Tragopogon mirus Ownbey and T. miscellus Ownbey are allopolyploids that formed repeatedly during the past 80 years following the introduction of three diploids ( T. dubius Scop . , T. pratensis L . and T. porrifolius L.) from Europe to western North America. These polyploid species of known parentage are useful for studying the consequences of recent and recurrent polyploidization. We summarize recent analyses of the cytogenetic, genomic and genetic consequences of polyploidy in Tragopogon . Analyses of rDNA ITS (internal transcribed spacer) + ETS (external transcribed spacer) sequence data indicate that the parental diploids are phylogenetically well separated within Tragopogon (a genus of perhaps 150 species), in agreement with isozymic and cpDNA data. Using Southern blot and cloning experiments on tissue from early herbarium collections of T. mirus and T. miscellus (from 1949) to represent the rDNA repeat condition closer to the time of polyploidization than samples collected today, we have demonstrated concerted evolution of rDNA. Concerted evolution is ongoing, but has not proceeded to completion in any polyploid population examined; rDNA repeats of the diploid T. dubius are typically lost or converted in both allopolyploids, including populations of independent origin. Molecular cytogenetic studies employing rDNA probes, as well as centromeric and subtelomeric repeats isolated from Tragopogon , distinguished all chromosomes among the diploid progenitors (2 n = 12). The diploid chromosome complements are additive in both allopolyploids (2 n = 24); there is no evidence of major chromosomal rearrangements in populations of either T. mirus or T. miscellus . cDNA-AFLP display revealed differences in gene expression between T. miscellus and its diploid parents, as well as between populations of T. miscellus of reciprocal origin. Approximately 5% of the genes examined in the allopolyploid populations have been silenced, and an additional 4% exhibit novel gene expression relative to their diploid parents. Some of the differences in gene expression represent maternal or paternal effects. Multiple origins of a polyploid species not only affect patterns of genetic variation in natural populations, but also contribute to differential patterns of gene expression and may therefore play a major role in the long-term evolution of polyploids.

By comparing the expected genome size of the polyploid (based on summing the genome size of species identified as either a parent or most closely related to the diploid progenitors) with the observed genome size, four polyploids showed genome downsizing and five showed increases. There was no discernable pattern in the direction of genome size change with age of polyploids, although with increasing age the amount of genome size change increased. In older polyploids (approx. 4.5 million years old) the increase in genome size was associated with loss of detectable genomic in situ hybridization signal, whereas some hybridization signal was still detected in species exhibiting genome downsizing. The possible significance of these results is discussed.

Summary• Here, we analyze long-term evolution in Nicotiana allopolyploid section Repandae (the closest living diploids are N. sylvestris , the maternal parent, and N. obtusifolia , the paternal parent). We compare data with other more recently formed Nicotiana allopolyploids.• We investigated 35S and 5S nuclear ribosomal DNA (rDNA) chromosomal location and unit divergence. A molecular clock was applied to the Nicotiana phylogenetic tree to determine allopolyploid ages.• N. tabacum and species of Repandae were c . 0.2 and 4.5 Myr old, respectively. In all Repandae species, the numbers of both 35S and 5S rDNA loci were less than the sum of those of the diploid progenitors. Trees based on 5S rDNA spacer sequences indicated units of only the paternal parent.• In recent Nicotiana allopolyploids, the numbers of rDNA loci equal the sum of those of their progenitors. In the Repandae genomes, diploidization is associated with locus loss. Sequence analysis indicates that 35S and 5S units most closely resemble maternal and paternal progenitors, respectively. In Nicotiana , 4.5 Myr of allopolyploid evolution renders genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) unsuitable for the complete resolution of parental genomes.

BackgroundPolyploidy, frequently termed “whole genome duplication”, is a major force in the evolution of many eukaryotes. Indeed, most angiosperm species have undergone at least one round of polyploidy in their evolutionary history. Despite enormous progress in our understanding of many aspects of polyploidy, we essentially have no information about the role of chromosome divergence in the establishment of young polyploid populations. Here we investigate synthetic lines and natural populations of two recently and recurrently formed allotetraploids Tragopogon mirus and T. miscellus (formed within the past 80 years) to assess the role of aberrant meiosis in generating chromosomal/genomic diversity. That diversity is likely important in the formation, establishment and survival of polyploid populations and species.Methodology/Principal FindingsApplications of fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) to natural populations of T. mirus and T. miscellus suggest that chromosomal rearrangements and other chromosomal changes are common in both allotetraploids. We detected extensive chromosomal polymorphism between individuals and populations, including (i) plants monosomic and trisomic for particular chromosomes (perhaps indicating compensatory trisomy), (ii) intergenomic translocations and (iii) variable sizes and expression patterns of individual ribosomal DNA (rDNA) loci. We even observed karyotypic variation among sibling plants. Significantly, translocations, chromosome loss, and meiotic irregularities, including quadrivalent formation, were observed in synthetic (S0 and S1 generations) polyploid lines. Our results not only provide a mechanism for chromosomal variation in natural populations, but also indicate that chromosomal changes occur rapidly following polyploidisation.Conclusions/SignificanceThese data shed new light on previous analyses of genome and transcriptome structures in de novo and establishing polyploid species. Crucially our results highlight the necessity of studying karyotypes in young (<150 years old) polyploid species and synthetic polyploids that resemble natural species. The data also provide insight into the mechanisms that perturb inheritance patterns of genetic markers in synthetic polyploids and populations of young natural polyploid species.

We investigated concerted evolution of rRNA genes in multiple populations of Tragopogon mirus and T. miscellus, two allotetraploids that formed recurrently within the last 80 years following the introduction of three diploids (T. dubius, T. pratensis, and T. porrifolius) from Europe to North America. Using the earliest herbarium specimens of the allotetraploids (1949 and 1953) to represent the genomic condition near the time of polyploidization, we found that the parental rDNA repeats were inherited in roughly equal numbers. In contrast, in most present-day populations of both tetraploids, the rDNA of T. dubius origin is reduced and may occupy as little as 5% of total rDNA in some individuals. However, in two populations of T. mirus the repeats of T. dubius origin outnumber the repeats of the second diploid parent (T. porrifolius), indicating bidirectional concerted evolution within a single species. In plants of T. miscellus having a low rDNA contribution from T. dubius, the rDNA of T. dubius was nonetheless expressed. We have apparently caught homogenization of rDNA repeats (concerted evolution) in the act, although it has not proceeded to completion in any allopolyploid population yet examined. (Ownbey 1950). The introduction of these dipsequences frequently show evidence of homogenizaloid species into the Palouse brought them into close tion, probably caused by processes such as unequal contact, something that rarely occurs in the Old World crossing over and gene conversion, mechanisms collecwhere the diploids are largely allopatric. Using mortively referred to as concerted evolution (Zimmer et al. phology and cytology, Ownbey (1950) demonstrated 1980;Dover 1982). The process of concerted evolution that T. mirus and T. miscellus are allotetraploids (2n ϭ can best be studied in synthetic polyploids or in natural 24) whose diploid (2n ϭ 12) parents are T. dubius and polyploids of clear and very recent ancestry. However, T. porrifolius and T. dubius and T. pratensis, respectively. only a few naturally occurring polyploid species areThe ancestries of both tetraploids were subsequently known to have arisen spontaneously within the past 150 confirmed through flavonoid, isozymic, and DNA studyears: Cardamine schulzii (Urbanska et al. 1997) clones from the polyploids suggested that the parental and P. S. Soltis, personal observation).rDNA types were not present in the allotetraploids in Variable numbers of rRNA genes coding for 18S-5.8S-equal frequency. In fact, T. dubius appeared to be under-26S RNA occur in different plant species (between 1000 represented in both allotetraploid species. To assess and Ͼ50,000 genes), forming multigene families in long whether concerted evolution has been operating in the tandem arrays (Hemleben and Zentgraf 1994). The recently formed allotetraploids, T. mirus and T. miscellus, intragenic (ITS) and intergenic spacers (IGS) associwe investigated the rDNA cistron using cloning, Southated with genic regions often vary among species and ern blots, slot blots, and single-str...

The nuclear cytoplasmic interaction (NCI) hypothesis of genome evolution and speciation in plants states that newly formed allopolyploids pass through a bottleneck of sterility and the fertile plants that emerge are fixed for speciesspecific chromosome translocations. These translocations restore fertility and reduce negative effects of the maternal cytoplasm on an alien paternal genome. Using fluorescent in situ hybridization and genomic in situ hybridization and by reviewing published data, we test the NCI hypothesis using three natural Nicotiana allotetraploids (all 2 n = 4 x = 48, N. arentsii , N. rustica and several genotypes, including a feral plant and cultivars, of N. tabacum (tobacco)). We compare these data with three synthetic tobacco plants (Th37) that are F3 descendent progeny of an allotetraploid formed from Ǩ N. sylvestris (2 n = 24) ¥ ǩ N. tomentosiformis (2 n = 24). No intergenomic translocations were observed in N. arentsii and N. rustica . An analysis of subtelomeric tandem repeats in these allotetraploids and their putative parents shows minimal genetic changes; those that do occur may reflect evolution in the diploids or the polyploids subsequent to allopolyploidy. All natural N. tabacum genotypes have intergenomic translocations. This may reflect a large 'genomic-shock' generated by allopolyploidy involving widely diverged parental species. Two of three synthetic tobacco plants had a translocation similar to that found in all cultivars of tobacco. This translocation may be significant in tobacco fertility and may have been fixed early in tobacco's evolution. But it is lacking in the feral tobacco, which might indicate a polyphyletic origin or early divergence from all cultivars examined. Overall, only in tobacco is there any evidence that NCI may have influenced genome evolution, and here further data are required to verify chromosome identity.

We used next generation sequencing to characterize and compare the genomes of the recently derived allotetraploid, Nicotiana tabacum (<200,000 years old), with its diploid progenitors, Nicotiana sylvestris (maternal, S-genome donor), and Nicotiana tomentosiformis (paternal, T-genome donor). Analysis of 14,634 repetitive DNA sequences in the genomes of the progenitor species and N. tabacum reveal all major types of retroelements found in angiosperms (genome proportions range between 17-22.5% and 2.3-3.5% for Ty3-gypsy elements and Ty1-copia elements, respectively). The diploid N. sylvestris genome exhibits evidence of recent bursts of sequence amplification and/or homogenization, whereas the genome of N. tomentosiformis lacks this signature and has considerably fewer homogenous repeats. In the derived allotetraploid N. tabacum, there is evidence of genome downsizing and sequences loss across most repeat types. This is particularly evident amongst the Ty3-gypsy retroelements in which all families identified are underrepresented in N. tabacum, as is 35S ribosomal DNA. Analysis of all repetitive DNA sequences indicates the T-genome of N. tabacum has experienced greater sequence loss than the S-genome, revealing preferential loss of paternally derived repetitive DNAs at a genome-wide level. Thus, the three genomes of N. sylvestris, N. tomentosiformis, and N. tabacum have experienced different evolutionary trajectories, with genomes that are dynamic, stable, and downsized, respectively.

We review and extend data showing concerted evolution of parental 18-5.8-26S nuclear ribosomal DNA (18-26S rDNA) gene families in three natural Nicotiana allotetraploids ( N. tabacum , N. rustica and N. arentsii , each 2 n = 4 x = 48) and one synthetic N. tabacum line (Th37, Ǩ N. sylvestris (2 n = 24) ¥ ǩ N. tomentosiformis (2 n = 24)). The origin of the gene families was analysed by sequence polymorphisms in the intergenic spacer (IGS) region and the number of chromosomal loci by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). FISH revealed that the number and locations of 18-26S rDNA in the natural allopolyploids was the sum of those found in the diploid progenitors. However, the rDNA restriction patterns showed polymorphisms in the IGS that were not additive, suggesting that parental rDNA clusters were partially ( N. tabacum, N. rustica ) or completely ( N. arentsii ) overwritten by hybrid-specific units. Thus the Nicotiana allotetraploids show evidence of concerted evolution, including both intralocus and interlocus gene conversion. A feral N. tabacum collected in Bolivia had a higher proportion of unconverted parental rDNA units than cultivated tobacco varieties, suggesting either that rDNA homogenization is accelerated by inbreeding or multiple origins of tobacco. There is no evidence for the elimination of N. sylvestris-derived rDNA units in the synthetic Th37 tobacco line as occurred in natural tobacco, although several novel rDNA unit variants were found in most but not all the hybrid plants. Factors that may control the occurrence and extent of rDNA homogenization are discussed for allopolyploids in Nicotiana and other taxa.