ClC proteins are a family of chloride channels and transporters that are found in a wide variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell types. The mammalian voltage-gated chloride channel ClC-1 is important for controlling the electrical excitability of skeletal muscle. Reduced excitability of muscle cells during metabolic stress can protect cells from metabolic exhaustion and is thought to be a major factor in fatigue. Here we identify a novel mechanism linking excitability to metabolic state by showing that ClC-1 channels are modulated by ATP. The high concentration of ATP in resting muscle effectively inhibits ClC-1 activity by shifting the voltage gating to more positive potentials. ADP and AMP had similar effects to ATP, but IMP had no effect, indicating that the inhibition of ClC-1 would only be relieved under anaerobic conditions such as intense muscle activity or ischemia, when depleted ATP accumulates as IMP. The resulting increase in ClC-1 activity under these conditions would reduce muscle excitability, thus contributing to fatigue. We show further that the modulation by ATP is mediated by cystathionine ␤-synthase-related domains in the cytoplasmic C terminus of ClC-1. This defines a function for these domains as gating-modulatory domains sensitive to intracellular ligands, such as nucleotides, a function that is likely to be conserved in other ClC proteins.Skeletal muscle has a high and variable demand for energy, in the form of ATP, and has elaborate systems to maintain the ATP supply. During intense exercise, however, ATP supply may not keep up with demand, and ATP concentration can decrease rapidly. In fast twitch fibers ATP can drop to below 25% of resting concentration within 25 s (1), a rate of ATP consumption that, if it continued, would deplete all ATP within a further 10 s. As the majority of ATP is consumed by the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) 5 Ca 2ϩ -ATPase pumping Ca 2ϩ back into the SR after each Ca 2ϩ -activated contraction (2), complete ATP depletion would lead to a rise in cytoplasmic calcium, rigor, and calcium-dependent damage (3, 4). This does not normally occur because force generation and ATP consumption decrease during exercise, compromising short term function but protecting cells from complete metabolic exhaustion. This process is well known as fatigue, but the factors contributing to fatigue remain controversial. A direct reduction in force generation by the contractile apparatus is thought to be a factor early in fatigue (3, 5), but a significant reduction in ATP consumption only occurs with a reduction in SR Ca 2ϩ release (and consequent reuptake) that occurs late in fatigue, correlating with ATP depletion (3). Indeed, ATP depletion and the concomitant increase in cytoplasmic Mg 2ϩ

Skeletal muscle acidosis during exercise has long been thought to be a cause of fatigue, but recent studies have shown that acidosis maintains muscle excitability and opposes fatigue by decreasing the sarcolemmal chloride conductance. ClC-1 is the primary sarcolemmal chloride channel and has a clear role in controlling muscle excitability, but recombinant ClC-1 has been reported to be activated by acidosis. Following our recent finding that intracellular ATP inhibits ClC-1, we investigated here the interaction between pH and ATP regulation of ClC-1. We found that, in the absence of ATP, intracellular acidosis from pH 7.2 to 6.2 inhibited ClC-1 slightly by shifting the voltage dependence of common gating to more positive potentials, similar to the effect of ATP. Importantly, the effects of ATP and acidosis were cooperative, such that ATP greatly potentiated the effect of acidosis. Adenosine had a similar effect to ATP at pH 7.2, but acidosis did not potentiate this effect, indicating that the phosphates of ATP are important for this cooperativity, possibly due to electrostatic interactions with protonatable residues of ClC-1. A protonatable residue identified by molecular modeling, His-847, was found to be critical for both pH and ATP modulation and may be involved in such electrostatic interactions. These findings are now consistent with, and provide a molecular explanation for, acidosis opposing fatigue by decreasing the chloride conductance of skeletal muscle via inhibition of ClC-1. The modulation of ClC-1 by ATP is a key component of this molecular mechanism.

The CLC-1 Cl− channel is abundantly expressed on the plasma membrane of muscle cells, and the membrane potential of muscle cells is largely controlled by the activity of this Cl− channel. Previous studies showed that low intracellular pH increases the overall open probability of recombinant CLC-1 channels in various expression systems. Low intracellular pH, however, is known to inhibit the Cl− conductance on the native muscle membrane, contradicting the findings from the recombinant CLC-1 channels in expressed systems. Here we show that in the presence of physiological concentrations of ATP, reduction of the intracellular pH indeed inhibits the expressed CLC-1, mostly by decreasing the open probability of the common gate of the channel.

Uniquely, the ClC family harbours dissipative channels and anion/H þ transporters that share unprecedented functional characteristics. ClC-1 channels are homodimers in which each monomer supports an identical pore carrying three anion-binding sites. Transient occupancy of the extracellular binding site by a conserved glutamate residue, E232, independently gates each pore. A common gate, the molecular basis of which is unknown, closes both pores simultaneously. Mutations affecting common gating underlie myotonia congenita in humans. Here we show that the common gate likely occludes the channel pore via interaction of E232 with a highly conserved tyrosine, Y578, at the central anion-binding site. We also identify structural linkages important for coordination of common gating between subunits and modulation by intracellular molecules. Our data reveal important molecular determinants of common gating of ClC channels and suggest that the molecular mechanism is an evolutionary vestige of coupled anion/H þ transport.

1. In the present work we investigated the dependence on temperature of the ionic conductance and gating of human muscle ClC-1 chloride channels, transiently expressed in human embryonic kidney (HEK 293) cells. 2. At normal pH, ClC-1 currents deactivated at negative potentials with a double-exponential time course. The time constants of the exponential components, corresponding to the relaxations of the fast and slow gates, were temperature dependent with Q(10) values of approximately 3 and approximately 4, respectively. Current amplitude increased with increasing temperature with a Q(10) of approximately 1.6. 3. The voltage dependence of the two gating processes was shifted towards more positive potentials with increasing temperature. The half-saturation voltage (V(1/2)) of the steady-state open probability (P(o)) was shifted by approximately 23 and approximately 34 mV per 10 degrees C increase in temperature, for the fast and slow gate, respectively. 4. At low pH, the voltage dependence of ClC-1 was reversed and currents were activated by hyperpolarisation with a single-exponential time course. This type of gating in ClC-1 resembled the slow gating of the Torpedo ClC-0 homologue, but differed with respect to its kinetics and temperature dependence, with a Q(10) of gating relaxations at negative potentials of approximately 5. The Arrhenius plot of ClC-1 conductance at low pH had a clear break point at approximately 25 degrees C, with higher Q(10) values at lower temperatures. 5. The temperature sensitivity of relaxation and open probability of the slow gate, which in both ClC-0 and ClC-1 controls two pores simultaneously, implies that the slow gating of ClC-1 is mechanistically different from that of ClC-0.

1. Gating of the skeletal muscle chloride channel (ClC-1) is sensitive to extracellular pH. In this study, whole-cell recording of currents from wild-type (WT) ClC-1 and a mutant, R304E, expressed in the Sf-9 insect cell line was used to investigate further the nature of the pHsensitive residues. 2. Extracellular Cd¥ produced a concentration-dependent block of WT ClC-1 with an IC50 of 1·0 ± 0·1 mÒ and a Hill coefficient of 2·0 ± 0·3. This block was sensitive to external pH, reducing at low pH, with an apparent pKa of 6·8 ± 0·1 and a Hill coefficient for proton binding of 3·0 ± 0·3. Anthracene-9-carboxylate (A-9-C) block of WT ClC-1 was also pH sensitive, increasing at low pH, with an apparent pKa of 6·4 ± 0·1 and a Hill coefficient for proton binding of 1·0 ± 0·2. 3. Compared with WT ClC-1, R304E had a lower affinity for Cd¥ (IC50, 3·0 ± 0·3 mÒ) but it had a similar Hill coefficient for transition metal ion binding. The Hill coefficient for proton binding to the Cd¥ binding site was reduced to 1·4 ± 0·3. In contrast, the A-9-C binding site in R304E showed the same pH sensitivity and affinity for the blocker as that seen in WT ClC-1. 4. ClC-1 has at least two binding sites for Cd¥, each of which has at least three residues which can be protonated. Binding of A-9-C is influenced by protonation of a single residue. Arg 304 is not sufficiently close to the A-9-C binding site to affect its characteristics, but it does alter Cd¥ binding, indicating that transition metal ions and aromatic carboxylates interact with distinct sites. 5. The block of ClC-1 by transition metal ions and the apparent pKa of this block, together with the apparent pKa for A-9-C block and gating are all compatible with the involvement of His residues in the pore and gate of ClC-1.

Background: Weakly voltage-dependent ClC-1 chloride channels regulate skeletal muscle excitability. Results: Intracellular NAD(H) altered the voltage dependence of ClC-1 gating, and specific mutations attenuated this effect. Conclusion: NAD(H) directly inhibits ClC-1 chloride channels by binding to intracellular domains. Significance: ClC-1 inhibition by NAD(H) may play an important role in muscle fatigue and the pathophysiology of myotonia congenita.

Our knowledge about ClC-1 muscle chloride channel gating, previously gained from single-channel recording and noise analysis, provides a theoretical basis for further analysis of macroscopic currents. In the present study, we propose a simple method of calculation of open probabilities (P(o)) of fast and slow gates from the relative amplitudes of ClC-1 inward current components. With this method, we investigated the effects of 2-(4-chlorophenoxy) propionic acid (CPP), a drug known to produce myotonia in animals, and dominant negative myotonic mutations, F307S and A313T, on fast and slow gating of ClC-1. We have shown that these mutations affected the P(o) of the slow gate, as expected from their mode of inheritance, and that CPP predominantly affected the fast gating process. CPP's action on the fast gating of mutant channels was similar to its effect in wild-type channels. Comparison of the effects of CPP and the mutations on fast and slow gating with the effects produced by reduction of external Cl(-) concentration suggested that CPP and mutations exert their action by affecting the transition of the channel from its closed to open state after Cl(-) binding to the gating site.