism of action is unknown.The cooperative activity of at least four X-linked genes, termed X-signal elements, represses expression of xol-1 (for review, see Meyer 2000a). By doubling the number of X-signal elements, an XX embryo reduces xol-1 expression by ∼10-fold (Rhin...