T-cell receptors recognize peptides presented by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) on the surface of antigen-presenting cells (APC). The ability of the T-cell receptor (TCR) to recognize more than one peptide-MHC structure defines cross-reactivity. Cross-reactivity is a documented phenomenon of the immune system whose importance is still under investigation. There are a number of rational arguments for cross-reactivity. These include the discrepancy between the theoretical high number of pathogen-derived peptides and the lower diversity of the T-cell repertoire, the need for recognition of escape variants, and the intrinsic low affinity of this receptor–ligand pair. However, quantifying the phenomenon has been difficult, and its immunological importance remains unknown. In this review, we examined the cases for and against an important role for cross reactivity. We argue that it may be an essential feature of the immune system from the point of view of biological robustness.

Peptide binding to MHC class II (MHCII) molecules is stabilized by hydrophobic anchoring and hydrogen bond formation. We view peptide binding as a process in which the peptide folds into the binding groove and to some extent the groove folds around the peptide. Our previous observation of cooperativity when analyzing binding properties of peptides modified at side chains with medium to high solvent accessibility is compatible with such a view. However, a large component of peptide binding is mediated by residues with strong hydrophobic interactions that bind to their respective pockets. If these reflect initial nucleation events they may be upstream of the folding process and not show cooperativity. To test whether the folding hypothesis extends to these anchor interactions, we measured dissociation and affinity to HLA-DR1 of an influenza hemagglutinin-derived peptide with multiple substitutions at major anchor residues. Our results show both negative and positive cooperative effects between hydrophobic pocket interactions. Cooperativity was also observed between hydrophobic pockets and positions with intermediate solvent accessibility, indicating that hydrophobic interactions participate in the overall folding process. These findings point out that predicting the binding potential of epitopes cannot assume additive and independent contributions of the interactions between major MHCII pockets and corresponding peptide side chains.

The clonal composition of the T cell response can affect its ability to mediate infection control or to induce autoimmunity but the mechanisms regulating the responding TCR repertoire remain poorly defined. Here, we immunized mice with wild-type or mutated peptides displaying varying binding half-lives with MHC class II molecules to measure the impact of peptide-MHC class II stability on the clonal composition of the CD4 T cell response. We found that while all peptides elicited similar T cell response size upon immunization, the clonotypic diversity of the CD4 T cell response correlated directly with the half-life of the immunizing peptide. Peptides with short half-lives focused CD4 T cell response toward high affinity clonotypes expressing restricted public TCR, while peptides with longer half-lives broadened CD4 T cell response by recruiting lower affinity clonotypes expressing more diverse TCR. Peptides with longer half-lives did not cause the elimination of high affinity clonotypes, and at a low dose, they also skewed CD4 T cell response toward higher affinity clonotypes. Taken collectively, our results suggest the half-life of peptide-MHC class II complexes is the primary parameter that dictates the clonotypic diversity of the responding CD4 T cell compartment.

Ligand binding is a thermodynamically cooperative process in many biochemical systems characterized by the conformational flexibility of the reactants. However the contribution of conformational entropy to cooperativity of ligation needs to be elucidated. Here we perform kinetic and thermodynamic analyses on a panel of cycle-mutated peptides, derived from influenza H3 HA306-319, interacting with wild type and a mutant HLA-DR. We observe that within a certain range of peptide affinity, this system shows isothermal entropy-enthalpy compensation (iEEC). The incremental increases in conformational entropy measured as disruptive mutations are added in the ligand or receptor are more than sufficient in magnitude to account for the experimentally observed lack of free energy decrease cooperativity. Beyond this affinity range, compensation is not observed, and therefore the ability of the residual interactions to form a stable complex decreases in an exponential fashion. Taken together, our results indicate that cooperativity and iEEC constitute the thermodynamic epiphenomena of the structural fluctuation that accompanies ligand/receptor complex formation in flexible systems. Therefore, ligand binding affinity prediction needs to consider how each source of binding energy contributes synergistically to the folding and kinetic stability of the complex in a process based on the trade-off between structural tightening and restraint of conformational mobility.

BackgroundHLA-DM (DM) mediates exchange of peptides bound to MHC class II (MHCII) during the epitope selection process. Although DM has been shown to have two activities, peptide release and MHC class II refolding, a clear characterization of the mechanism by which DM facilitates peptide exchange has remained elusive.Methodology/Principal FindingsWe have previously demonstrated that peptide binding to and dissociation from MHCII in the absence of DM are cooperative processes, likely related to conformational changes in the peptide-MHCII complex. Here we show that DM promotes peptide release by a non-cooperative process, whereas it enhances cooperative folding of the exchange peptide. Through electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and fluorescence polarization (FP) we show that DM releases prebound peptide very poorly in the absence of a candidate peptide for the exchange process. The affinity and concentration of the candidate peptide are also important for the release of the prebound peptide. Increased fluorescence energy transfer between the prebound and exchange peptides in the presence of DM is evidence for a tetramolecular complex which resolves in favor of the peptide that has superior folding properties.Conclusion/SignificanceThis study shows that both the peptide releasing activity on loaded MHCII and the facilitating of MHCII binding by a candidate exchange peptide are integral to DM mediated epitope selection. The exchange process is initiated only in the presence of candidate peptides, avoiding possible release of a prebound peptide and loss of a potential epitope. In a tetramolecular transitional complex, the candidate peptides are checked for their ability to replace the pre-bound peptide with a geometry that allows the rebinding of the original peptide. Thus, DM promotes a “compare-exchange” sorting algorithm on an available peptide pool. Such a “third party”-mediated mechanism may be generally applicable for diverse ligand recognition in other biological systems.