Nuclear receptors form strong dimers that are essential for their function as transcription factors, and it is thought that ligand binding can affect dimer stability. In this report, we describe convenient fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based methods for measuring the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of dimers of the estrogen receptor-alpha ligand-binding domain (ERalpha-LBD). We have developed receptors that are chemically labeled with a single fluorophore in a site-specific manner. These fluorophore-labeled ERs are functional and can be used to measure directly the affinity and stability of ERalpha-LBD dimers. Our results indicate that unliganded ERalpha-LBDs exist as very stable dimers and that the dissociation rate of these dimers is slow (t(1/2)=39 +/- 3 min at 28 C) and is further slowed (< or =7-fold) by the addition of various ligands. Estrogen antagonists provide greater kinetic stabilization of the ER dimers than agonists. In addition, coactivator peptides containing the LXXLL motif selectively stabilize agonist-bound ERalpha-LBD dimers. These fluorescence-based assays for measuring the kinetic and thermodynamic stability of ER dimers provide a functional in vitro method for assessing the agonist or antagonist character of novel ligands.

Nuclear receptors (NRs) complexed with agonist ligands activate transcription by recruiting coactivator protein complexes. In principle, one should be able to inhibit the transcriptional activity of the NRs by blocking this transcriptionally critical receptor-coactivator interaction directly, using an appropriately designed coactivator binding inhibitor (CBI). To guide our design of various classes of CBIs, we have used the crystal structure of an agonist-bound estrogen receptor (ER) ligand binding domain (LBD) complexed with a coactivator peptide containing the LXXLL signature motif bound to a hydrophobic groove on the surface of the LBD. One set of CBIs, based on an outside-in design approach, has various heterocyclic cores (triazenes, pyrimidines, trithianes, cyclohexanes) that mimic the tether sites of the three leucines on the peptide helix, onto which are appended leucine residue-like substituents. The other set, based on an inside-out approach, has a naphthalene core that mimics the two most deeply buried leucines, with substituents extending outward to mimic other features of the coactivator helical peptide. A fluorescence anisotropy-based coactivator competition assay was developed to measure the specific binding of these CBIs to the groove site on the ER-agonist complex with which coactivators interact; control ligand-binding assays assured that their interaction was not with the ligand binding pocket. The most effective CBIs were those from the pyrimidine family, the best binding with K(i) values of ca. 30 microM. The trithiane- and cyclohexane-based CBIs appear to be poor structural mimics, because of equatorial vs axial conformational constraints, and the triazene-based CBIs are also conformationally constrained by amine-substituent-to-ring resonance overlap, which is not the case with the higher affinity alkyl-substituted pyrimidines. The pyrimidine-based CBIs appear to be the first small molecule inhibitors of NR coactivator binding.

No abstract

The ligand-induced conformation of a nuclear receptor ligand-binding domain (LBD) is a principal factor leading to transcriptional activity and determining the pharmacological response. Using the estrogen receptor (ER) LBD-labeled site specifically with a fluorophore, we demonstrate that effects of ligand binding on the conformation and dynamics of this domain can be studied directly, in a quantitative and convenient fashion, by various fluorescence methods. Estrogen ligands of different pharmacological character-agonists, selective ER modulators (SERMs), and pure antagonists-each produce distinctive spectroscopic signatures, characteristic of the conformational or dynamic features of their ER-LBD complexes. We can directly follow the equilibrium of helix 12 positions through the degree of local fluorophore rotational freedom and receptor helicity near the C terminus of helix 11. We observe differences even between ligands within a specific pharmacological class, such as the SERMs raloxifene and trans-4-hydroxytamoxifen, highlighting the ability of these fluorescent receptor sensors to detect unique ER conformations induced even by closely related ligands, yet ones that produce distinctive biological activities in estrogen target cells. Fluorophore-labeled LBDs can serve as versatile molecular sensors predictive of ligand pharmacological character and should be broadly applicable to other members of the nuclear receptor superfamily.