We present the first direct comparative evaluation of an antibody-drug conjugate and of a small molecule-drug conjugate for cancer therapy, using chemically defined products which bind with high-affinity to carbonic anhydrase IX, a marker of tumor hypoxia and of renal cell carcinoma.

In most cases, cytotoxic drugs do not preferentially accumulate at the tumor site, causing unwanted toxicities and preventing dose escalation to therapeutically active regimens. Here, we show that acetazolamide derivatives, which bind to carbonic anhydrase IX (CAIX) on the surface of kidney cancer cells, selectively deliver payloads at the site of disease, sparing normal organs. Biodistribution studies, performed in tumor-bearing mice with acetazolamide derivatives bearing a technetium-99m chelator complex or a red fluorophore as payload, revealed a preferential tumor accumulation of the compound at doses up to 560 nmol/Kg. The percentage of injected dose per gram in the tumor was dose-dependent and revealed optimal tumor:organ ratios at 140 nmol/Kg, with a tumor:blood ratio of 80:1 at 6 h. Acetazolamide, coupled to potent cytotoxic drugs via a dipeptide linker, exhibited a potent antitumor activity in nude mice bearing SKRC-52 renal cell carcinomas, while drug derivatives devoid of the acetazolamide moiety did not exhibit any detectable anticancer activity at the same doses. The observation of tumor regression with a noninternalizing ligand and with different cytotoxic moieties (MMAE and PNU-159682) indicates a general mechanism of action, based on the selective accumulation of the product on tumor cells, followed by the extracellular proteolytic release of the cytotoxic payload at the neoplastic site and the subsequent drug internalization into tumor cells. Acetazolamide-based drug conjugates may represent a promising class of targeted agents for the treatment of metastatic kidney cancer, as the majority of human clear cell renal cell carcinomas are strongly positive for CAIX.

The covalent conjugation of potent cytotoxic agents to either macromolecular carriers or small molecules represents a well‐known approach to increase the therapeutic index of these drugs, thus improving treatment efficacy and minimizing side effects. In general, cytotoxic activity is displayed only upon cleavage of a specific chemical bond (linker) that connects the drug to the carrier. The perfect balance between the linker stability and its selective cleavage represents the key for success in these therapeutic approaches and the chemical toolbox to reach this goal is continuously expanding. In this Review article, we highlight recent advances on the different modalities to promote the selective release of cytotoxic agents, either by exploiting specific hallmarks of the tumor microenvironment (e.g. pH, enzyme expression) or by the application of external triggers (e.g. light and bioorthogonal reactions).

Two small-molecule-drug conjugates (SMDCs, 6 and 7) featuring lysosomally cleavable linkers (namely the Val-Ala and Phe-Lys peptide sequences) were synthesized by conjugation of the αvβ3-integrin ligand cyclo[DKP-RGD]-CH2NH2 (2) to the anticancer drug paclitaxel (PTX). A third cyclo[DKP-RGD]-PTX conjugate with a nonpeptide "uncleavable" linker (8) was also synthesized to be tested as a negative control. These three SMDCs were able to inhibit biotinylated vitronectin binding to the purified αVβ3-integrin receptor at nanomolar concentrations and showed good stability at pH 7.4 and pH 5.5. Cleavage of the two peptide linkers was observed in the presence of lysosomal enzymes, whereas conjugate 8, which possesses a nonpeptide "uncleavable" linker, remained intact under these conditions. The antiproliferative activities of the conjugates were evaluated against two isogenic cell lines expressing the integrin receptor at different levels: the acute lymphoblastic leukemia cell line CCRF-CEM (αVβ3-) and its subclone CCRF-CEM αVβ3 (αVβ3+). Fairly effective integrin targeting was displayed by the cyclo[DKP-RGD]-Val-Ala-PTX conjugate (6), which was found to differentially inhibit proliferation in antigen-positive CCRF-CEM αVβ3 versus antigen-negative isogenic CCRF-CEM cells. The total lack of activity displayed by the "uncleavable" cyclo[DKP-RGD]-PTX conjugate (8) clearly demonstrates the importance of the peptide linker for achieving the selective release of the cytotoxic payload.

The discovery of protein ligands,capable of forming ar eversible covalent bond with amino acid residues on ap rotein target of interest, may represent ag eneral strategy for the discovery of potent small-molecule inhibitors.W e analyzed the ability of different aromatic aldehydes to form imines by reaction with lysine using 1 HNMR techniques.2 -Hydroxybenzaldehyde derivatives were found to efficiently form imines in the millimolar concentration range.T hese benzaldehyde derivatives could increase the binding affinity of protein ligands towards the cognate protein target. Affinity maturation was achieved not only by displaying ligand and aldehyde moieties on two complementary locked nucleic acid strands but also by incorporating the binding fragments in as ingle small-molecule ligand. The affinity gain was only observed when lysine residues were accessible in the immediate surroundings of the ligand-binding site and could be abrogated by quenching with amolar excess of hydroxylamine. Conflict of interestD.N. is ac o-founder and shareholder of Philogen (www.philogen.com), aSwiss-Italian Biotech company that operates in the field of DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries.J .S.isaboard member of Philochem AG (www.philochem.ch).

Small molecule-drug conjugates (SMDCs) are increasingly being considered as an alternative to antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) for the selective delivery of anticancer agents to the tumor site, sparing normal tissues. Carbonic anhydrase IX (CAIX) is a membrane-bound enzyme, which is over-expressed in the majority of renal cell carcinomas and which can be efficiently targeted in vivo, using charged derivatives of acetazolamide, a small heteroaromatic sulfonamide. Here, we show that SMDC products, obtained by the coupling of acetazolamide with monomethyl auristatin E (MMAE) using dipeptide linkers, display a potent anti-tumoral activity in mice bearing xenografted SKRC-52 renal cell carcinomas. A comparative evaluation of four dipeptides revealed that SMDCs featuring valine-citrulline and valine-alanine linkers exhibited greater serum stability and superior therapeutic activity, compared to the counterparts with valine-lysine or valinearginine linkers. The most active products substantially inhibited tumor growth over a prolonged period of time, in a tumor model for which sunitinib and sorafenib do not display therapeutic activity. However, complete tumor eradication was not possible even after ten intravenous injection. Macroscopic near-infrared imaging procedures confirmed that ligands had not lost the ability to selectively localize at the tumor site at the end of therapy and that the neoplastic masses continued to express CAIX. The findings are of mechanistic and of therapeutic significance, since CAIX is a non-internalizing membrane-associated antigen, which can be considered for targeted drug delivery applications in kidney cancer patients.

Self‐immolative (SI) spacers are sophisticated chemical constructs designed for molecular delivery or material degradation. We describe herein a (S)‐2‐(aminomethyl)pyrrolidine SI spacer that is able to release different types of anticancer drugs (possessing either a phenolic or secondary and tertiary hydroxyl groups) through a fast cyclization mechanism involving carbamate cleavage. The high efficiency of drug release obtained with this spacer was found to be beneficial for the in vitro cytotoxic activity of protease‐sensitive prodrugs, compared with a commonly used spacer of the same class. These findings expand the repertoire of degradation machineries and are instrumental for the future development of highly efficient delivery platforms.

Antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) represent an attractive class of biopharmaceutical agents, with the potential to selectively deliver potent cytotoxic agents to tumors. It is generally assumed that ADC products should preferably bind and internalize into cancer cells in order to liberate their toxic payload, but a growing body of evidence indicates that also ADCs based on noninternalizing antibodies may be potently active. In this Communication, we investigated dipeptide-based linkers (frequently used for internalizing ADC products) in the context of the noninternalizing F16 antibody, specific to a splice isoform of tenascin-C. Using monomethyl auristatin E (MMAE) as potent cytotoxic drug, we observed that a single amino acid substitution of the Val-Cit dipeptide linker can substantially modulate the in vivo stability of the corresponding ADC products, as well as the anticancer activity in mice bearing the human epidermoid A431 carcinoma. In these settings, the linker based on the Val-Ala dipeptide exhibited better performances, compared to Val-Cit, Val-Lys, and Val-Arg analogues. Mass spectrometric analysis revealed that the four linkers displayed not only different stability in vivo but also differences in cleavage sites. Moreover, the absence of anticancer activity for a F16-MMAE conjugate featuring a noncleavable linker indicated that drug release modalities, based on proteolytic degradation of the immunoglobulin moiety, cannot be exploited with noninternalizing antibodies. ADC products based on the noninternalizing F16 antibody may be useful for the treatment of several human malignancies, as the cognate antigen is abundantly expressed in the extracellular matrix of several tumors, while being virtually undetectable in most normal adult tissues.