Background: A rapid and comprehensive metabolic stability screen at the top of a drug discovery flow chart serves as an effective gate in eliminating low value compounds. This imparts a significant level of efficiency and saves valuable resources. While microsomes are amenable to high throughput automation and are cost effective, their enzymatic make-up is limited to that which is contained in endoplasmic reticulum, thereby informing only on Phase I metabolism. Lack of Phase II metabolism data can become a potential liability later in the process, adversely affecting discovery projects’ timelines and budget. Hepatocytes offer a full complement of metabolic enzymes and retain their cellular compartments, better representing liver metabolic function. However, hepatocyte screens are relatively expensive, labor intensive, and not easily automatable. Liver S9 fractions include Phase I and II metabolic enzymes, are relatively inexpensive, easy to use, and amenable to automation, making them a more appropriate screening system. We compare the data from the three systems and present the results.Results: Liver S9 and hepatocyte stability assays binned into the same category 70-84% of the time. Microsome and hepatocyte data were in agreement 73-82% of the time. The true rate for stability versus plasma clearance was 45% for hepatocytes and 43% for S9.Conclusion: In our opinion, replacing liver microsome and hepatocyte assays with S9 assay for high throughput metabolic screening purposes provides the combined benefit of comprehensive and high quality data at a reasonable expense for drug discovery programs.
With the goal of refining our discovery DMPK workflow, we conducted a retrospective analysis on internal Celgene compounds by calculating the physicochemical properties and gathering data from several assays including solubility, rat and human liver S9 stability, Caco-2 permeability, and rat intravenous (iv.) and oral pharmacokinetics. Our analysis identified plasma clearance to be most statistically relevant for prediction of oral exposure. In rat, compounds with rat S9 stability of ≥70% at 60 min and a plasma clearance of ≤43 ml/min/kg had the greatest chance of achieving oral exposures above 3 µM.h. Compounds with the dual advantage of plasma clearance ≤43 ml/min/kg and Caco-2 permeability ≥8 × 10(-6) cm/s or efflux ratio ≤8 were highly likely to achieve those oral exposures. Implementation of these criteria leads to a significant increase in efficiency, good pharmacokinetic properties, cost savings and a reduction in the use of animals.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.