Passive integrated transponder (PIT) tags have been used to infer demography and behavior of lotic fishes, but their application has mostly been limited to salmonids. We studied the efficiency of a portable PIT antenna in a small Piedmont stream (mean width = 2.4 m) in South Carolina by comparing two tag sizes (8‐ and 12‐mm full‐duplex tags) applied to two nongame species (Mottled Sculpin Cottus bairdii and Creek Chub Semotilus atromaculatus). A 285‐m stream reach was blocked off under base flow conditions in September 2016, and 8‐ or 12‐mm PIT tags were implanted in 67 Creek Chub (62–138 mm TL) and 65 Mottled Sculpin (60–88 mm TL). Starting at 1 d after tagging, the study reach was sampled with the portable PIT antenna twice daily for five consecutive days, during which apparent survival of tagged fish was assumed. Generalized linear mixed‐effects models with a logistic link identified that detection efficiency depended on species, tag size, body length, and the species × body length interaction. Mottled Sculpin had detection rates of 56% (8‐mm tags) and 79% (12‐mm tags), with 67% of detections occurring in riffle‐dominated sections, whereas Creek Chub had 3% (8‐mm tags) and 16% (12‐mm tags) detection rates, with 62% of detections occurring in pool‐dominated sections. Detection efficiency decreased with body size in Creek Chub but not in Mottled Sculpin; the observed decrease for Creek Chub was most likely attributable to an ontogenetic habitat shift. The reasonably high detection efficiency of Mottled Sculpin, even with 8‐mm tags, suggested that the portable PIT antenna can be a viable option for some species in small streams, allowing individual‐based approaches to studying small‐bodied species or earlier life stages without the need for repeated physical capture and handling.
Received May 13, 2017; accepted October 2, 2017Published online November 10, 2017
Fish populations at the fringe of their geographic range often inhabit marginal habitats and are vulnerable to ecological disturbances, such as species invasion, land cover conversion, and climate change. The Driftless Area of northeastern Iowa, USA represents the southwestern edge of the native range of Brook Trout Salvelinus fontinalis, where endemic populations have been greatly reduced due to habitat degradation and introduced Brown Trout Salmo trutta. Therefore, documenting Brook Trout occurrence patterns at the southern tip of their range may prove useful for the conservation of peripheral populations. We fitted single-species occupancy models at multiple spatial scales to estimate the relative effects of biotic (e.g., Brown Trout density) and habitat (instream, riparian, and watershed) variables on Brook and Brown Trout occupancy to predict their current distribution in the Iowa Driftless Area. Species occurrence and physical habitat data were collected at 138 stream segments of the Upper Iowa, Yellow, and Little Maquoketa River watersheds (8-digit hydrologic unit codes) during May-September in 2018 and 2019. Brook Trout occupancy was low (19 of 138 sites) and affected by local (instream and riparian) habitat covariates, particularly August--September stream temperatures, but no adverse effects of Brown Trout density were detected. Brown Trout occupied 54% of streams (74 of 138 sites), and occupancy was influenced by a combination of local-scale (mean stream velocity, percentage of run macrohabitat, and August-September stream temperatures) and catchment-scale (percent forested land cover and upstream catchment area) habitat variables. Our results provide evidence that instream thermal conditions are a critical determinant of Brook Trout distribution, while Brown Trout exhibit plasticity in habitat suitability and increased colonization in areas where they are introduced. Given the dependence of Brook Trout on cold stream temperatures, the projected loss of thermally suitable habitats due to climate change may facilitate their replacement by naturalized Brown Trout at the southwestern extent of their range.
We collected fishes and habitat data at 138 streams to evaluate the effects of introduced brown trout ( Salmo trutta) and habitat conditions on occurrence, detection, abundance, and size structure of sculpin ( Cottus spp.), longnose dace ( Rhinichthys cataractae), and southern redbelly dace ( Chrosomus erythrogaster) in the Driftless Area, USA. Sculpin detection decreased with increasing stream velocity, whereas southern redbelly dace detection increased with stream depth. Sculpin occupancy declined with increasing stream temperature and velocity and increased with increasing forested land, boulder substrate, and brown trout length and abundance. Longnose and southern redbelly dace occupancy and abundance declined with increasing brown trout abundance and occupancy increased with stream temperature. Longnose dace occupancy also increased with increasing stream temperature and cobble substrate and declined with increasing elevation. Native fish size structure was unrelated to brown trout presence. Our results suggest that effects of brown trout are not ubiquitous across native fishes and depend on abiotic conditions and species-specific habitat requirements, highlighting the need to consider both biotic and abiotic conditions when balancing native species conservation with introduced sportfish management.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.