A phylogenetic hypothesis for the patellid limpets is reconstructed by cladistic analysis of morphological characters from 37 species, representing all but one of the living members of the family. Characters included in the analysis are derived from shell shape and microstructure, headfoot and pallial complex, radula and sperm. The species fall into four clades, providing the basis for a new phylogenetic classification into four monophyletic genera:
Helcion
(four species; southern Africa),
Cymbula
(eight species; southern Africa, eastern Atlantic, southern Indian Ocean),
Scutellastra
(17 species; southern and southwestern Africa, Australia, Indo–West Pacific, Eastern Pacific) and
Patella
(nine species; northeastern Atlantic and Mediterranean). The analysis suggests sister–group relationships between
Helcion
and
Cymbula
, and between
Scutellastra
and
Patella
. In combination with present–day patterns of geographical distribution, this phylogenetic hypothesis is used to discuss the historical biogeography of the Patellidae.
Scutellastra
may have originated in southern Africa and dispersed across the Pacific, or alternatively may be a primitively Tethyan group. Both
Helcion
and
Cymbula
appear to have originated in southern Africa, but three
Cymbula
species have dispersed respectively to northwest Africa, St Helena and the southern Indian Ocean. The patellids of the northeastern Atlantic form a single clade,
Patella
(including
P. pellucida
), which may have arrived by northward dispersal of an ancestor from southern Africa, or possibly by vicariance of a widespread ancestral Tethyan distribution. The known fossil record of patellids is too fragmentary to permit choice between these alternatives.
The mature sperm of three species of the subfamily Mytilinae (Choromytilus meridionalis, Mytilus galloprovincialis, Aulacomya ater) are of the primitive type. The sperm are 50–55 μm long, with a distinct head, midpiece of four to six mitochondria, and tail. In all three species the acrosome is in the form of an elongated hollow cone; yet each has its own characteristic morphology, indicating that sperm ultrastructure can be used as an aid to bivalve identification. A reexamination and comparison of the acrosomes from five subclasses of bivalve show that each subclass has an acrosome with a unique form. The process of spermatogenesis is similar in all three species; early spermatogonia are located close to the wall of the germinal follicle, and successive stages are displaced toward the center. Observations support the theories of acrosome formation by coalescence of numerous proacrosomal vesicles and of reduction in mitochondrial number by mitochondrial fusion.
Light and transmission electron microscopy of the spermatozoa and spermatogenesis of 16 species (in three genera, Patella, Helcion, Cellana) of patellid limpet have shown that head lengths of the sperm range from 3 to 13 μm, and each species has a sperm with a unique morphology, indicating that the spermatozoa can be used as a taxonomic character. Although spermatozoon structure is species specific, five types can be recognized, based on the size, shape, and structure of the nucleus and acrosome. The occurrence of five morphological types of sperm, one of which (Cellana capensis) is particularly different from other patellids, suggests that the taxonomy of the family Patellidae be re-examined. The morphological changes that occur during spermatogenesis are very similar in all species, although two patterns of chromatin condensation are found. Those species with sperm that have short squat nuclei (length:breadth < 3.5:1) have a granular pattern of condensation. Species with sperm that have more elongate nuclei (length:breadth > 5:1) have an initial granular phase followed by the formation of chromatin fibrils. These fibrils become organized along the long axis of the elongating nucleus. The absence of a manchette suggests that nuclear elongation is brought about from within the nucleus.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.