Our purpose was to conduct a prospective randomized trial to compare the Versajet system (Smith & Nephew, London, UK) vs hand-held dermatome escharectomy for burn débridment. All patients admitted over the course of 1 year at our burn center were recruited and randomly assigned to Versajet or hand-held dermatome escharectomy. We evaluated the 1) time for complete débridment and 2) the efficacy of Versajet in reaching the correct dermal plane. Secondary end points were the assessment of postoperative pain (evaluated with the visual analog scale), adverse effects, complete healing times, and contractures rates (after 6 months). A total of 87 patients were analyzed in two homogeneous groups of 42 (Versajet) and 45 (escharectomy) patients. All of them received adequate débridment, but the Versajet procedure was faster (P < .05) and more precise in obtaining the correct plane. One Versajet patient required ligation of a large subcutaneous vessel, which inadvertently was cut during the procedure. Versajet is a feasible, simple, and safe technique that hastens surgical débridment of burns and adds more precision to the procedure.
Since 2001, Hyalomatrix PA (Fidia Advanced Biopolymers, Abano Terme, Italy) has been used in our center on pediatric burned patients as a temporary dermal substitute to cover deep partial-thickness burns after dermabrasion. This "bridge" treatment was adopted to remove necrotic debris (dermabrasion) and to stimulate regeneration in a humid and protected environment (Hyalomatrix PA). We present results obtained with this approach. On the third to fifth day after admission, dermabrasion was practiced on deep burned areas, which were covered with Hyalomatrix PA. Change of dressings was performed every 7 days. On day 21, those areas still without signs of recovery were removed with classic escharectomy and covered with thin skin grafts. We treated 300 patients. Sixty-one percent needed only one dermabrasion treatment, 22.3% (67 patients) more than one, and 16.7% (50 patients) the classic escharectomy. A total of 83% of patients healed within 21 days. Our study suggests that the combination of dermabrasion with a temporary dermal substitute could be a good and feasible approach for treatment of deep partial-thickness burns. Prospective randomized studies are now necessary to compare our protocol with the gold standard treatment of topical dressings.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl 2010; 92: 118-123 118Dressings have always been an important issue in reconstructive surgery to obtain better aesthetic and functional outcomes. This is particularly true in burns, where infections and contractures are more frequent than in other fields. Over latter years, pharmacological research has produced several products with different purposes: avoidance of infection (i.e. silvercontaining products), promotion of re-epithelialisation (alginates, hyaluronic acid-derived products), or both.In the ambulatory facility of our burn centre, we use different products for different purposes. Although we try to use them according to burn thickness and local status, no clear guideline exists and much of the decision is often left to the surgeon's personal experience. During the last days of 2005, new silver-based products (nanocrystalline silverActicoat, Smith and Nephew, and silver carboxymethylcellulose -Aquacel Ag, Convatec) were introduced in our clinical practice. In the present study, we analysed burn outcomes, in terms of healing times, during the last 2 months of 2005 and the first 2 months of 2006, to see if changes in wound care corresponded to an amelioration of healing times. We also tried to correlate eventual differences with those obtained from other products already in use.
Patients and MethodsAfter local Institutional Review Board approval was obtained, we gathered data from patients treated in the ambulatory facility of our burn centre during the last 2 months of 2005 and the first 2 months of 2006. We excluded from the study: (i) admitted patients; (ii) patients with mixed superficial partial thickness and deep partial thickness burns; (iii) patients with full-thickness burns; and (iv) operated (2006, 19; 2005, 29 days; Student's t-test, P < 0.01). Among all dressings, paraffin gauzes had the shortest healing times in superficial burns (5 days); with silver-based dressings in deep burns, the healing times were nanocrystalline silver (16 days) and silver carboxymethylcellulose (21 days). CONCLUSIONS Results of our retrospective study would suggest that paraffin gauzes are a valuable option in superficial burns, while silver-based dressings are preferable in deep burns.
RECONSTRUCTIVE SURGERY
Deep partial-thickness burns exhibit ambiguous behavior, either spontaneously healing or evolving into full-thickness burns. The aim of this study was to investigate these lesions for the presence of apoptotic cells and to compare their rate with that of superficial and full-thickness burns. We used colocalization of DNA fragments (ie, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase Biotin-dUTP nick end labeling) and Fas ligand CD95 antibodies to calculate the apoptotic rate of superficial, deep partial-thickness and full-thickness burns in 45 patients after the thermal injury. Biopsies were collected mainly during the acute postburn phase (first week of hospitalization). Deep partial-thickness burns presented apoptotic cells, both in the dermis and in cutaneous adnexa, and showed a higher apoptotic rate than superficial and full-thickness burns (44.5% in deep partial thickness, interquartile range 6.3-90.5%; 5.6% in superficial partial thickness, interquartile range: 0-13%; 0% for full-thickness burn; P = .000243). A significant greater apoptotic rate was present in cells of deep partial-thickness burns when compared with superficial and full thickness. These data would suggest that deep burns sustain an ischemic damage that forces cells to undergo apoptosis and could represent the biologic basis for their clinical evolution into full-thickness burns. Further correlation studies are now required to confirm this hypothesis.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.