The authors describe the discovery of anti-mycobacterial compounds through identifying mechanistically diverse inhibitors of the essential Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) enzyme, pantothenate kinase (CoaA). Target-driven drug discovery technologies often work with purified enzymes, and inhibitors thus discovered may not optimally inhibit the form of the target enzyme predominant in the bacterial cell or may not be available at the desired concentration. Therefore, in addition to addressing entry or efflux issues, inhibitors with diverse mechanisms of inhibition (MoI) could be prioritized before hit-to-lead optimization. The authors describe a high-throughput assay based on protein thermal melting to screen large numbers of compounds for hits with diverse MoI. Following high-throughput screening for Mtb CoaA enzyme inhibitors, a concentration-dependent increase in protein thermal stability was used to identify true binders, and the degree of enhancement or reduction in thermal stability in the presence of substrate was used to classify inhibitors as competitive or non/uncompetitive. The thermal shift-based MoI assay could be adapted to screen hundreds of compounds in a single experiment as compared to traditional biochemical approaches for MoI determination. This MoI was confirmed through mechanistic studies that estimated K(ie) and K(ies) for representative compounds and through nuclear magnetic resonance-based ligand displacement assays.
The successful discovery and subsequent development of small molecule inhibitors of drug targets relies on the establishment of robust, cost-effective, quantitative, and physiologically relevant in vitro assays that can support prolonged screening and optimization campaigns. The current study illustrates the process of developing and validating an enzymatic assay for the discovery of small molecule inhibitors using alkaline phosphatase from bovine intestine as model target. The assay development workflow includes an initial phase of optimization of assay materials, reagents, and conditions, continues with a process of miniaturization and automation, and concludes with validation by quantitative measurement of assay performance and signal variability. The assay is further evaluated for dose–response and mechanism-of-action studies required to support structure–activity-relationship studies. Emphasis is placed on the most critical aspects of assay optimization and other relevant considerations, including the technology, assay materials, buffer constituents, reaction conditions, liquid handling equipment, analytical instrumentation, and quantitative assessments. Examples of bottlenecks encountered during assay development and strategies to address them are provided.
Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) DNA gyrase ATPase was the target of a tuberculosis drug discovery program. The low specific activity of the Mtb ATPase prompted the use of Mycobacterium smegmatis (Msm) enzyme as a surrogate for lead generation, since it had 20-fold higher activity. Addition of GyrA or DNA did not significantly increase the activity of the Msm GyrB ATPase, and an assay was developed using GyrB alone. Inhibition of the Msm ATPase correlated well with inhibition of Mtb DNA gyrase supercoiling across three chemical scaffolds, justifying its use. As the IC50 of compounds approached the enzyme concentration, surrogate assays were used to estimate potencies (e.g., the shift in thermal melt of Mtb GyrB, which correlated well with IC(50)s >10 nM). Analysis using the Morrison equation enabled determination of K(i)(app)s in the sub-nanomolar range. Surface plasmon resonance was used to confirm these IC(50)s and measure the K ds of binding, but a fragment of Mtb GyrB had to be used. Across three scaffolds, the dissociation half life, t1/2, of the inhibitor-target complex was ≤ 8 min. This toolkit of assays was developed to track the potency of enzyme inhibition and guide the chemistry for progression of compounds in a lead identification program.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.