The differentiation of palatal from non-palatal snoring is very important for ENT surgeons trying to determine whether palatal surgery would be curative. At present sleep nasendoscopy is the accepted method. Palatal vibration produces marked modulation of sound loudness at low frequency (below approximately 100 Hz). We calculate a crest factor for the sound waveform (ratio of peak to root mean square (rms) value in any given epoch), as a measure of the degree of modulation. Free-field snore sounds were recorded from 11 supine adult patients under intravenous sedation (midazolam), using a digital tape recorder. Recordings were transferred to a PC (sampling frequency 11 kHz), and analysed using code written by us. Direct visual confirmation of the site of snoring was gained from simultaneous sleep nasendoscopy, taken as the gold standard. In six patients the dominant site was the soft palate. The non-palatal group (five patients) comprised one epiglottic, two hypopharyngeal and two tongue base snorers. The crest factor was found to be significantly higher for palatal snorers (p < 0.01, Student-t or Mann-Whitney tests). Furthermore, palatal could be distinguished from non-palatal snorers on the basis of crest factor alone in all 11 cases, making this a promising non-invasive diagnostic technique.

We have developed a portable device for patient use in logging snoring loudness in the home, for guiding treatment decisions and measuring the clinical effectiveness of treatment. The device uses a free field microphone and is positioned on a bedside table. The prototype devices contain no inherently expensive components and are simple to operate (producing only 5% patient error to date). They are portable, battery powered, rugged and produce digital data which are easily and automatically analysed, and these design parameters enable the devices to be used for first line patient assessment. Of the 75 recordings made so far from 30 patients, 85% were successful, yielding clinically useful data. Because it is sound levels which are recorded and not replayable sounds, patient privacy is maintained, resulting in excellent patient acceptance (to date no patient has refused). The device has a dynamic range of 45-90 dB sound pressure level and a frequency range of 30 Hz-5 kHz. Because snoring intensities often vary significantly throughout the night the device can measure continuously over 8 h.