The ability of proteases to regulate many aspects of cell function and defense accounts for the considerable interest in the design of novel protease inhibitors. There are many naturally occurring proteinaceous serine protease inhibitors, one of which is a 14 amino acid cyclic peptide from sunflower seeds that shows both sequence and conformational similarity with the trypsin-reactive loop of the Bowman-Birk family of serine protease inhibitors. This inhibitor adopts a beta-hairpin conformation when bound at the active site of bovine beta-trypsin. We illustrate here an approach to inhibitor design in which the beta hairpin from the naturally occurring peptide is transplanted onto a hairpin-inducing template. Two mimetics with the sequences RC*TKSIPPIC*F (where C*C* is a disulfide) and TKSIPPI are studied, each mounted onto a D-Pro-L-Pro template. NMR studies revealed a well-defined beta-hairpin conformation for each mimetic in aqueous solution; this conformation is closely related to the trypsin-bound conformation of the natural inhibitor and includes a cis-Ile-Pro peptide bond. Both mimetics inhibit trypsin in the mid nanomolar range. An alanine scan revealed the importance for inhibitory activity of the specificity-determining Lys residue and of the first but not the second Pro residue in the IPPI motif. Since these hairpin mimetics can be prepared by parallel combinatorial synthesis, this family of molecules may be a useful starting point for the discovery of other biologically or medicinally useful serine protease inhibitors.

Summary Miniproteins provide a bridge between proteins and small molecules. Here we adapt methods from combinatorial chemistry to optimize CD4M33, a synthetic miniprotein into which we had previously transplanted the HIV-1 gp120 binding surface of the CD4 receptor. Iterative deconvolution of generated libraries produced CD4M47, a derivative of CD4M33 that had been optimized at four positions. Surface-plasmon resonance demonstrated 4-to-6-fold improvement in CD4M47 affinity for gp120 to a level about 3-fold tighter than that of CD4 itself. Assessment of the neutralization properties of CD4M47 against a diverse range of isolates spanning from HIV-1 to SIVcpz showed that CD4M47 retained the extraordinary breadth of the parent CD4M33, but yielded only limited improvements in neutralization potencies. Crystal structures of CD4M47 and a phenylalanine variant ([Phe23]M47) were determined at 2.4 and 2.6 Å resolution, in ternary complexes with HIV-1 gp120 and the 17b antibody. Analysis of these structures revealed a correlation between mimetic affinity for gp120 and overall mimetic-gp120 interactive surface. A correlation was also observed between CD4- and mimetic-induced gp120-structural similarity and CD4- and mimetic-induced gp120 affinity for the CCR5 co-receptor. Despite mimetic substitutions, including a glycine to (D)-proline change, the gp120 conformation induced by CD4M47 was as close or closer to the conformation induced by CD4 as the one induced by the parent CD4M33. Our results demonstrate the ability of combinatorial chemistry to optimize a disulfide-containing miniprotein and of structural biology to decipher the resultant interplay between binding affinity, neutralization breadth, molecular mimicry, and induced affinity for CCR5.

These novel CD4 miniproteins might constitute a promising class of HIV microbicides.